Open tcllib tickets: Feature requests

Triage of all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15. Each ticket was checked against tcllib trunk on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5, using local servers for the network modules and a Windows 11 VM for Windows-only tickets. Outdated, superseded, duplicate and misfiled tickets are listed separately. Rows marked patch link to a prototype fix with a regression test (147 in all, in tcllib-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-16.

Open feature requests 129

⬜c0046f29cd2026Additional index on main documentation pageRFE-OPEN (feasible: a flat alphabetical list of packages/manpages would be generated in support/devel/sak/doc/doc_auto.tcl)

Open ticket c0046f29cd · RFE · (unused) · filed 2026-08-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a flat alphabetical list of packages/manpages would be generated in support/devel/sak/doc/doc_auto.tcl)

  • Module sak doc / embedded/md/toc.md
  • Tested toc.md has "By Categories" and "By Type" (Applications, plus Modules sorted by module directory name). Packages whose module directory has a different name (e.g. doctools::toc under doctools2toc) are hard to find without a flat list.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE; touches generated docs)
  • Suggested action keep open (related to 685345eb4d)
  • Suggested ticket comment The ToC has a by-module list (By Type > Modules), but no flat alphabetical list of package names. Generating one in sak's doc tooling looks feasible.
⬜b192bd41492026stringprep is based on RFC 3454 (2002) not on its successor 8264 (2017)RFE-OPEN (large: PRECIS (RFC 8264) is a different framework, with IdentifierClass/FreeformClass, derived properties from Unicode data and profiles …

Open ticket b192bd4149 · RFE · stringprep · filed 2026-02-10

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (large: PRECIS (RFC 8264) is a different framework, with IdentifierClass/FreeformClass, derived properties from Unicode data and profiles like RFC 8265/8266)

  • Module stringprep 1.0.3
  • Tested code inspection
  • Cause n/a. RFC 3454 is still the base for profiles that are in use (nameprep/IDNA2003, SASLprep RFC 4013, which the module already registers), so the existing package stays valid.
  • Prototype none (new package-sized work)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE. A PRECIS implementation would be a new package, not a change to stringprep.
  • Suggested ticket comment PRECIS (RFC 8264) is a separate framework, not a revision of stringprep's tables. It would best be a new package next to stringprep, which is still needed for SASLprep/IDNA2003.
⬜e15c2a7ce12026json::write proposals: tdom formatting, true, false, nullRFE-OPEN (implemented on branch e15c2a7c-json-write-hao, tip d6d4f017f5, not merged)

Open ticket e15c2a7ce1 · RFE · json :: write · filed 2026-02-02

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (implemented on branch e15c2a7c-json-write-hao, tip d6d4f017f5, not merged)

  • Module json::write 1.0.5 on trunk (1.1.0 on the branch)
  • Tested ran the branch's json_write.test with tclsh9.1 and tclsh8.6: 20/20 pass. tdom is not installed here, so only the non-tdom path ran. Trunk has not touched the json_write.* files or pkgIndex.tcl since the branch point (1e1136edbe), so the merge is clean.
  • Cause n/a. Review notes on the branch:
    • two tests are both named json-write-6.2. The last one (string-null default) should be 6.4.
    • string-null maps the empty string to null, so code that uses it cannot write an empty JSON string. This is documented, but it is a design choice the maintainer should accept explicitly.
    • in tdom mode \x7f is not escaped. That is valid JSON, and test 4.0 adjusts its expected result for it.
  • Prototype none (the work is already on the branch)
  • Suggested action fix the duplicate test name, then review and merge the branch.
  • Suggested ticket comment The branch passes its tests on 9.1 and 8.6 (without tdom) and merges cleanly into trunk. One nit: the test name json-write-6.2 is used twice.
⬜6506b959a52026and header and footer arguments for mkdoc applicationRFE-OPEN (feasible and small). mkdoc only has -css. For now, #' #include "file.md" can serve as a per-file header/footer workaround. The report…

Open ticket 6506b959a5 · Bug · A Category Is Missing · filed 2026-01-28

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible and small). mkdoc only has -css. For now, #' #include "file.md" can serve as a per-file header/footer workaround. The reporter is the mkdoc author, and oehhar invited him to contribute.

  • Module mkdoc 0.7.2 (modules/mkdoc/mkdoc.tcl, apps/mkdoc)
  • Tested code read only
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open, waiting for a contribution from the author
  • Suggested ticket comment (none needed, Harald already replied)
⬜bfb02104672025json2dict not documented and has dead codeRFE-OPEN (trivial. Maintainer decision: drop the dead block, or deprecate/remove the three undocumented helpers)

Open ticket bfb0210467 · RFE · json · filed 2025-10-29

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (trivial. Maintainer decision: drop the dead block, or deprecate/remove the three undocumented helpers)

  • Module json 1.3.6 (modules/json/json.tcl)
  • Tested code review on trunk. grep over all of tcllib: json::dict2json, json::list2json and json::string2json have no callers and no docs.
  • Cause json.tcl:252-279. The title says json2dict, but the ticket means dict2json. Its if {0 && ...} quoting block has been dead since 2006 (0de9029772). The helpers also produce invalid JSON for keys or strings that contain " or \, because string2json does no escaping.
  • Prototype none (RFE. Removing or deprecating API is the maintainer's call)
  • Suggested action keep open for a maintainer decision. Simplest fix: delete the dead if and say in a comment that json::write is the supported writer.
  • Suggested ticket comment The three helpers dict2json/list2json/string2json are undocumented, nothing in tcllib uses them, and they do no escaping. Suggest removing the dead if {0 && ...} block now and deprecating the helpers in favour of json::write.
⬜3438f804e42025Add progress bar to the tar packageRFE-OPEN (feasible, code supplied; should use {*}$progress instead of eval [concat ...], and needs docs and a test)

Open ticket 3438f804e4 · RFE · tar · filed 2025-10-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, code supplied; should use {*}$progress instead of eval [concat ...], and needs docs and a test)

  • Module tar 0.15
  • Tested code review. create has no progress option on trunk.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Reasonable addition. The callback should be invoked as a command prefix ({*}$cmd total done), and add/untar may want the same option.
⬜fbf8d906402024New alignment tag for numeric valuesRFE-OPEN (patch not applied; justify still accepts only left/right/center)

Open ticket fbf8d90640 · Patch · report · filed 2024-05-08

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (patch not applied; justify still accepts only left/right/center)

  • Module report 0.5
  • Tested code read of report.tcl:_justify and FormatCell
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none. The inline patch is reversed and against 1.20. Its design is debatable (non-numeric cells, including the title row, get centered rather than the column's own alignment) and it lacks docs and tests.
  • Suggested action keep open; ask for a version where non-numeric cells fall back to left (or a configurable alignment), plus a report.man update
  • Suggested ticket comment Not applied yet. The idea is reasonable, but non-numeric cells (including headers) are centered by the patch; a version with a clear fallback, docs and a test would be easier to merge.
⬜4a80a491182024New modes for nonterminalsRFE-OPEN (new nonterminal modes; overlaps with eb8c1e69ba "prune")

Open ticket 4a80a49118 · RFE · pt (parsetools) · filed 2024-01-24

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (new nonterminal modes; overlaps with eb8c1e69ba "prune")

  • Module pt
  • Tested code read; modes are still value/leaf/void
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (changes the meta grammar, container, all engines and generators)
  • Suggested action keep open; link to eb8c1e69ba
  • Suggested ticket comment Still open; related to eb8c1e69ba. It needs support across all pt engines and generators.
⬜aa6f1708182024Augmented and Active grammarsRFE-OPEN (design proposal: extra per-nonterminal data and grammar-embedded AST actions; feasible, but it is a design task)

Open ticket aa6f170818 · RFE · pt (parsetools) · filed 2024-01-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (design proposal: extra per-nonterminal data and grammar-embedded AST actions; feasible, but it is a design task)

  • Module pt
  • Tested code read; not implemented
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (API design)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still open; this needs a design decision on the grammar serialization extension before implementation.
⬜dd79d8540e2024More documentation: How to write your grammarRFE-OPEN (docs request; the suggested text is largely in the ticket and could become a new pt "grammar design tips" page)

Open ticket dd79d8540e · RFE · pt (parsetools) · filed 2024-01-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (docs request; the suggested text is largely in the ticket and could become a new pt "grammar design tips" page)

  • Module pt docs
  • Tested no such page exists in modules/pt/*.man
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action keep open (docs task)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still wanted; the recommendations in this ticket could be turned into a new pt manpage.
⬜27bed812fa2023::tar::create - Relative path to specific directoryRFE-OPEN (feasible: e.g. a -directory dir option for create/add that resolves files relative to dir and stores the relative names, like tar -C;…

Open ticket 27bed812fa · Bug · tar · filed 2023-04-25

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: e.g. a -directory dir option for create/add that resolves files relative to dir and stores the relative names, like tar -C; about 15 lines plus docs)

  • Module tar 0.15
  • Tested code review. create accepts only -dereference/-chan/-gzip. add -prefix prepends a string but cannot strip one.
  • Prototype none (RFE, API design)
  • Suggested action keep open (retype to RFE)
  • Suggested ticket comment Valid request: there is no thread-safe way to store paths relative to a base directory. A -directory option (or separate on-disk path and archive name) for create/add would cover it.
⬜294ebffb632022add multicast DNS capabilitiesRFE-OPEN (feasible and small). The second variant, which joins the group automatically when the nameserver is a multicast address, avoids hard-code…

Open ticket 294ebffb63 · Patch · dns · filed 2022-05-25

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible and small). The second variant, which joins the group automatically when the nameserver is a multicast address, avoids hard-coded values. It needs tcludp and package require ip, but the dns module already uses ip. A full mDNS client would also need to collect several answers per query, which the current single-reply design does not do.

  • Module dns 1.6.1
  • Tested not tested (no tcludp, multicast network)
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open; maintainer decision
  • Suggested ticket comment Still wanted? The auto-join variant is small. Note that dns::resolve keeps only the first reply, while mDNS usually returns several.
⬜f3b221e01e2022irc lib misses elementsRFE-OPEN (TLS support. picoirc 0.14.1 in the same module already supports ircs:// via tls::socket.)

Open ticket f3b221e01e · Bug · irc · filed 2022-05-24

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (TLS support. picoirc 0.14.1 in the same module already supports ircs:// via tls::socket.)

  • Module irc 0.8.0 (modules/irc/irc.tcl)
  • Tested code read. cmd-connect uses a plain socket $host $port with no hook to substitute a TLS socket.
  • Cause irc.tcl:cmd-connect
  • Prototype none (RFE; would need a socketcmd config option or similar, untestable without a TLS IRC server)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE. Suggest adding a configurable socket command (e.g. config socketcmd ::tls::socket).
  • Suggested ticket comment irc::connection still connects with a plain socket only. picoirc already supports ircs:// via tls. A configurable socket command for irc would be a small addition.
⬜e718d41c5d2022include tmdoc literate programming package into tcllibRFE-OPEN (feasible, but needs the author to contribute and maintain it; no activity since 2022)

Open ticket e718d41c5d · RFE · (unused) · filed 2022-05-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, but needs the author to contribute and maintain it; no activity since 2022)

  • Module none (external, github mittelmark/tmdoc)
  • Tested none
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action maintainers' decision: ask the author for a contribution branch, or close
  • Suggested ticket comment Is the author still interested in contributing tmdoc as a tcllib module (code, .man, tests)? Otherwise this will be closed.
⬜dac0c417ef2022Protecting against attacks and general improvementsRFE-OPEN (Priority 1 is largely done: md4, md5, sha1, sha256, ripemd128/160, crc32, cksum, sum and crc16 all accept --. A single data argument ca…

Open ticket dac0c417ef · Bug · (unused) · filed 2022-04-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (Priority 1 is largely done: md4, md5, sha1, sha256, ripemd128/160, crc32, cksum, sum and crc16 all accept --. A single data argument cannot trigger -file/-filename. Priority 2, option consistency (-hex vs -format), is an API-wide RFE)

  • Module md4, md5, sha1/sha256, ripemd, crc (trunk)
  • Tested 9.1, each hash with -- "-file /etc/passwd" (hashes the string) and with "-hex", "-filename" etc. as the only argument. md4/md5/ripemd/crc32 reject an option-like single data argument with "wrong # args" (no file access). sha1/sha256 hash it.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (broad API redesign)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE for option consistency, or close since the security part is covered by --
  • Suggested ticket comment All the hash and crc commands now accept --. Data starting with "-" can't make them read a file. Making -hex/-format consistent across modules is still open as an RFE.
⬜e056ba31162021Gamblers_Ruin_Expectation as Probability in TCLLIB mathRFE-OPEN (trivial one-liner 1 - p**n; Arjen (2022) wanted to look at the general gambler's-ruin problem instead; nothing done since)

Open ticket e056ba3116 · Patch · math :: special · filed 2021-09-19

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (trivial one-liner 1 - p**n; Arjen (2022) wanted to look at the general gambler's-ruin problem instead; nothing done since)

  • Module math (math::special / math::probopt etc.); nothing named gambler/ruin on trunk
  • Tested grep of modules/math on trunk; no implementation
  • Cause n/a (feature request)
  • Prototype none (RFE, maintainer decision on scope)
  • Suggested action Arjen to decide; likely close as "won't fix", since the proposed formula is just 1-p**n and isn't a gambler's-ruin computation
  • Suggested ticket comment Nothing like this is in math on trunk. The proposed proc only computes 1-p**n, so it is not really worth a package entry; please reopen with the full gambler's-ruin formulas if they are still wanted.
⬜5af6381a8b2021Quadratic Equation Solution, 2 reals from Muller's methodRFE-OPEN (feasible, small, low value)

Open ticket 5af6381a8b · Patch · math · filed 2021-07-03

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, small, low value)

  • Module math (no quadratic solver exists; math::polynomials has no root finding)
  • Tested grep of modules/math. The attachment submission.txt (ae66d4ee…) is not in the repository db, so its code could not be read.
  • Prototype none (RFE; the proposed option-flag API (1/2/3) does not fit tcllib style)
  • Suggested action owner (Arjen) to decide; if wanted, a math::polynomials::roots for degree ≤ 2 (real and complex, numerically stable) would be cleaner. Otherwise reject.
  • Suggested ticket comment (none)
⬜1985a342552021add truncate method to some virtchan impsRFE-OPEN (feasible; branch virtchan-1985a34255 has aku's implementation from 2022-04-12, not merged). Refchan truncate exists only in Tcl 9.0+. O…

Open ticket 1985a34255 · RFE · virtchannel base · filed 2021-04-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible; branch virtchan-1985a34255 has aku's implementation from 2022-04-12, not merged). Refchan truncate exists only in Tcl 9.0+. On 8.6 tip, a handler that lists truncate is rejected with bad method "truncate". So the method must be added only on Tcl 9, or the packages must require 9; the branch instead bumps everything to require 8.6, which does not help.

  • Module virtchannel_base (tcl::chan::memchan 1.0.5, string 1.0.4, variable 1.0.5, ...)
  • Tested a small refchan that lists truncate, with chan truncate: works on 9.1, fails at chan create on 8.6.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (an implementation already exists in the branch; it needs conditionalising for Tcl 8.6, which is a design decision)
  • Suggested action keep open. Rebase the branch and add the method only when package vsatisfies [info patchlevel] 9.
  • Suggested ticket comment Refchan truncate only exists in Tcl 9.0+ (8.6 rejects the method name), so the branch needs to add the method only on 9.x before it can be merged.
⬜b0c1aa2c982021Extend the test suite for math::decimalRFE-OPEN (decimal.test still has only 2 tests)

Open ticket b0c1aa2c98 · Bug · math · filed 2021-03-14

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (decimal.test still has only 2 tests)

  • Module math, math::decimal 1.0.5
  • Tested decimal.test, 2 tests (9.1, 8.6).
  • Prototype none. The a316389e99 prototype adds 10 fromstr tests, a start.
  • Suggested action keep open (owner Arjen)
  • Suggested ticket comment (none)
⬜148eb6d8492019Add a "package require tcllib" type "metapackage"RFE-OPEN (feasible: the installer could write a tcllib package that provides the release version and the list of packages. sak already knows the …

Open ticket 148eb6d849 · RFE · None · filed 2019-06-26

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: the installer could write a tcllib package that provides the release version and the list of packages. sak already knows the package list.)

  • Module n/a (installer/packaging)
  • Tested nothing provides a tcllib package (only tcllibc and tcllib::testutils).
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open; needs a maintainer decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available. A generated tcllib package reporting the release version and contained packages seems feasible from sak's package list.
⬜3fff267fc42018ftp with explicit tlsRFE-OPEN (no TLS support in ftp on trunk; patch not reviewable locally)

Open ticket 3fff267fc4 · Patch · ftp · filed 2018-11-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (no TLS support in ftp on trunk; patch not reviewable locally)

  • Module ftp 2.4.14
  • Tested grep of ftp.tcl/ftp.man: no AUTH TLS/PBSZ/PROT and no tls hook. The attachment diff.txt (e6a8c060…) is missing from the local repository clone, so the patch could not be checked.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (attachment unavailable; feature)
  • Suggested action keep open; a human should read diff.txt on the web. Related: 781246ffff (open RFE "Support SSL connections in FTP package").
  • Suggested ticket comment (none until the patch is reviewed) Possibly link to [781246].
⬜59c60db9612018cmdline - not work correctly when options without dash prefix appear before options with dashRFE-OPEN (POSIX-style behaviour by design; GNU-style permutation would be a new opt-in)

Open ticket 59c60db961 · Bug · cmdline · filed 2018-10-18

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (POSIX-style behaviour by design; GNU-style permutation would be a new opt-in)

  • Module cmdline 1.5.3
  • Tested getoptions with argv fileA -f v stops at fileA and leaves fileA -f v (9.1)
  • Cause getKnownOpt stops at the first non-option, like POSIX getopt (and like -- handling). Permuting by default would break scripts that pass option-like words after operands.
  • Prototype none (behaviour change / new option)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE, or close as Works as Designed
  • Suggested ticket comment cmdline follows POSIX getopt: option processing stops at the first operand. GNU permutation would have to be opt-in.
⬜67b7bafb202018::math::combined_market_rateRFE-OPEN (same planned "market" package as e6b2685388, never created; the formula N/sum(1/x) is just the harmonic mean)

Open ticket 67b7bafb20 · Patch · math :: statistics · filed 2018-09-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (same planned "market" package as e6b2685388, never created; the formula N/sum(1/x) is just the harmonic mean)

  • Module math::statistics 1.6.1 (no such proc)
  • Tested grep modules/math: no combined_market_rate
  • Cause n/a. Note: the proposed code returns 0 for a single argument and when the first argument is 0, which is questionable.
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action decide together with e6b2685388; likely close (it is just a harmonic mean)
  • Suggested ticket comment This is the harmonic mean of the rates. It has not been added, and the "market" package from e6b2685388 was never created.
⬜e6b26853882018proportional weighted sharesRFE-OPEN (Arjen planned a separate "market" package in 2019, never created)

Open ticket e6b2685388 · Patch · math :: statistics · filed 2018-08-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (Arjen planned a separate "market" package in 2019, never created)

  • Module math::statistics 1.6.1 (no such proc; no "market" package exists)
  • Tested grep of modules/math for proportional/weighted shares: nothing
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (new package / maintainer decision)
  • Suggested action Arjen to decide whether the "market" package is still planned; otherwise close
  • Suggested ticket comment The planned "market" package was never created and trunk has no such proc. Closing unless someone still wants to do it.
⬜77608718b52018ncgi nvlist parsing with regards to content type and http methodRFE-OPEN (feasible). Still true: nvlist only looks at the query string for GET and at the body for POST, and nvlist errors on e.g. text/plain or …

Open ticket 77608718b5 · RFE · ncgi · filed 2018-01-08

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible). Still true: nvlist only looks at the query string for GET and at the body for POST, and nvlist errors on e.g. text/plain or application/json ("Unknown Content-Type"). pooryorick implemented option 2 (post/poststring/querystring) on the pooryorick/mime branches, but they were never merged and the pyk branch was closed in 2024-11 (51bb6cedcd). Option 1 (a backward-compatible querystring parser next to multipart) is small.

  • Module ncgi 1.4.6
  • Tested ncgi::reset "a=b" text/plain; ncgi::nvlist gives the error "Unknown Content-Type: text/plain" on 9.1 and 8.6
  • Cause ncgi.tcl:query/nvlist
  • Prototype none (API design)
  • Suggested action keep open. The useful parts of the abandoned mime-branch work could be salvaged.
  • Suggested ticket comment Still applicable on trunk (ncgi 1.4.6). The rewrite in the mime/pyk branches was not merged, so a small backward-compatible addition is still welcome.
⬜d6e71bb36a2017Have comm use TclOO instead of snitRFE-OPEN (feasible: comm::future is a small snit type; TclOO is available in 8.6+, but comm still supports 8.5, so it needs either dropping 8.5 or …

Open ticket d6e71bb36a · RFE · comm · filed 2017-12-02

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: comm::future is a small snit type; TclOO is available in 8.6+, but comm still supports 8.5, so it needs either dropping 8.5 or keeping snit there)

  • Module comm 4.7.3 (still package require snit for comm::future)
  • Tested code reading
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still wanted; comm::future is small enough to port to TclOO once comm requires Tcl 8.6.
⬜95cf3738292017ldap testsuite is fatally incompleteRFE-OPEN (still true: apart from the filter encoder, ldap.test only checks argument errors)

Open ticket 95cf373829 · Bug · ldap · filed 2017-10-31

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still true: apart from the filter encoder, ldap.test only checks argument errors)

  • Module ldap 1.10.2
  • Tested read ldap.test. The af927e957f prototype below adds a small in-process mock LDAP server (mockAccept/mockRead, test ldap-30.0) that answers a rootDSE search and an extended request. It is the first test that exercises real protocol traffic, and it works with plain sockets on 127.0.0.1 without devtools/coserv.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype partial seed in prototypes/af927e957f.patch
  • Suggested action keep open. Extend the mock from af927e957f to cover bind, search, add, modify and delete.
  • Suggested ticket comment The proposed fix for af927e957f adds a minimal mock server to ldap.test. It could be extended to cover the other operations.
⬜430c5bbc9f2017Allow case insensitive matching of literalsRFE-OPEN (feasible but large: needs a new PE operator or literal syntax, plus support in the PEG grammar, verify, the Tcl/C PARAM engines, all gene…

Open ticket 430c5bbc9f · RFE · pt (parsetools) · filed 2017-08-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible but large: needs a new PE operator or literal syntax, plus support in the PEG grammar, verify, the Tcl/C PARAM engines, all generators and the docs)

  • Module pt (PEG language, serialization, all backends)
  • Tested grep for nocase/insensitive in pt. Nothing.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (spans meta grammar to engines)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not supported. It needs a new parsing-expression form handled by every pt backend; patches welcome.
⬜eb8c1e69ba2017Add "prune" modeRFE-OPEN (no prune mode; modes are still value/leaf/void). Closely related to 4a80a49118 ("New modes for nonterminals"), which proposes a never-a-n…

Open ticket eb8c1e69ba · RFE · pt (parsetools) · filed 2017-08-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (no prune mode; modes are still value/leaf/void). Closely related to 4a80a49118 ("New modes for nonterminals"), which proposes a never-a-node mode. AK noted it can be done as a post-parse AST transform.

  • Module pt
  • Tested code read (pt_pegrammar.tcl mode handling)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action keep open; consider handling it together with 4a80a49118
  • Suggested ticket comment Still open. See also 4a80a49118, which proposes a related "no node" mode; both need changes from the meta grammar through all engines.
⬜aff22194d72016imap4 - BODY.PEEK failsRFE-OPEN (feasible but not trivial). imap4::fetch does not support raw FETCH items such as BODY.PEEK[1]: any unknown word, including "BODY" its…

Open ticket aff22194d7 · Bug · imap4 · filed 2016-12-27

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible but not trivial). imap4::fetch does not support raw FETCH items such as BODY.PEEK[1]: any unknown word, including "BODY" itself, is treated as a header field name. The request therefore becomes BODY[HEADER.FIELDS (BODY.PEEK[1] FROM)], and the echoed response has nested brackets, which imaptotcl_symbol cannot parse. Its regex [\w\.]+\[[^\[]+\] splits it into BODY HEADER.FIELDS S ....

  • Module imap4 0.5.5
  • Tested fed the responses directly to imap4::imaptotcl on 9.1. (BODY[1] {46}) parses fine. (BODY[HEADER.FIELDS (BODY.PEEK[1] FROM)] {46}) gives garbage, as reported. CANNOT-TEST against a real server (no IMAP server available; would need a fake server on 127.0.0.1).
  • Cause imap4.tcl fetch (default branch of the item switch) and imaptotcl_symbol (regex)
  • Prototype none (proper support needs fetch to pass BODY[...] and BODY.PEEK[...] items through and map them to the "body" attribute for -inline lookups)
  • Suggested action keep open as an RFE (support BODY[section] / BODY.PEEK[section] in fetch)
  • Suggested ticket comment fetch currently only knows the named items plus header field names, so BODY.PEEK[1] is sent as a header name inside HEADER.FIELDS and the echoed reply confuses the parser. Supporting BODY[section] items in fetch is an enhancement still to be done.

---

Side findings (no ticket in this batch):

  • httpd.test cannot run standalone (tclsh9.1 httpd.test aborts: "Error in ncgi.tcl: can't find package fileutil", because ncgi is loaded before fileutil in the support block). It works only through sak.
  • In the httpd test harness ::fileutil::magic::filetype is missing, so serving any file that goes through ::httpd::mime-type (for example .html) returns 500.
  • coroutine::util::gets_safety: return -code $result -options $opts rethrows read errors with an empty message.
  • huddle-12.0 leaves the "map" type registered after deleting ::map, which breaks jsondump in later tests.
  • The three httpd prototypes all add tests at the same spot in httpd.test (before "# Test proxies"); applying more than one needs manual merging of the hunk.
⬜922880978d2016http::autoproxy::init does not discover https proxy on WindowsRFE-OPEN (feasible but needs new options; NEEDS-WINDOWS to test)

Open ticket 922880978d · Bug · http :: autoproxy · filed 2016-09-16

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible but needs new options; NEEDS-WINDOWS to test)

  • Module autoproxy 1.8.1
  • Tested code reading. init calls GetWin32Proxy http only. ProxyServer may hold http=...;https=..., and GetWin32Proxy already parses it per protocol (the answer to aku's question). The https_proxy environment variable is ignored on Unix as well.
  • Cause autoproxy keeps a single proxy_host/port. filter, and tunnel_connect for https, use the same one.
  • Prototype none (needs an option like -https_proxy and tunnel_connect changes)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment The registry value ProxyServer uses the form http=h:p;https=h:p, and GetWin32Proxy can already pick https. Supporting it needs a separate https proxy setting (also for https_proxy on Unix).
⬜76045b938d2016New selenium libraryRFE-OPEN (low value: anonymous submitter, no follow-up since 2016, needs an external browser/WebDriver and no test infrastructure here)

Open ticket 76045b938d · RFE · (unused) · filed 2016-06-19

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (low value: anonymous submitter, no follow-up since 2016, needs an external browser/WebDriver and no test infrastructure here)

  • Module none (external package selenium-tcl on SourceForge)
  • Tested none (no code submitted to tcllib)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Rejected/Out of date unless the author comes back with a contribution
  • Suggested ticket comment No contribution or follow-up came after 2016, and the package lives on as its own project. Closing. Please reopen with a concrete contribution if still interested.
⬜e7d1eeebb42016Dynamic callbacks without re-creating the interfaceRFE-OPEN (feasible: e.g. a per-call -callback override in the generated proc; the workaround in the ticket still works)

Open ticket e7d1eeebb4 · RFE · rest · filed 2016-03-12

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: e.g. a per-call -callback override in the generated proc; the workaround in the ticket still works)

  • Module rest 1.8
  • Tested code read. The callback is still baked into the generated proc at create_interface time.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (API design)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not supported; a per-call callback override would be a reasonable addition.
⬜682ca9b2e12016Variables in the middle of a URLRFE-OPEN / DOCS. %name% (and %name:default%) URL tokens still work but are only documented under ::rest::substitute; the create_interface not…

Open ticket 682ca9b2e1 · RFE · rest · filed 2016-03-12

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN / DOCS. %name% (and %name:default%) URL tokens still work but are only documented under ::rest::substitute; the create_interface note sits in a [comment] at the end of rest.man. rest::describe still does not list them.

  • Module rest 1.8
  • Tested code read (create_interface uses ::rest::substitute on the url; describe looks only at req_args/opt_args)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action keep open; the cheap part is turning the TOKENS comment in rest.man into real docs
  • Suggested ticket comment Still undocumented: the URL token feature is described only in a comment in rest.man, and describe ignores it. Documenting it and teaching describe about the tokens would cover this.
⬜751707e0ae2015logger::logproc should accept command prefixespatchRFE-OPEN (small, compatible. Prototype ready)

Open ticket 751707e0ae · RFE · logger · filed 2015-12-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (small, compatible. Prototype ready)

  • Module logger 0.9.5
  • Tested ${log}::logproc warn [list ::msg warn] fails on trunk with Invalid cmd '::msg warn' - does not exist (9.1, 8.6). Found a related bug: when a child service is created after a new-style logproc is set on the parent, logging from the child passes the internal args to the callback: myp: <-_logger::service par::ch {hi child}>.
  • Cause logger.tcl logproc, one-argument case: info commands $cmd checks the whole prefix, and the generated proc splices the prefix with [list %s ...]. That generated proc also skips _setservicename, which the other two forms call, so the child's -_logger::service marker reaches the callback.
  • Prototype prototypes/751707e0ae.patch (101 lines, tests logger-8.2.1 (prefix) and logger-8.2.2 (child inherits callback). It also updates logger.man). It checks the first word, calls with linsert $prefix end $text, and wraps the call in _setservicename/_restoreservice. Both new tests fail without the fix. The log module passes 373/373 on 9.1 and 8.6.
  • Suggested action apply the prototype. That also allows closing 1113348fff.
  • Suggested ticket comment Proposed patch: logproc accepts a command prefix (the text is appended as the last argument). It also fixes the internal -_logger::service args leaking to a parent's callback when logging from a child service.
⬜785d2954d42015Improve C-implementation of JSON-parsingRFE-OPEN (stale). Branch tkt-785d2954d4-jsonc (last 2da77f541a, 2015-06-08) was never merged. Trunk C code since moved to bison 3 / Tcl 9 and still…

Open ticket 785d2954d4 · Patch · json · filed 2015-05-27

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (stale). Branch tkt-785d2954d4-jsonc (last 2da77f541a, 2015-06-08) was never merged. Trunk C code since moved to bison 3 / Tcl 9 and still builds lists and string objects.

  • Module jsonc 1.1.2 (modules/json/c)
  • Tested fossil diff --from trunk --to tkt-785d2954d4-jsonc and code read (no critcl here)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (would require rebasing the branch onto the bison-3/Tcl-9 parser)
  • Suggested action human decision. Either rebase (dict objects, shared literals, numeric objects) or close as Stale. Note: typed numeric objects can change the string rep of numbers.
  • Suggested ticket comment The branch from 2015 was never merged and has since diverged (bison 3, Tcl 9). It would need to be re-done on top of the current parser.
⬜203aa0ea502015odie::processman should return exit codes of processes it mangesRFE-OPEN (now feasible on Tcl 9: tcl::process status $pid (TIP 462) returns the CHILDSTATUS of exec & children; still no portable way on 8.6)

Open ticket 203aa0ea50 · RFE · odie · filed 2015-05-17

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (now feasible on Tcl 9: tcl::process status $pid (TIP 462) returns the CHILDSTATUS of exec & children; still no portable way on 8.6)

  • Module processman (odie::processman / processman 0.8)
  • Tested 9.1, 9.0: exec sh -c "exit 3" & then tcl::process status → {1 {child process exited abnormally} {CHILDSTATUS pid 3}}. processman.tcl unchanged: spawn uses exec ... &, events only calls the onexit script, no exit code is kept.
  • Cause processman.tcl ::processman::events / onexit keep no status; hypnotoad (2015) said this needs C-level plumbing. Tcl 8.7+/9 now has it.
  • Prototype none (RFE: new API, e.g. pass the exit status to the onexit callback when tcl::process exists)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE (the resolution is already "Wont Fix" but the status is Open: decide one way). The doc category complaint was fixed by aku in 2015.
  • Suggested ticket comment On Tcl 8.7/9 tcl::process status returns the exit status of exec & children, so onexit could pass it to the callback without C code. 8.6 still has no portable way.
⬜9853e83aee2015Add the "browse" package from stackato-cliRFE-OPEN (feasible: the package is small and pure Tcl)

Open ticket 9853e83aee · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2015-01-16

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: the package is small and pure Tcl)

  • Module none
  • Tested no browse package in tcllib or tklib.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not imported. The stackato-cli browse package is small and would fit Tcllib.
⬜685345eb4d2014Idea for documentation index: By command name, map to module/package(s)RFE-OPEN (feasible: a keyword-index-style generator in sak doc / dtplite; nobody worked on it since 2015)

Open ticket 685345eb4d · RFE · (unused) · filed 2014-12-11

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a keyword-index-style generator in sak doc / dtplite; nobody worked on it since 2015)

  • Module doctools / dtplite, sak localdoc (trunk)
  • Tested checked embedded/md (toc.md, toc0-2.md, index.md): only by-category, by-type/module, and keyword indexes; no command index
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE, needs design for incremental multi-package help systems)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE (related to c0046f29cd)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented. The generated docs only have category, module, and keyword indexes.
⬜b41b6f76b02014No IPv6 support for FTPRFE-OPEN (still missing on trunk; draft branch exists)

Open ticket b41b6f76b0 · Bug · ftp · filed 2014-08-11

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still missing on trunk; draft branch exists)

  • Module ftp 2.4.14
  • Tested code check on trunk. OpenActiveConn builds PORT with string map {. ,} on the local address, so with an IPv6 control connection it sends e.g. PORT ::1,p1,p2. OpenPassiveConn only parses the IPv4 227 reply. There is no EPRT/EPSV on trunk. aku's draft is on branch ak-tkt-b41b6f76b0-ftp-eprt (ad53730d6b, eb27679053, 2014-12, ftp "2.5"), never merged. No local IPv6 FTP server was available to test the branch.
  • Cause ftp.tcl OpenActiveConn / OpenPassiveConn are IPv4-only.
  • Prototype none (feature; the existing branch should be reviewed and rebased instead)
  • Suggested action keep open; review/rebase branch ak-tkt-b41b6f76b0-ftp-eprt onto trunk (it predates the Tcl 9 work); tcllib's ftpd would also need EPRT/EPSV for tests
  • Suggested ticket comment Still missing on trunk. The draft EPRT/EPSV work on branch ak-tkt-b41b6f76b0-ftp-eprt was never merged and needs to be rebased and tested.
⬜0fc3770ef52014Request for IPv6 support in the function ::ip::nextNetRFE-OPEN (feasible, same situation as 1852685fff; no patch was supplied)

Open ticket 0fc3770ef5 · RFE · ip · filed 2014-02-03

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, same situation as 1852685fff; no patch was supplied)

  • Module ip 1.5.1 (ipMore.tcl)
  • Tested code read. nextNet uses 32-bit integer arithmetic.
  • Cause ipMore.tcl:nextNet is IPv4-only
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open (could be combined with 1852685fff as "IPv6 in ipMore")
  • Suggested ticket comment Still IPv4-only. A patch is welcome. See also 1852685fff.
⬜3610485fff2013Validate option default at instance creationRFE-OPEN (feasible, behaviour change)

Open ticket 3610485fff · RFE · snit · filed 2013-04-10

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, behaviour change)

  • Module snit 2.3.4
  • Tested on 9.1 and 8.6, option -x -default bad -validatemethod V then T create t succeeds; V is not called for the default.
  • Cause defaults are copied into options() in RT.type.typemethod.create without calling the validator.
  • Prototype none (RFE; validating defaults could break existing types that use placeholder defaults such as "")
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE (or make it opt-in, e.g. a pragma)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still the case: defaults are not passed through -validatemethod. Feasible, but it should probably be opt-in to avoid breaking types with placeholder defaults.
⬜3584574fff2012File/directory checking featureRFE-OPEN (feasible; the patch on 3584575fff implements file/dir classes via fileutil)

Open ticket 3584574fff · RFE · cmdline · filed 2012-11-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible; the patch on 3584575fff implements file/dir classes via fileutil)

  • Module cmdline 1.5.3 (typedGetopt)
  • Tested code reading. The typed classes are still only the string is classes plus enumerations.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (new feature)
  • Suggested action keep open together with 3584575fff
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented. The patch on 3584575fff contains a file/dir implementation but needs rework for the current code.
⬜3508603fff2012json: pretty-printing a dictionaryRFE-OPEN (low value; obsolete in practice). Pretty-printing a Tcl dict is not a JSON-parser concern. json::write indented/aligned pretty-prints…

Open ticket 3508603fff · Patch · json · filed 2012-03-19

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (low value; obsolete in practice). Pretty-printing a Tcl dict is not a JSON-parser concern. json::write indented/aligned pretty-prints JSON output.

  • Module json 1.3.6
  • Tested patch read, not applied anywhere
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Rejected (human decision)
  • Suggested ticket comment Pretty-printing Tcl dicts is outside the json parser's scope. json::write offers indented/aligned JSON output.
⬜3501392fff2012New Module: socks5RFE-OPEN (no SOCKS support in tcllib; the 2012 patch against 1.14 was never reviewed. It needs review for Tcl 8.5+/9 and a test suite with a local …

Open ticket 3501392fff · Patch · A Category Is Missing · filed 2012-03-10

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (no SOCKS support in tcllib; the 2012 patch against 1.14 was never reviewed. It needs review for Tcl 8.5+/9 and a test suite with a local proxy.)

  • Module none (proposed new module)
  • Tested none (attachment not reviewed in depth; tcllib still has no socks module)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action maintainers' decision: review/import or close as stale
  • Suggested ticket comment tcllib still has no SOCKS module. Is the author still around to update the contribution for current tcllib/Tcl 9 with tests?
⬜3441173fff2011Implement OpenPGP/GPGRFE-OPEN (large: OpenPGP packet format, key parsing, web of trust; nothing has been done since 2011)

Open ticket 3441173fff · RFE · pki · filed 2011-11-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (large: OpenPGP packet format, key parsing, web of trust; nothing has been done since 2011)

  • Module pki 0.22
  • Tested code check only; pki has no OpenPGP code.
  • Prototype none (new feature, far beyond the scope)
  • Suggested action human decision: close as Won't Fix (long-term idea from 2011, no one is working on it) or keep as a wishlist item
  • Suggested ticket comment No work on this since 2011; pki supports only X.509/PKCS formats. Closing unless someone volunteers to implement it.
⬜3423097fff2011smtp lacks -timeout optionRFE-OPEN (feasible; overlaps 1427906fff)

Open ticket 3423097fff · RFE · smtp · filed 2011-10-13

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible; overlaps 1427906fff)

  • Module mime / smtp 1.5.2
  • Tested code reading. Only -maxsecs exists, used for the end-of-DATA reply (default 120). Connect/greeting/command waits are fixed (300–3600 s, capped at 600 per read).
  • Cause smtp.tcl: hard-coded talk/hear timeouts
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open together with 1427906fff, or close one as a duplicate of the other.
  • Suggested ticket comment Still valid. -maxsecs only covers the final reply after DATA. A general -timeout would also cover 1427906fff.
⬜3012802fff2010add timeout feature for nntpRFE-OPEN (feasible: a -timeout option via the existing cget/configure plus a fileevent/vwait getline, about 40 lines. Untestable without a mock NNT…

Open ticket 3012802fff · RFE · nntp · filed 2010-06-07

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a -timeout option via the existing cget/configure plus a fileevent/vwait getline, about 40 lines. Untestable without a mock NNTP server, and none exists in the module.)

  • Module nntp 0.2.3
  • Tested code reading. ::nntp::fetch and ::nntp::response still call blocking gets. The _configure proc exists now (it did not in 2010), so a -timeout option has an obvious home. The attached nntp.tcl is a full copy of 0.2.2 with getline/timeout added, and is not applied.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE).
  • Suggested action keep open (related to 920974ffff / 2431506fff).
  • Suggested ticket comment Still no timeout on trunk. The package now has configure/cget, so a -timeout option would fit there.
⬜3002617fff2010des , des-mode parameter and key paddingRFE-OPEN (the -des-mode/null padding request is questionable; silent key padding is unsafe). DOCS part still valid: des.man says -key "takes a bina…

Open ticket 3002617fff · RFE · A Category Is Missing · filed 2010-05-17

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (the -des-mode/null padding request is questionable; silent key padding is unsafe). DOCS part still valid: des.man says -key "takes a binary string of 8 bytes" and never says that a 24-byte key selects 3DES.

  • Module des 1.2
  • Tested read des.man and des.tcl (key length must be a multiple of 8; mode chosen by length)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (docs-only change, no test possible; suggest one sentence in des.man: "A 24-byte key selects triple DES (3DES)")
  • Suggested action fix the doc sentence, reject padding, then close
  • Suggested ticket comment Automatic key padding would weaken keys and won't be added. The manpage should say that a 24-byte key selects 3DES.
⬜3000165fff2010include an attribute parserRFE-OPEN (feasible: a small htmlparse::parseAttributes proc that returns a name/value dict and handles quoted, unquoted and bare attributes)

Open ticket 3000165fff · RFE · htmlparse · filed 2010-05-11

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a small htmlparse::parseAttributes proc that returns a name/value dict and handles quoted, unquoted and bare attributes)

  • Module htmlparse 1.2.3
  • Tested nothing in htmlparse or html parses attributes.
  • Cause -
  • Prototype none (new API)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still wanted and easy to add as a helper; it would also cover 1733442.
⬜2821416fff2009smtp should not use [vwait]RFE-OPEN (needs an asynchronous API redesign, e.g. callbacks or coroutines)

Open ticket 2821416fff · RFE · smtp · filed 2009-07-14

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (needs an asynchronous API redesign, e.g. callbacks or coroutines)

  • Module mime / smtp 1.5.2
  • Tested code reading. hear still does vwait ${token}(readable).
  • Cause smtp.tcl: hear
  • Prototype none (API redesign)
  • Suggested action keep open (or close as Rejected if nobody plans an async smtp)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still true: smtp waits with nested vwait. Fixing this needs a new callback/coroutine API, not a small fix.
⬜2800400fff2009struct::graph:op::toAdjacencyMatrix issuesRFE-OPEN (partly done: point 2 is done, the matrix uses 1/0 per graphops.man. Points 1, 3 and 4 (separate node list, direction/multiplicity, combin…

Open ticket 2800400fff · RFE · struct :: graph · filed 2009-06-03

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done: point 2 is done, the matrix uses 1/0 per graphops.man. Points 1, 3 and 4 (separate node list, direction/multiplicity, combiner command) are not implemented.)

  • Module struct::graph::op 0.11.4
  • Tested graphops.man / graphops.tcl inspection
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (API design; best as a new command)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE
  • Suggested ticket comment Elements are now 1/0. Direction, multiplicity and node-order options are still missing; they'd best be a new command to keep compatibility.
⬜2787872fff2009default standard channel should not be created implicitelyRFE-OPEN (feasible but incompatible: comm.tcl creates ::comm::comm at package load, and existing code relies on it)

Open ticket 2787872fff · RFE · comm · filed 2009-05-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible but incompatible: comm.tcl creates ::comm::comm at package load, and existing code relies on it)

  • Module comm 4.7.3
  • Tested code reading (tail of comm.tcl)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (API change)
  • Suggested action close as Won't fix, or keep open for a future major version
  • Suggested ticket comment Creating ::comm::comm on load is long-standing documented behaviour that much code depends on; changing it would break compatibility. Use comm::comm destroy if the default channel is unwanted.
⬜2779581fff2009sid2SDDL functionRFE-OPEN (feasible and small. Needs a decision on where AD helpers go)

Open ticket 2779581fff · Patch · ldap · filed 2009-04-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible and small. Needs a decision on where AD helpers go)

  • Module ldap 1.10.2
  • Tested read the attachment sid2sddl.tcl. Nothing like it exists in tcllib: no "sddl" or "objectSid" in modules/ or examples/.
  • Cause n/a. The patch has a bug: binary scan "x2SIi*" uses signed S/I, so an identifier authority of 2^31 or more gives a wrong value. Since Tcl 8.5 it should use Su/Iu/iu* and drop the manual overflow fix-up.
  • Prototype none (needs a placement decision: ldap, a new ldap::activedirectory package, or examples/. The 2009 comments left this open)
  • Suggested action keep open if someone wants an AD helper package. Otherwise close as Rejected and point to examples.
  • Suggested ticket comment Never applied. If wanted, it should use unsigned binary scan formats (Su Iu iu*, Tcl 8.5+) and needs a home (ldap or a separate AD helper package) plus tests.
⬜2769242fff2009Persistence for various data structuresRFE-OPEN (vague; nothing implemented)

Open ticket 2769242fff · RFE · struct · filed 2009-04-16

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (vague; nothing implemented)

  • Module struct
  • Tested n/a
  • Cause n/a. graph/tree/matrix already have serialize/deserialize, which gives basic persistence when combined with a file or sqlite store.
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Won't Fix (serialize/deserialize covers it), or keep as a wishlist item
  • Suggested ticket comment struct::graph/tree/matrix provide serialize/deserialize, which can be stored anywhere. A generic persistence layer is not planned. Suggest closing.
⬜2690366fff2009Tk GUI for dtpliteRFE-OPEN (feasible, no design exists; filed by the maintainer as an idea in 2009)

Open ticket 2690366fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2009-03-17

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, no design exists; filed by the maintainer as an idea in 2009)

  • Module apps/dtplite
  • Tested none (quick look; no GUI code exists)
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action close as "won't do" unless someone volunteers. Human decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment Nothing has been done since 2009. Closing as an idea without a design or volunteer.
⬜2662968fff2009Have lappend method accept multiple valuesRFE-OPEN (feasible; still single value)

Open ticket 2662968fff · Bug · struct :: graph · filed 2009-03-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible; still single value)

  • Module struct::graph 2.4.4, struct::tree 2.1.1
  • Tested graph_tcl.tcl _lappend, __arc_lappend and __node_lappend, and tree_tcl.tcl _lappend, all take exactly key value. So do the C implementations (graph/methods.c, tree/m.c).
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (needs matching changes in four Tcl procs and three C methods, plus docs. The critcl variants can't be tested here.)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE
  • Suggested ticket comment Still single-value in both the Tcl and C implementations of graph and tree. Doable, but it needs coordinated changes in both backends.
⬜2431506fff2008Event based nntp, plus cleanupsRFE-OPEN (contributed rewrite, never applied. It only supports RFC 977 commands, so applying it as is would drop the X* extensions trunk has.)

Open ticket 2431506fff · Patch · nntp · filed 2008-12-15

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (contributed rewrite, never applied. It only supports RFC 977 commands, so applying it as is would drop the X* extensions trunk has.)

  • Module nntp 0.2.3
  • Tested the attachment mynntp.gz (gzip of mynntp.tcl, based on nntp 0.2.1) is present in the repo. Trunk nntp.tcl still uses blocking gets.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (whole-package rewrite, > 60 lines, API change).
  • Suggested action keep open as a design reference, or close as "won't apply" if nobody will merge it. Needs a maintainer decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment Not applied. Trunk nntp is still blocking. The patch is a full rewrite against 0.2.1 and lacks the non-RFC977 commands, so it would need porting.
⬜2359926fff2008fileutil::tempdir on windowsRFE-OPEN (feasible, small; NEEDS-WINDOWS to test). The Windows fallback list is still C:\TEMP C:\TMP \TEMP \TMP after TMPDIR/TEMP/TMP.

Open ticket 2359926fff · RFE · fileutil · filed 2008-11-29

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, small; NEEDS-WINDOWS to test). The Windows fallback list is still C:\TEMP C:\TMP \TEMP \TMP after TMPDIR/TEMP/TMP.

  • Module fileutil 1.16.4 (TempDir)
  • Tested read TempDir on trunk
  • Cause there is no use of the system temp path API. On Windows, the fallback could add $env(LOCALAPPDATA)/Temp and $env(SystemRoot)/Temp, or derive the directory from Tcl 8.6+'s file tempfile, which uses GetTempPathW.
  • Prototype none (needs Windows to verify)
  • Suggested action keep open, low priority (TEMP/TMP are normally set on Windows)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still valid for the fallback path. A cheap improvement would be to try %SystemRoot%\Temp, or the directory of a [file tempfile] on 8.6+, before C:\TEMP.
⬜2250870fff2008improvements for fileutil::traverseRFE-OPEN (patch not applied: no -notroot, -sort, -order or basedir method on trunk. The patch targets traverse 0.4 and has no tests. traverse cha…

Open ticket 2250870fff · Patch · fileutil · filed 2008-11-09

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (patch not applied: no -notroot, -sort, -order or basedir method on trunk. The patch targets traverse 0.4 and has no tests. traverse changed a lot since then, with symlink/cycle fixes and callback fixes, so it no longer applies.)

  • Module fileutil::traverse 0.7
  • Tested compared the attached patch with trunk traverse.tcl
  • Prototype none (feature work, no longer applies)
  • Suggested action keep open if wanted, or close. -notroot can be done with -filter, and sorting by the caller. Human decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment The patch was never applied and does not apply to traverse 0.7. -notroot can be emulated with -filter. A re-based patch with tests would be needed.
⬜1968596fff2008add -padding to aes packageRFE-OPEN (feasible). aes still pads only with NUL bytes (aes.tcl:509 Pad), so a -padding pkcs7 option would be about 30 lines and backward comp…

Open ticket 1968596fff · RFE · aes · filed 2008-05-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible). aes still pads only with NUL bytes (aes.tcl:509 Pad), so a -padding pkcs7 option would be about 30 lines and backward compatible. -hexkey is not really needed, because binary decode hex (8.6+) covers it; a doc example would be enough. The related des request is 3002617fff.

  • Module aes 1.2.2
  • Tested code read only
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE / API addition)
  • Suggested action keep open (low priority), maybe together with 3002617fff
  • Suggested ticket comment Still valid: aes only zero-pads. For hex keys, use -key [binary decode hex $hexkey] (Tcl 8.6+).
⬜1969042fff2008Typewriter/fixed-width fontRFE-OPEN (feasible: a new markup command in checker + all formatters)

Open ticket 1969042fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2008-05-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a new markup command in checker + all formatters)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested checked the command list in checker.tcl. There is still no generic fixed-width/"literal" inline markup (only const, term, cmd, example, ...).
  • Prototype none (language extension that touches every backend)
  • Suggested action keep open; needs the maintainer's decision on the language
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available. The closest inline markups are [const] and [term].
⬜1969144fff2008Alternatives, repetition, and list structureRFE-OPEN (language extension)

Open ticket 1969144fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2008-05-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (language extension)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested no alt/rep commands or display-syntax block exist. A workaround works: [opt "[arg option] [arg value] ..."] renders as ?option value ...?, and a double-quoted [vset NAME "[...markup...]"] stores formatted markup for reuse.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open or close as won't-do; human decision
  • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented. Repetition is usually written as [opt "[arg x] ..."], and [vset] with double-quoted markup can name reusable fragments.
⬜1969151fff2008"Macro" definitionsRFE-OPEN (partly covered: [vset name "markup"] (doctools since 2003) acts as a parameterless macro; there are no parameterized macros)

Open ticket 1969151fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2008-05-21

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly covered: [vset name "markup"] (doctools since 2003) acts as a parameterless macro; there are no parameterized macros)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested [vset OPTS "[opt "[arg option] [arg value] ..."]"] then [vset OPTS] inside [call] renders correctly in text and html on 9.1. With braces, the markup stays literal.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open for parameterized macros, or close noting vset/include. Needs a human decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment Parameterless macros are possible with [vset name "...markup..."] (double quotes, so the markup is expanded) and [include]. Parameterized macros are still missing.
⬜1913502fff2008Suppression level EnhancementRFE-OPEN (not implemented. Would need an API redesign. The 2008 maintainers suggested a major version)

Open ticket 1913502fff · RFE · log · filed 2008-03-13

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (not implemented. Would need an API redesign. The 2008 maintainers suggested a major version)

  • Module log 1.5 / logger 0.9.5
  • Tested code review. Neither log nor logger has a priority within a level. A logger sub-service per verbosity (foo::v1, foo::v2) gives most of this today.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (API design)
  • Suggested action close as Rejected/Postponed unless someone wants to redesign logger. The workaround is sub-services.
  • Suggested ticket comment There are no plans for per-level priorities. The usual workaround is a logger child service per verbosity, enabled independently.
⬜1911513fff2008deserialise into a branch of a treeRFE-OPEN (feasible: a "graft"/deserialize serial ?node? that inserts under a node; needs node-name clash handling and both Tcl and critcl impleme…

Open ticket 1911513fff · RFE · struct :: tree · filed 2008-03-10

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a "graft"/deserialize serial ?node? that inserts under a node; needs node-name clash handling and both Tcl and critcl implementations, so moderate work)

  • Module struct::tree 2.1.3
  • Tested code review. deserialize takes only the serialization, and there is no graft method.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available. A graft operation would need a policy for node-name clashes, and implementations in both the Tcl and C backends.
⬜1908510fff2008Submission: fileutil::globfindRFE-OPEN (the code is attached and the Tcl license fits, but it was never reviewed. It would need tests and docs, and overlaps fileutil::find/trave…

Open ticket 1908510fff · RFE · fileutil · filed 2008-03-06

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (the code is attached and the Tcl license fits, but it was never reviewed. It would need tests and docs, and overlaps fileutil::find/traverse.)

  • Module fileutil
  • Tested none (quick look at the attachment, globfind 1.5.3)
  • Prototype none (new package submission)
  • Suggested action human decision; probably close as won't-do (an alternative implementation of existing functionality; the wiki page keeps the code available)
  • Suggested ticket comment Not integrated in 18 years. fileutil::find and fileutil::traverse cover this. Closing unless someone wants to adopt it with tests and docs.
⬜1852685fff2007::ip::isOverlap should support IPv6RFE-OPEN (feasible. The ip.tcl core already has IPv6 Normalize6/Mask6, so isOverlap could dispatch on ip::version.)

Open ticket 1852685fff · RFE · ip · filed 2007-12-17

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible. The ip.tcl core already has IPv6 Normalize6/Mask6, so isOverlap could dispatch on ip::version.)

  • Module ip 1.5.1 (ipMore.tcl)
  • Tested 9.1: ip::isOverlap 2002:0a23:0100::/80 2002:0a23:0100::5 gives "invalid ip address"
  • Cause ipMore.tcl functions work on 32-bit integers only
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still IPv4-only. It could be built on ip::prefix/ip::equal, which already handle IPv6.
⬜1811890fff2007inifile : allow keys with no assignmentpatchRFE-OPEN (feasible; attached patch was never applied)

Open ticket 1811890fff · Patch · inifile · filed 2007-10-11

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible; attached patch was never applied)

  • Module inifile 0.3.3 (modules/inifile/ini.tcl)
  • Tested 9.1, 8.6. On trunk a line like C (no =) inside a section is silently dropped by _loadfile, and lost on commit.
  • Cause ini.tcl:_loadfile only accepts *=* lines; there is no state for "key without value".
  • Prototype prototypes/1811890fff.patch (52 lines, test inifile-6.1). Re-creation of the 2007 patch (attachment inifile-patch.tgz; it is stored double-UTF-8-encoded and has to be decoded latin-1 first) against trunk. A solo array marks bare keys. They read as value "" (value with a default returns the default, as in the original patch). commit writes them back bare. set/delete/revert clear the mark. ini.man not updated yet.
  • Suggested action decide on the semantics of value for bare keys (default vs ""), then apply the prototype with a doc note. Close 2037560fff as a duplicate.
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not supported on trunk. A prototype based on the attached patch (bare keys are kept, read as empty value, written back without "=") is ready for review.
⬜1800599fff2007Generate html redirect pages to sub-commandsRFE-OPEN (not implemented. It depends on knowing which commands a page defines, the same missing piece as 1798413.)

Open ticket 1800599fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-09-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (not implemented. It depends on knowing which commands a page defines, the same missing piece as 1798413.)

  • Module dtplite 1.0.5
  • Tested code reading of dtplite.tcl
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open, together with 1798413
  • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented. It needs the same command-definition index as 1798413, so the two would best be done together.
⬜1800608fff2007dtplite html output: title, meta keywords + descriptionRFE-OPEN (feasible, small: fmt.html already has c_xref_keywords and c_get_title at manpage_begin)

Open ticket 1800608fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-09-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, small: fmt.html already has c_xref_keywords and c_get_title at manpage_begin)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1 (mpformats/fmt.html), dtplite
  • Tested read fmt.html on trunk. The page title is still "$title - $shortdesc" (moddesc). There is no <meta name="keywords"> or <meta name="description">.
  • Cause fmt.html fmt_manpage_begin builds <head> with only charset/viewport meta and the title.
  • Prototype none (RFE; someone has to decide on the title format: titledesc vs moddesc)
  • Suggested action keep open as an RFE, low priority
  • Suggested ticket comment Still valid on trunk: the HTML head has no keywords/description meta, and the title uses moddesc. A small change in mpformats/fmt.html could add both.
⬜1800617fff2007doctools module toc: name vs. titledescRFE-OPEN (feasible but a design change of the dtplite per-module TOC layout)

Open ticket 1800617fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-09-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible but a design change of the dtplite per-module TOC layout)

  • Module doctools/dtplite (doctoc generation)
  • Tested quick look only. dtplite still emits the two-level TOC with name titledesc rows.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open, or close as "won't do" if nobody wants it. Needs a human decision.
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented. The per-module TOC lists pages with their titledesc. Grouping by titledesc and listing commands would need dtplite to collect the [call] command names.
⬜1798413fff2007Documenting related commands on one man pageRFE-OPEN (still reproduced on 9.1: [call] entries get numeric anchors <a name="1">, <a name="2">, and the xref database knows nothing about c…

Open ticket 1798413fff · Bug · doctools · filed 2007-09-19

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still reproduced on 9.1: [call] entries get numeric anchors <a name="1">, <a name="2">, and the xref database knows nothing about command definitions, so [cmd other] does not link to the page that defines it. This is a feature request, not a bug.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1 fmt.html
  • Tested formatted a two-call page to HTML on 9.1 and checked the anchors
  • Cause mpformats/fmt.html fmt_call uses a counter for anchors. dtplite builds xrefs only from titles, keywords and terms.
  • Prototype none (named anchors are easy, but the cross-page command index in dtplite needs design. Changing anchors would also break existing #N links.)
  • Suggested action keep open (related: 1800599, 1681568)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still the case: command definitions get numeric anchors and are not in the cross-reference data. Named anchors plus a command index in dtplite would solve this together with 1800599.
⬜1753433fff2007Code and man page for lognormal income distribution libraryRFE-OPEN (partly done: pdf/cdf/random-lognormal exist; income-distribution functions such as Lorenz/Gini were not added)

Open ticket 1753433fff · RFE · math · filed 2007-07-13

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done: pdf/cdf/random-lognormal exist; income-distribution functions such as Lorenz/Gini were not added)

  • Module math, math::statistics 1.6.1
  • Tested code inspection. Arjen reported in 2015 that the attachment is corrupt. Other Kemp-Benedict contributions (gamma/beta distributions) are in pdf_stat.tcl.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action Arjen to decide (close, or keep as a reminder). He wrote in 2021 "long overdue".
  • Suggested ticket comment (none, owner decision)
⬜1730868fff2007install as Tcl ModulesRFE-OPEN (still not supported. Related patch ticket 3495830fff, "First go at installing tcl modules", is also Open.)

Open ticket 1730868fff · RFE · None · filed 2007-06-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still not supported. Related patch ticket 3495830fff, "First go at installing tcl modules", is also Open.)

  • Module installer.tcl / sak
  • Tested installer.tcl and support/installation have no .tm install mode.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (installer redesign)
  • Suggested action keep open, and link with 3495830fff (or close one as a duplicate of the other).
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not supported. See patch ticket 3495830fff.
⬜1695111fff2007doctools - Gather markup statisticsRFE-OPEN (not implemented. It is easy to do as a counting hook in checker.tcl, but AK filed it as a self-reminder and no user asked for it.)

Open ticket 1695111fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (not implemented. It is easy to do as a counting hook in checker.tcl, but AK filed it as a self-reminder and no user asked for it.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested code reading
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action close as Rejected (stale self-reminder) unless the maintainer wants to keep it
  • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented, and there has been no demand since 2007. Closing as stale.
⬜1695122fff2007doctools - Use pluginmgr to handle backendsRFE-OPEN (partly done. The doctools2 rewrite of the index and TOC parts, from 2009-03, uses pluginmgr and snit for its import/export plugins. The m…

Open ticket 1695122fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done. The doctools2 rewrite of the index and TOC parts, from 2009-03, uses pluginmgr and snit for its import/export plugins. The main doctools (doc) format still uses the old safe-interp engine. doctools::doc from doctools2 was never written.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1, doctools2idx / doctools2toc
  • Tested code reading (doctools2idx/export.tcl requires pluginmgr+snit, doctools.tcl still uses interp)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (large rewrite)
  • Suggested action keep open as the "doctools2 for doc format" item, or close and track it as one item together with 1695123/1695145
  • Suggested ticket comment Done for docidx/doctoc in doctools2 (pluginmgr-based import/export). The doc format itself has not been ported yet.
⬜1695123fff2007doctools - Rework to use snitRFE-OPEN (partly done. doctools2idx/doctools2toc are snit types. doctools.tcl is still the custom object system.)

Open ticket 1695123fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done. doctools2idx/doctools2toc are snit types. doctools.tcl is still the custom object system.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested code reading
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (large rewrite)
  • Suggested action same as 1695122 (keep open or merge into one doctools2-doc ticket)
  • Suggested ticket comment The doctools2 index/TOC packages use snit. The doc format engine has not been ported.
⬜1695126fff2007doctools - Add backend 'wordlist'RFE-OPEN (no such engine. It would be simple, about 50 lines based on fmt.null with fmt_plain_text collecting words.)

Open ticket 1695126fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (no such engine. It would be simple, about 50 lines based on fmt.null with fmt_plain_text collecting words.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested listed mpformats
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action close as Rejected (stale self-reminder) or keep open (maintainer decision)
  • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented. A wordlist engine would be a small addition based on fmt.null if someone needs it.
⬜1695128fff2007doctools - Add backend 'semantic'RFE-OPEN (no such engine. It is feasible in the same way as 1695126.)

Open ticket 1695128fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (no such engine. It is feasible in the same way as 1695126.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested listed mpformats
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action same as 1695126
  • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented. It is feasible as a small engine that collects the arguments of the semantic markup commands.
⬜1695131fff2007doctools - Add backend 'doctools'RFE-OPEN (there is no doctools-to-doctools pretty printer. doctools2idx/toc have export_docidx/export_doctoc for their formats, but there is no…

Open ticket 1695131fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (there is no doctools-to-doctools pretty printer. doctools2idx/toc have export_docidx/export_doctoc for their formats, but there is no equivalent for doc.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested listed mpformats and doctools2* exporters
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open with the doctools2-doc items (1695122/1695145)
  • Suggested ticket comment Exists for the index and TOC formats (doctools2 docidx/doctoc exporters), but not for the doc format.
⬜1695137fff2007doctools - Misc processing ideasRFE-OPEN (depends on 1695126/1695128, which do not exist. It is a list of ideas with no concrete request.)

Open ticket 1695137fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (depends on 1695126/1695128, which do not exist. It is a list of ideas with no concrete request.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested n/a
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Rejected (idea list, nothing actionable)
  • Suggested ticket comment This is a list of ideas that depends on the wordlist/semantic backends, which were never written. Closing because there is nothing actionable here.
⬜1695145fff2007doctools - General tree representation as backend APIRFE-OPEN (partly done. doctools2idx/toc parse into a canonical serialization, a tree/dict, and the exporters work on that. The doc format still use…

Open ticket 1695145fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done. doctools2idx/toc parse into a canonical serialization, a tree/dict, and the exporters work on that. The doc format still uses the event-stream engine API.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1, doctools2idx/toc
  • Tested code reading (doctools2idx/structure.tcl, export.tcl)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (large rewrite)
  • Suggested action keep open together with 1695122/1695123 (or merge them into one doctools2-doc ticket)
  • Suggested ticket comment The doctools2 index/TOC packages implement this with a serialized structure passed to the export plugins. The doc format has not been ported.
⬜1681568fff2007doctools - add facility to hyperlink between documentsRFE-OPEN (partly done. Since doctools 1.3.4, 2008-05-15, [sectref id] links to (sub)sections within a document, and dtplite links [term]s that …

Open ticket 1681568fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-03-15

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (partly done. Since doctools 1.3.4, 2008-05-15, [sectref id] links to (sub)sections within a document, and dtplite links [term]s that match another document's title. [sectref-external] only formats the text, with no link and no check. There are still no links to a specific section of another document.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1, dtplite 1.0.5
  • Tested code reading of checker.tcl sectref/sectref-external
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (needs cross-document label database in dtplite)
  • Suggested action keep open (related: 1798413, 1800599)
  • Suggested ticket comment Links within a document now work through section ids and [sectref]. Links to a section of another document are still missing, because [sectref-external] produces no link.
⬜1680877fff2007procedures to get/set ber encoded data independ of tagRFE-OPEN (feasible, ~25 lines + docs/tests). There is no asnGetTLV/asnTLV yet. It could be built on asnPeekTag (multi-byte tags) and asnGetLength, …

Open ticket 1680877fff · RFE · asn · filed 2007-03-14

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, ~25 lines + docs/tests). There is no asnGetTLV/asnTLV yet. It could be built on asnPeekTag (multi-byte tags) and asnGetLength, instead of the single-byte asnGetByte used in the proposal.

  • Module asn 0.8.5
  • Tested code read
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment (none)
⬜1657338fff2007Blowfish CFB modeRFE-OPEN (patch never applied; modes are still ecb cbc)

Open ticket 1657338fff · Patch · blowfish · filed 2007-02-11

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (patch never applied; modes are still ecb cbc)

  • Module blowfish 1.0.6
  • Tested compared the attached patch with blowfish.tcl
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (new feature). The 2007 patch has bugs: if ($cfb_mode), unbraced expr, and it only allows a short final block. It also predates the d56da1abca padding changes and would need rework, docs and test vectors.
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE, or close as Won't Fix unless someone provides standard CFB test vectors
  • Suggested ticket comment The patch was never applied and does not apply to the current code. CFB is still missing. A reworked patch with known-answer tests would be welcome.
⬜1601203fff2006i18n package addRFE-OPEN (wiki page not checked, no network; no code was ever attached, and Tcl's own Unicode/msgcat support has since covered much of this)

Open ticket 1601203fff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2006-11-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (wiki page not checked, no network; no code was ever attached, and Tcl's own Unicode/msgcat support has since covered much of this)

  • Module none
  • Tested no i18n package in tcllib.
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action close as Out of Date
  • Suggested ticket comment No code was submitted, and Tcl's Unicode and msgcat support covers most needs. Closing; reopen with a concrete package.
⬜1592656fff2006let ::ftp::Put uses STOU and STOTRFE-OPEN (patch not applied; ftp.tcl has no STOU/STOT and inline Put without a name still uses ftp.tmp)

Open ticket 1592656fff · Patch · ftp · filed 2006-11-08

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (patch not applied; ftp.tcl has no STOU/STOT and inline Put without a name still uses ftp.tmp)

  • Module ftp 2.4.14
  • Tested code read
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none. The patch changes default behaviour (no name → STOU instead of ftp.tmp), adds the HylaFAX-only STOT command, and does not return the server-assigned name, so it needs an API decision.
  • Suggested action keep open for a decision, or close as Won't fix. If wanted, STOU should report the assigned name (from the 150/226 reply).
  • Suggested ticket comment The patch was never applied. STOU support would be useful only if Put also returned the name the server assigned; STOT is HylaFAX-specific.
⬜1510449fff2006Feature request: Robots exclusion rules parser/checkerRFE-OPEN (feasible, small. No robots.txt support in tcllib.)

Open ticket 1510449fff · RFE · None · filed 2006-06-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, small. No robots.txt support in tcllib.)

  • Module n/a (new package)
  • Tested grep over the modules. Nothing related exists.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (new module)
  • Suggested action keep open, or close for lack of interest (the promised code never arrived, 2006).
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available in tcllib. A contribution following RFC 9309 would be welcome.
⬜1475968fff2006comm - use canonical ids for remote host connectionsRFE-OPEN (hard: needs a protocol extension or reverse DNS; see aku's 2006 analysis); the manpage still documents the limitation

Open ticket 1475968fff · RFE · comm · filed 2006-04-25

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (hard: needs a protocol extension or reverse DNS; see aku's 2006 analysis); the manpage still documents the limitation

  • Module comm 4.7.3
  • Tested code reading (commIncomingOffered builds the id from the peer address; comm.man line ~320 WARNING)
  • Cause commIncomingOffered only knows the peer IP; the connecting side uses whatever host form the user gave
  • Prototype none (protocol change)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE, or close as Won't fix (documented limitation)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still a documented limitation. A fix needs a protocol extension where the connecting side sends its host name; patches welcome.
⬜1427906fff2006option for server timeout on initializeRFE-OPEN (feasible, about 15 lines)

Open ticket 1427906fff · RFE · smtp · filed 2006-02-08

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, about 15 lines)

  • Module mime / smtp 1.5.2
  • Tested code reading. initialize still uses a fixed hear $token 600 for the greeting. -maxsecs exists but only applies to the reply after the final ".". Other waits are fixed at 300/600/3600 s.
  • Cause smtp.tcl: initialize/talk callers use hard-coded timeouts
  • Prototype none (RFE; API choice needed)
  • Suggested action keep open. Handle together with 3423097fff (same request in general form).
  • Suggested ticket comment Still valid: the greeting wait is fixed at 600 s, and -maxsecs only covers the end of DATA. See also 3423097fff.
⬜1385688fff2005pop3 - New retrieval method + minor performance improvementRFE-OPEN (not applied: RetrFast still splits the whole message for debug logging; there is no "tofile" retrieval mode)

Open ticket 1385688fff · RFE · pop3 · filed 2005-12-20

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (not applied: RetrFast still splits the whole message for debug logging; there is no "tofile" retrieval mode)

  • Module pop3 1.11
  • Tested compared with trunk pop3.tcl.
  • Cause n/a. The patch is a full 2005 pop3.tcl (1.6.3 base) and does not apply as is. The temp-file code could now just use file tempfile (8.6+).
  • Prototype none (RFE/new API)
  • Suggested action keep open, or take only the cheap part (skip the split when debug logging is suppressed) and close
  • Suggested ticket comment Neither part was applied. The logging optimisation is easy to redo on trunk; a tofile mode would now use file tempfile.
⬜1373937fff2005bench package does not work as TMRFE-OPEN (feasible, low value)

Open ticket 1373937fff · Bug · bench · filed 2005-12-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible, low value)

  • Module bench 0.6
  • Tested code reading only
  • Cause modules/bench/bench.tcl:bench::Invoke still runs [list $ip [file join $self libbench.tcl] ...]. A child interpreter cannot read a script inside a wrapped (starkit/zipfs) filesystem. Tcllib installs bench as a normal package directory, never as a .tm, so a stock install is not affected.
  • Prototype none (only matters for custom wrapping. The fix would be: if [lindex [file system $self] 0] ne "native", copy libbench.tcl to a temp file. A test would need a VFS mount.)
  • Suggested action keep open as low-priority RFE, or close as Won't Fix
  • Suggested ticket comment Still true: bench execs libbench.tcl by path, so it fails when wrapped. Tcllib itself never installs bench as a module. The fix is to copy libbench.tcl to a native temp file when file system is not native.
⬜1316233fff2005struct::tree - need more testcases - walk, deserializeRFE-OPEN (test-coverage task still valid)

Open ticket 1316233fff · Bug · struct :: tree · filed 2005-10-07

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (test-coverage task still valid)

  • Module struct::tree 2.1.3
  • Tested tree.testsuite has no tests for root-node attributes in deserialize, or for walks that modify the tree. Ad hoc on 9.1 and 8.6: root attributes deserialize correctly. Adding children during a walk visits them. Deleting a not-yet-visited sibling during a walk fails with an internal error, can't read "children(y)": no such element in array (tree_tcl _walk).
  • Cause walk semantics under modification are undefined. Pinning them down requires deciding the semantics and checking the C implementation too.
  • Prototype none (needs a semantics decision)
  • Suggested action keep open; possibly add a root-attribute deserialize test
  • Suggested ticket comment Still missing. Deleting a pending node during walk currently fails with an internal "can't read children(...)" error in the Tcl implementation. The walk semantics under modification need defining before tests can be written.
⬜1283594fff2005$object info self commandRFE-OPEN (trivial to add)

Open ticket 1283594fff · RFE · snit · filed 2005-09-07

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (trivial to add)

  • Module snit 2.3.4
  • Tested info supports args/body/default/type/vars/options/methods/typevars/typemethods. There is no self.
  • Cause -
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open if wanted (a few lines in RT.method.info plus docs), else close as Rejected
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available. It would be a small addition to $obj info if still wanted.
⬜1267112fff2005doctools - Add table supportRFE-OPEN (there is still no table markup in checker.tcl. Feasible, but it needs a markup design and support in all 10 backends. Markdown/HTML/LaTeX…

Open ticket 1267112fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2005-08-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (there is still no table markup in checker.tcl. Feasible, but it needs a markup design and support in all 10 backends. Markdown/HTML/LaTeX/nroff(tbl) can do it, and text/wiki/tmml would need a preformatted fallback.)

  • Module doctools 1.6.1
  • Tested code reading of checker.tcl command list
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (needs design, well over 60 lines)
  • Suggested action keep open
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented, and units.man still uses [example] for its tables. The proposal in the comments (table_begin/row/table_end) is a reasonable starting point.
⬜1266913fff2005skiplist - Walking through a rangeRFE-OPEN (feasible: _walk could take optional -from/-to keys and use the search path to start; about 20 lines plus docs)

Open ticket 1266913fff · RFE · struct :: skiplist · filed 2005-08-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: _walk could take optional -from/-to keys and use the search path to start; about 20 lines plus docs)

  • Module struct::skiplist 1.4
  • Tested code review. walk cmd takes no range arguments (skiplist.tcl _walk).
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action keep open (low priority)
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not available: walk always walks the whole list. A -from/-to key range would be easy to add on top of the existing search.
⬜1234478fff2005Add support for writing Bibtex filesRFE-OPEN (feasible: a bibtex::format type key dict writer is about 30 lines)

Open ticket 1234478fff · RFE · bibtex · filed 2005-07-07

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (feasible: a bibtex::format type key dict writer is about 30 lines)

  • Module bibtex 0.8
  • Tested checked API, the package has a parser only
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (new API)
  • Suggested action keep open as RFE
  • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented. The bibtex package only parses.
⏳1213545fff2005mime: Provide getheaders and getbody (enhancement)RFE-OPEN (the 2018 comment refers to a9488befa9, which is on Poor Yorick's mime rewrite branch, never merged and closed by Jan in 2024. On trunk,…

Open ticket 1213545fff · Bug · mime · filed 2005-06-02 · Pending (resolved, waiting for confirmation)

⏳ Since triage (updated 2026-11-16)

Status now: Pending

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (the 2018 comment refers to a9488befa9, which is on Poor Yorick's mime rewrite branch, never merged and closed by Jan in 2024. On trunk, getbody on a multipart still errors "MIME part isn't a leaf")

    • Module mime 1.7.2
    • Tested 9.1: mime::getbody on multipart/form-data → error
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (API design)
    • Suggested action reset from Pending; close as won't-fix, or keep open. Workaround: buildmessage and split at the first CRLFCRLF; getheader already gives the headers.
    • Suggested ticket comment The rewrite mentioned in 2018 was never merged into trunk. getheader returns the headers; for a multipart body, use buildmessage and cut at the first blank line.
    ⬜1191854fff2005profiler - No sense to clutter output when total calls = 0RFE-OPEN (trivial to implement, but needs an API decision. hobbs asked for it to be optional)

    Open ticket 1191854fff · Bug · profiler · filed 2005-04-28

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (trivial to implement, but needs an API decision. hobbs asked for it to be optional)

    • Module profiler 0.7
    • Tested code read. printname still prints the "Total calls: 0" block for uncalled procs.
    • Cause profiler.tcl:printname/print. No option to skip uncalled procs.
    • Prototype none (needs an API choice, e.g. print ?-nonzero? ?pattern?)
    • Suggested action keep open as RFE, low priority, or close as Won't Fix. Callers can already filter with sortFunctions calls or dump.
    • Suggested ticket comment Still current behaviour. As noted, this should be an option rather than a change of default; a patch adding e.g. a flag to print/printsorted would be welcome.
    ⬜1176295fff2005memoize packageRFE-OPEN (feasible; the wiki implementation is small)

    Open ticket 1176295fff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2005-04-04

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible; the wiki implementation is small)

    • Module none (cache::async is different)
    • Tested no memoize package in tcllib.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action keep open (good first contribution) or close as stale
    • Suggested ticket comment Still not in Tcllib. A small memoize package based on the wiki code would be welcome if someone submits it with tests and docs.
    ⬜1156718fff2005comm - Make each connection's serial into a lamport clockRFE-OPEN (feasible via the protocol extension mechanism, but the promised patch never came in 20 years; low value)

    Open ticket 1156718fff · RFE · comm · filed 2005-03-04

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible via the protocol extension mechanism, but the promised patch never came in 20 years; low value)

    • Module comm 4.7.3
    • Tested code reading: comm.tcl comm_cmd_send increments a per-channel serial; receiver never adjusts its serial from received ones
    • Cause n/a (RFE)
    • Prototype none (RFE, needs a protocol change)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Out of Date (no patch, no demand), or keep open if someone wants it
    • Suggested ticket comment No patch was ever submitted and the comm protocol is unchanged. Closing; please reopen with a patch if still wanted.
    ⬜1115865fff2005WebDAV clientRFE-OPEN (code exists only in the old davkit starkit; it depends on TclXML/expat and a modified httpd)

    Open ticket 1115865fff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2005-02-04

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (code exists only in the old davkit starkit; it depends on TclXML/expat and a modified httpd)

    • Module none
    • Tested no webdav package in tcllib.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date unless someone imports the code
    • Suggested ticket comment The davkit code was never imported, and it depends on TclXML/expat. Closing as stale; reopen if someone prepares a Tcllib-ready version.
    ⬜1113348fff2005No way for logproc to discover servicenameRFE-OPEN (workaround works. Would be mostly covered by the 751707e0ae prototype)

    Open ticket 1113348fff · Bug · logger · filed 2005-01-31

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (workaround works. Would be mostly covered by the 751707e0ae prototype)

    • Module logger 0.9.5
    • Tested the old ${log}::logproc level argname body form with variable service still works on 9.1, and gives the child's name when a child service inherits it (Logging service bar::kid : fromkid). That form is documented as deprecated.
    • Cause the new-style logproc callback gets only the text.
    • Prototype none separately. prototypes/751707e0ae.patch lets ${log}::logproc error [list customized $service] pass the name as a prefix argument.
    • Suggested action close together with 751707e0ae once that is applied. Or un-deprecate the body form.
    • Suggested ticket comment With command-prefix support (751707e0ae prototype) the service name can be bound into the callback. The old argname/body form also still gives access to $service.
    ⬜1061759fff2004Make pop3 non-blockingRFE-OPEN (pop3 is still fully blocking; feasible today with coroutines, but it means a large rewrite of every command, not a small patch)

    Open ticket 1061759fff · RFE · pop3 · filed 2004-11-07

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (pop3 is still fully blocking; feasible today with coroutines, but it means a large rewrite of every command, not a small patch)

    • Module pop3 1.11
    • Tested code read.
    • Prototype none (API redesign)
    • Suggested action human decision: keep as a wishlist item or close as Won't Fix (the original amsn code link is dead)
    • Suggested ticket comment pop3 is still blocking. A non-blocking version would be a rewrite (e.g. coroutine-based), and no one is working on it.
    ⬜1015402fff2004Add cmd to fileutil: which, a wrapper around auto_execokRFE-OPEN (trivial to add, but low value: the submitter agreed that auto_execok does the same)

    Open ticket 1015402fff · RFE · fileutil · filed 2004-08-24

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (trivial to add, but low value: the submitter agreed that auto_execok does the same)

    • Module fileutil 1.16.4
    • Tested no fileutil::which on trunk
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as won't-do, or add a 3-line wrapper. Human decision.
    • Suggested ticket comment Tcl's [auto_execok] covers this, so a wrapper was never added.
    ⬜1011831fff2004should use the same code as http packageRFE-OPEN (low value). Reusing http's quoteString would make ncgi depend on Tcl's http package, and the output differs anyway (http encodes space …

    Open ticket 1011831fff · RFE · ncgi · filed 2004-08-18

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (low value). Reusing http's quoteString would make ncgi depend on Tcl's http package, and the output differs anyway (http encodes space as %20, ncgi as +, and http leaves -._~ unescaped). The useful part of the request is matching http's UTF-8 behaviour, and prototype 1f29f7baf9 does that.

    • Module ncgi 1.4.6
    • Tested http::formatQuery a "ö -._~\n(" gives a=%C3%B6%20-._~%0D%0A%28 on 9.1 and 8.6
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (see 1f29f7baf9.patch)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Won't fix once 1f29f7baf9 is applied
    • Suggested ticket comment http::mapReply no longer exists (it is now quoteString). ncgi::encode keeps its own small table and avoids the http dependency. Its UTF-8 behaviour is being aligned with http in 1f29f7baf9.
    ⬜996326ffff2004Hook for errmode 'error'RFE-OPEN (easy: HandleError's error branch writes a hardcoded plain-text block. A callback option or errmode, e.g. errorcmd, would be a small c…

    Open ticket 996326ffff · RFE · textutil :: expander · filed 2004-07-23

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (easy: HandleError's error branch writes a hardcoded plain-text block. A callback option or errmode, e.g. errorcmd, would be a small change.)

    • Module textutil::expander 1.3.2
    • Tested code review, expander.tcl:HandleError
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE, API addition)
    • Suggested action keep open
    • Suggested ticket comment Still hardcoded in HandleError. A small, feasible addition, e.g. an error-formatting callback.
    ⬜934702ffff2004Add a XML parsing module to tcllibRFE-OPEN (still no general XML parser in tcllib; tDOM is the de facto standard and widely packaged)

    Open ticket 934702ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2004-04-14

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (still no general XML parser in tcllib; tDOM is the de facto standard and widely packaged)

    • Module none (only the minimal xsxp in amazon-s3, which needs TclXML, and htmlparse)
    • Tested code review. amazon-s3 requires the external xml (TclXML) package, see closed ticket 28919a4f4e.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Out of Date (point to tDOM)
    • Suggested ticket comment tDOM is now the standard XML solution for Tcl and is widely available. A pure-Tcl parser in Tcllib is unlikely to be maintained. Closing.
    ⬜920974ffff2004Add support for async requests to nntpRFE-OPEN (feasible, but needs an API design: callbacks and a fileevent-driven state machine. Not a small patch.)

    Open ticket 920974ffff · RFE · nntp · filed 2004-03-22

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible, but needs an API design: callbacks and a fileevent-driven state machine. Not a small patch.)

    • Module nntp 0.2.3
    • Tested code reading. nntp.tcl is still fully synchronous (gets $sock in fetch/response), with no -command or progress callback.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE, API redesign).
    • Suggested action keep open. 2431506fff carries an event-based rewrite that would address this.
    • Suggested ticket comment Still synchronous on trunk. See 2431506fff for a contributed event-based version.
    ⬜914293ffff2004RSS generator moduleRFE-OPEN (no code ever contributed; RSS has declined in importance)

    Open ticket 914293ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2004-03-11

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (no code ever contributed; RSS has declined in importance)

    • Module none
    • Tested no rss package in tcllib or tklib.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Nobody contributed code for this in over 20 years. Closing; reopen with an implementation.
    ⬜914295ffff2004RSS parserRFE-OPEN (no code ever contributed; would need an XML parser, see 934702ffff)

    Open ticket 914295ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2004-03-11

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (no code ever contributed; would need an XML parser, see 934702ffff)

    • Module none
    • Tested no rss package in tcllib.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Nobody contributed code for this in over 20 years. Closing; reopen with an implementation.
    ⬜892318ffff2004ftp - site to site transfer supportRFE-OPEN (low value: FXP is disabled on most servers for security reasons). Same request as open RFE 1813193.

    Open ticket 892318ffff · RFE · ftp · filed 2004-02-07

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (low value: FXP is disabled on most servers for security reasons). Same request as open RFE 1813193.

    • Module ftp 2.4.14
    • Tested none (RFE)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Won't fix (or keep one of 892318/1813193 and close the other as duplicate)
    • Suggested ticket comment FXP (server-to-server) transfers are disabled on nearly all servers today. Closing, together with the duplicate request 1813193.
    ⬜886385ffff2004Enhanced do...while/until [prefix] [suffix] Control StructurRFE-OPEN (feasible, small, but no interest in 20+ years; the same is easily written with control::do and while)

    Open ticket 886385ffff · Patch · control · filed 2004-01-28

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible, small, but no interest in 20+ years; the same is easily written with control::do and while)

    • Module control 0.1.4 (control::do exists, without prefix/suffix)
    • Tested code reading (control/do.tcl, control.man)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected, unless someone wants to adopt it
    • Suggested ticket comment The prefix/suffix extension did not attract interest, and control::do covers the base case. Closing; reopen with a patch against do.tcl if still wanted.
    ⬜850810ffff2003Add the wiki skiplist demo code as exampleRFE-OPEN (low value; wiki page not checked, no network; would also need a licence check of wiki code)

    Open ticket 850810ffff · RFE · struct :: skiplist · filed 2003-11-28

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (low value; wiki page not checked, no network; would also need a licence check of wiki code)

    • Module struct::skiplist 1.4
    • Tested no examples/struct skiplist demo exists (examples/struct only has diff demos).
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Out of Date unless someone wants to adopt it
    • Suggested ticket comment No one has picked this up in 20+ years, and the skiplist man page already documents the API. Closing; reopen with a self-contained example file if wanted.
    ⬜837818ffff2003Quoting moduleRFE-OPEN (trivial, but low value: list covers brace quoting, and the backslash map is a one-liner)

    Open ticket 837818ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2003-11-07

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (trivial, but low value: list covers brace quoting, and the backslash map is a one-liner)

    • Module none
    • Tested no quoting helper in tcllib (only page::util::quote, which is internal to page).
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected unless someone wants a small string::quote package
    • Suggested ticket comment Core list already produces properly quoted words, and no further helpers were proposed in 20 years. Closing.
    ⬜832488ffff2003License woesRFE-OPEN (legal/policy question, needs a maintainer decision. It is not a code bug.)

    Open ticket 832488ffff · Bug · None · filed 2003-10-29

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (legal/policy question, needs a maintainer decision. It is not a code bug.)

    • Module comm (modules/comm/comm.LICENSE)
    • Tested comm.LICENSE (Open Group RI license, with clauses that ask for notification and acknowledgement) is still in trunk. Other non-tcllib licenses exist too: amazon-s3, mkdoc (BSD-3), snit, hook, generator, textutil/expander.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action keep open for a human decision (relicense, document it in devdoc/tcllib_license.man, or close as Won't Fix).
    • Suggested ticket comment comm still ships under the Open Group RI license. Resolving this needs a project decision, not a code change.
    ⬜781246ffff2003Support SSL connections in FTP packageRFE-OPEN (feasible but not small. It needs a socket-command option like pop3/smtp, AUTH TLS, PBSZ/PROT P, and TLS on the data connections too)

    Open ticket 781246ffff · RFE · ftp · filed 2003-08-01

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible but not small. It needs a socket-command option like pop3/smtp, AUTH TLS, PBSZ/PROT P, and TLS on the data connections too)

    • Module ftp 2.4.14
    • Tested code read. No TLS support in ftp.tcl. Its twins 781240 and 898235 are closed.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action keep open as RFE (or close as Won't fix if nobody intends to do FTPS)
    • Suggested ticket comment Still not supported. Explicit FTPS would need a -socketcmd-style hook plus AUTH TLS/PROT P handling for both control and data connections.
    ⬜773246ffff2003snit: Multi-delegation for optionsRFE-OPEN (author's resolution: use snit::macro / configuremethod)

    Open ticket 773246ffff · RFE · snit · filed 2003-07-17

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (author's resolution: use snit::macro / configuremethod)

    • Module snit 2.3.4
    • Tested -
    • Cause The author's 2004 comment says this is propagation, not delegation, and should be done with a snit::macro.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Rejected (per the author's 2004 comment)
    • Suggested ticket comment As Will noted, this is propagation rather than delegation and is best done with a -configuremethod or snit::macro. Closing.
    ⬜772430ffff2003snit: clean up error stacks, hide internals.RFE-OPEN (vague; low value)

    Open ticket 772430ffff · RFE · snit · filed 2003-07-16

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (vague; low value)

    • Module snit 2.3.4 / 1.4.3
    • Tested errorInfo of failing methods still shows snit internals (e.g. ::T2::Snit_methodm ... in snit 1, uplevel frames in snit 2).
    • Cause -
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Out of Date unless someone wants to take it on (2003 note from the original author, no concrete proposal)
    • Suggested ticket comment Old wish from snit's original author with no concrete specification. Closing unless someone has a specific proposal.
    ⬜726275ffff2003distinguish tcllib man pages from other packagesRFE-OPEN (still relevant: there is a concrete clash now)

    Open ticket 726275ffff · RFE · general request · filed 2003-04-23

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (still relevant: there is a concrete clash now)

    • Module installer / doc generation
    • Tested compared the installed names under idoc/man (installed flat into man/mann) with the man pages of Tcl 8.6/9.0/9.1 and the system. unicode.n (tcllib stringprep "unicode") clashes with Tcl 9.1's new unicode(n) command page. There were no other clashes with Tcl. Generic names (graph.n, queue.n, matrix.n, log.n, …) can still clash with other packages.
    • Cause installer.tcl copies idoc/man/files/modules/*/*.n into one mann directory under the page names.
    • Prototype none (naming policy; the immediate fix is renaming stringprep's unicode.man output, e.g. to tcllib_unicode like tcllib_ip)
    • Suggested action keep open, or file a specific bug for the unicode.n clash with Tcl 9.1 and close this general one
    • Suggested ticket comment Still relevant: tcllib's unicode.n (stringprep) now collides with Tcl 9.1's unicode(n). Suggest renaming that page like tcllib_ip.n.
    ⬜724730ffff2003Behaviour of struct::graph walkRFE-OPEN (not implemented; walk still visits every node at most once (graph_tcl.tcl visited array, graph/walk.c))

    Open ticket 724730ffff · RFE · struct :: graph · filed 2003-04-20

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (not implemented; walk still visits every node at most once (graph_tcl.tcl visited array, graph/walk.c))

    • Module struct::graph 2.4.4
    • Tested code inspection
    • Cause n/a. Unrestricted walks/trails need cycle limits and changes to both the Tcl and C implementations.
    • Prototype none (API extension in two implementations)
    • Suggested action keep open as RFE or close as Won't Fix; close 724822ffff as its duplicate
    • Suggested ticket comment walk still has path semantics (each node once). A "walk/trail" mode would need an API extension in both the Tcl and C implementations. No one is working on it.
    ⬜723677ffff2003ADD --> ::struct::tree -exists -- myTreeRFE-OPEN (trivial, but info commands already covers it, and with TclOO info object isa object)

    Open ticket 723677ffff · RFE · struct :: tree · filed 2003-04-18

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (trivial, but info commands already covers it, and with TclOO info object isa object)

    • Module struct::tree 2.1.3
    • Tested code review. No class-level existence check exists. tree exists checks nodes, not trees.
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected (use [llength [info commands myTree]])
    • Suggested ticket comment Tcl introspection (info commands myTree) answers this directly, and none of the other struct containers offer a class-level exists either. Closing.
    ⬜704171ffff2003doctools - ease of use - no quoting requiredRFE-OPEN (comment, arg etc. still take exactly one argument, see checker.tcl proc comment {text}. Unresolved design question from AK's 2004 c…

    Open ticket 704171ffff · RFE · doctools · filed 2003-03-15

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (comment, arg etc. still take exactly one argument, see checker.tcl proc comment {text}. Unresolved design question from AK's 2004 comment: is [arg a b c] one argument or three?)

    • Module doctools 1.6.1
    • Tested code reading of checker.tcl
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (needs a per-command semantics decision)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected, or keep open (maintainer decision)
    • Suggested ticket comment The markup commands still take a fixed number of arguments. AK asked in 2004 for a list of which commands should accept varargs, and with which meaning, and that never came. Closing for lack of a concrete proposal.
    ⬜704175ffff2003doctools - generalize: doctool .GT. manpage toolRFE-OPEN (manpage_begin title section version still requires all three arguments, checker.tcl:274. There is no alternative document-start command.)

    Open ticket 704175ffff · RFE · doctools · filed 2003-03-15

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (manpage_begin title section version still requires all three arguments, checker.tcl:274. There is no alternative document-start command.)

    • Module doctools 1.6.1
    • Tested code reading
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action keep open or close as Rejected (maintainer decision). Making section/version optional would be a small checker+backend change, but every backend uses them in headers.
    • Suggested ticket comment manpage_begin still requires title, section and version. Making section and version optional is feasible, but it touches every backend's header code.
    ⬜685073ffff2003expander - Input stackRFE-OPEN (feasible, moderate: expand would need to read input from a stack that macros can push onto. Not implemented. The submitter is the maintai…

    Open ticket 685073ffff · RFE · textutil :: expander · filed 2003-02-12

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (feasible, moderate: expand would need to read input from a stack that macros can push onto. Not implemented. The submitter is the maintainer, aku.)

    • Module textutil::expander 1.3.2
    • Tested code review of expander.tcl. Only a context (output) stack exists.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action keep open (or close as Won't Fix if nobody wants it)
    • Suggested ticket comment Not implemented yet. It is still feasible but needs changes to the expand loop.
    ⬜654762ffff2002doctools - Add backend 'docbook'RFE-OPEN (no docbook engine. Feasible with fmt.tmml/_xml.tcl as a template, but the requester himself suggested closing it in 2003.)

    Open ticket 654762ffff · RFE · doctools · filed 2002-12-16

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (no docbook engine. Feasible with fmt.tmml/_xml.tcl as a template, but the requester himself suggested closing it in 2003.)

    • Module doctools 1.6.1 (backends: desc html latex list markdown nroff null text tmml wiki)
    • Tested listed mpformats/fmt.*
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected (no demand for 20+ years)
    • Suggested ticket comment There is still no docbook backend. The requester suggested closing this in 2003 and nobody has asked since, so closing. A new engine modelled on fmt.tmml is welcome as a contribution.
    ⬜564071ffff2002doctools - multi-release SYNOPSIS conventionRFE-OPEN (still not possible: all [require] lines must be in the header and are printed as one block before all [call]s. It would need checker …

    Open ticket 564071ffff · RFE · doctools · filed 2002-06-03

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (still not possible: all [require] lines must be in the header and are printed as one block before all [call]s. It would need checker and backend changes to let require appear between calls.)

    • Module doctools 1.6.1
    • Tested a .man with require foo 1.0, require foo 1.1 and two calls, in the text format on 9.1. The SYNOPSIS lists both requires first, then both calls.
    • Cause checker.tcl allows require only in the header state. Backends collect requires and calls separately (c_held / synopsis).
    • Prototype none (RFE, needs a markup decision)
    • Suggested action close as Rejected (24 years old, and tcllib's own pages never adopted the convention), or keep open if the maintainer wants it
    • Suggested ticket comment doctools still prints all [require]s before all [call]s in the synopsis, so this convention cannot be expressed. Closing unless someone wants to design the markup.
    ⬜531541ffff2002Partial message constructionRFE-OPEN (still not implemented; pop3d's TOP still builds the whole message and does split/lrange, pop3d.tcl ::pop3d::Transfer)

    Open ticket 531541ffff · RFE · mime · filed 2002-03-18

    Full verdict

    RFE-OPEN (still not implemented; pop3d's TOP still builds the whole message and does split/lrange, pop3d.tcl ::pop3d::Transfer)

    • Module mime 1.7.2, pop3d
    • Tested code check
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (API addition)
    • Suggested action close as won't-fix (24 years old, works as is), or keep as low-priority RFE
    • Suggested ticket comment Still not implemented; pop3d builds the full message for TOP, which works. Closing as won't-fix unless someone needs it for large mailboxes.