Triage of all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15. Each ticket was checked against tcllib trunk on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5, using local servers for the network modules and a Windows 11 VM for Windows-only tickets. Outdated, superseded, duplicate and misfiled tickets are listed separately. Rows marked patch link to a prototype fix with a regression test (147 in all, in tcllib-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-16.
package require registry gives 1.4 and package versions registry lists only 1.4.FIXED in Tcl: on Windows Tcl 9.1.1, package require registry gives 1.4 and package versions registry lists only 1.4.
package require registry 1.0, autoproxy.tcl line 154)
package require registry 1.0 works.
package require registry gives 1.4 and package versions registry lists only 1.4.
FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (c87d543cef, 2024-09-13)
string is. c87d543cef ("Tcl 8/9 adaptions in tests") removed it from the expected message.
FIXED on trunk after 2.0 (cc4d362b78, 2026-08-04, "Integrated pbrooks-2026-08-critcl-fixes"; d69b5f3fd3 removed the conflicting SHA256Init/Update/Final declarations from sha256.h). NEEDS-WINDOWS to confirm.
FIXED (no failures on current Tcl)
sak test run on cmdline fileutil grammar_me snit tar with 9.1, 9.0 and 8.6: 2025 passed, 0 failed out of 2103 (the rest skipped) on each
Crc32_c itself…FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (9a3a6d56be, 2024-01-11). The critcl code moved out of crc32.tcl into crc32c.tcl. In 1.20 crc32.tcl defined Crc32_c itself and was also pulled in again via yencode's package require crc32, hence "redefinition of tcl__crc_Crc32_c".
package require Tcl 8.5 9)FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (758418619e, 2023-11-14, Rolf's Tcl 9 work integrated; installer now package require Tcl 8.5 9)
configure with Tcl 9 first on PATH (it picked /bin/tclsh9.0), then make install-libraries: completed and generated tcllib2.0/pkgIndex.tcl
Status now: Pending
DONE on trunk (8c56f46b22, 2026-01-30, mark: "added an example to the asn package's docs"; after tcllib 2.0, not in a release yet). asn.man's Examples section now has a full encode/decode example.
FIXED since tcllib 1.19 (fb859d7803, 2018-01-24)
$math::... variable references are left. The remaining relative math::exact::... names are command names, which TIP 278 did not change.
FIXED since tcllib 1.19 (d50864197b, 2018-01-24), plus the Tcl 9 port 22c749a4ef (2023, in tcllib 2.0)
$yaml::-style relative variable references remain.
yaml:: variable references were removed in d50864197b, and yaml passes its tests on Tcl 9.0/9.1. Closing.
DONE (657782a889 / 9073bd414a, 2018, ticket 83d674b2dd; option -tlsimport)
-tlsimport 1 does tls::import right after the socket opens (native TLS, e.g. port 465). The attached patch artifact is not in the repository.
smtp::sendmessage -tlsimport 1 (ticket 83d674b2dd, tcllib 1.20). Closing.
FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (25005159c5, merged a500ff9409, 2022-10-10). DUPLICATE of e23279c7d1 and 0dd2a66f08.
websocket::test without the protocol header.
validate now returns an empty protocol list when the header is absent.
DONE (httpd.man added in 5dd3f483bf/df153cb3ea, 2018-02, tcllib 1.19; now generated from the sources by build/build.tcl)
FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (bb98482e6f, 2024-09-13, "Tcl 9 portability fixes")
set library x; source snit2.tcl on 9.1/8.6 now works, and ::library is untouched. Old artifacts up to 2023 still had set library ... inside namespace eval ::snit::, and that mechanism fails on 8.6 (info exists ::snit::library → 0).
set instead of variable in snit.tcl/snit2.tcl; now variable library.
variable library.
FIXED since tcllib 1.20 (d5e2fcf04b, 2018-05-31: use /dev/urandom when it exists instead of nettool)
env PATH=/bin tclsh with uuid::uuid generate works on 9.1 and 8.6. Also, nettool cannot be loaded at all right now (see the pkgIndex typo above), so uuid never reaches nettool.
exec ifconfig in nettool (build/platform_unix_linux.tcl) is covered by tickets d879576438 and 9a21637273.
validate now always returns a protocols key. Also a D…FIXED since tcllib 2.0 (25005159c5, ticket 0dd2a66f08; merged in a500ff9409, 2022-10-10). validate now always returns a protocols key. Also a DUPLICATE of 0bd02c1bf8.
websocket::test with no Sec-WebSocket-Protocol header returns 1.
combine_relaxed, the isContainer setti…DONE (02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24, Tcllib 1.18). It brought json2huddle.tcl, the number/boolean/null types, combine_relaxed, the isContainer setting and the matching yaml changes.
FIXED since tcllib 1.19 (2c24d9d9c1, 2018-01-08: comm-6.0 now uses -ssl2 0 -ssl3 0 -tls1 1)
FIXED since tcllib 1.19 (c49c11b395 "Do not use ssl2 or ssl3 in tests", patthoyts, 2017-10-27, merged 048189d3a6). The test server was SSLv3-only, which modern OpenSSL rejects.
FIXED since tcllib 1.18 (f705e6446e, 2015-05-21, per aku's comment)
DONE (02ec11eeba "Merged huddle/yaml work - Updated to huddle 0.2, yaml 0.3.8", 2015-11-24. It was developed on branch huddle-a753cade83 and later updated in 5a516799b4, 2015-12-10)
huddle true/false/boolean (tag b) with JSON output true/false. huddle create now use…DONE (02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24, Tcllib 1.18). It added huddle true/false/boolean (tag b) with JSON output true/false. huddle create now uses dict semantics for duplicate keys.
huddle create a 1 a 2 gives HUDDLE {D {a {s 2}}} on trunk (1.17 gave {a {s 1} a {s 2}}). huddle jsondump [huddle create a [huddle boolean true]] gives {"a":true}. Checked on 9.1 and 8.6.
DONE (cd1a3ac12d, tcllib 1.17). Only the test cases were missing, and they are now written.
^ anchor is removed.
-casesensitivestrings 1, 6.3 quoted macro value)
FIXED since tcllib 1.18 (02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24). This is the same issue as 3315620fff.
huddle jsondump [huddle create a b c 00.34] gives {"a":"b","c":"00.34"} on 9.1 and 8.6. The attached patch (artifact 73c511b240) is not in the local repo, so it could not be compared, but its stated result now matches the trunk output.
huddle number.
error type is now documented in websocket.man together with connect, disconn…DONE (a500ff9409, 2022-10-10, tcllib 2.0) for the example given: the error type is now documented in websocket.man together with connect, disconnect, close and timeout.
test/upgrade context (577ed0d10b), are tracked separately.
error type and the other event types are documented now (since a500ff9409). Closing; specific gaps can get their own tickets.
DONE. Unused-variable/initialization parts went in with 5d35be9b3a (2014-08-11). The pointer-cast parts were done differently: (void*)(uintptr_t) with <stdint.h> in 4bc853f186 (2020-05-15, "Fixed all the warnings reported on Linux"), then 022eea6e5b (2024, Tcl 9) and 0b25980a00 (2026-10-02, Windows warnings).
FIXED since tcllib 1.18 (huddle 0.2 rewrite, 02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24)
huddle get [huddle create {a a} b] {a a} works on 9.1 and 8.6 trunk (also get_stripped, exists, nested paths). The tcllib-1-17 huddle.tcl (0.1.5) fails with key "{a a}" not known in dictionary.
_key_reflexive is gone)
huddle get $h {a a} works. Closing as fixed.
FIXED since tcllib 1.15 (2a9631a53b, 2012-03-30, ncgi 1.3.3). The ticket resolution is already "Fixed" but the status is still Open.
ncgi::reset "=x"; ncgi::nvlist gives anonymous x
huddle number.FIXED since tcllib 1.18 (02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24). Plain values are huddle strings and are always quoted; numbers need an explicit huddle number.
huddle jsondump [huddle create key 000000] gives {"key":"000000"} on 9.1 and 8.6 (1.17 gave 000000).
huddle number / huddle compile number validate with string is double, so huddle number 007 (also 0x10, Inf, " 12") still dumps invalid JSON. That is a different and narrower issue, left as is because yaml may rely on such tokens.
huddle number.
DONE (log::logsubst, ea802e332b, 2018-05-18, log 1.4, tcllib 1.20. Implemented by the same reporter as RFE 19607f927b)
::log::logsubst level msg with lazy substitution. Its tests check that suppressed levels do not substitute.
log::logsubst (subst-based, as suggested in the comments) via 19607f927b, log 1.4, tcllib 1.20.
FIXED since tcllib 1.18 (02ec11eeba, 2015-11-24, huddle 0.2 rewrite)
huddle jsondump [huddle create {a b} b c d] gives {"a b":"b","c":"d"} on trunk with 9.1 and 8.6, and on the tcllib-1-18 huddle.tcl. The tcllib-1-17 huddle.tcl still fails with key "{a b}" not known in dictionary.
FIXED since tcllib 1.17 (cd1a3ac12d, 2015-04-21; branch bibtex-071dbedcc8)
title = {A string {theory} test} now parses as a normal record on 9.1 and 8.6
^ anchor. ParseRecords now uses {^\s*string[^\{]*\{(.*)\}[^\}]*}.
FIXED since tcllib 1.19 (8b8f10e2bb, 2017-11-01, ticket c247ed5db4, merged 0826350f8d 2018-01-24)
ldap::MessageReceiver now has a partial branch for the sequence byte that just returns and waits for the next fileevent. It is present in tcllib-1-19 (ldap 1.9.2). CANNOT-TEST the original LDAPS server situation.
default branch, which reported a protocol error.
FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (2ba9a8f7a5, 2009-05-06, "md5c command was leaking a Tcl_Obj on each call")
FIXED since tcllib 1.9 (bd21455bc5, 2006-07-02, ncgi 1.3.1), the same fix as 1116123. The error message quoted ("dont know how to handle ...") comes from tclhttpd, not ncgi, so the reporter probably had an older ncgi bundled with tclhttpd.
Content-Type: application/x-www-form-urlencoded; charset=UTF-8 parses fine on 9.1 and 8.6
DONE (4b2ffb42f2, 2019-08-29, ticket 138d56dbaf, tcllib 1.20)
tcllibc when modules/tcllibc exists. make install-binaries (sak.tcl critcl) builds and installs it.
make install-binaries builds and installs it via critcl.
FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (3846dac25c, 2009-09-24)
tcl8.5only constraint, and repeat-4.5 uses a per-version result.
FIXED (the testsuite was adapted for 8.6's wrong#args messages long ago; tcllib trunk tests run clean on 8.6 and 9.x)
sak test run on trunk. 9.1: 26708 passed, 13 failed out of 27126. 8.6: 27038 passed, 4 failed out of 27445. None of the failures is a wrong#args message. The 9.1-only failures are crc (7, new binary "expected byte sequence" message), hook (2, changed -errorstack contents) and doctools2base msgcat-2.0, which fails on both versions; websocket (3) also fails on both.
tcltest::wrongNumArgs/tcl-version helpers now handle it.
FIXED since tcllib 1.11 (stack traces moved into per-version files, ChangeLog 2008-09-02)
DONE (1a2e9c5b7b, 2014-07-21, ticket c4b8162da5; inifile 0.3, in tcllib 1.17)
ini::open ?-encoding E? file ?mode? exists. Tests inifile-4.x cover it. b09616777a (2018) added encoding handling to commit/revert.
FIXED since tcllib 1.14 (ftpd 1.2.6, [Bug 3357765] passive-mode fix with PasvCheckAndWait, ChangeLog 2011-08-09)
dlist receives the channel. In 2008, List called Fs dlist right after PASV, before the client had connected, so the channel was still "". Remaining corner case: a LIST/NLST sent without any PORT/PASV still passes "" to fsCmd instead of replying 425.
::ftpd::List not waiting for the passive connection
fsCmd dlist.
FIXED (by Tcl: passes on 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 tip; still fails on 8.5)
stringprep.test -constraints knownBug passes 25/25 on 9.1, 9.0 and 8.6. On 8.5 nameprep-5 still fails: no non-BMP characters (U+1D7BB).
knownBug.
knownBug with a fullUnicode constraint (true when encoding convertfrom utf-8 yields U+1D7BB), so nameprep-5 runs on 8.6+/9.x and is skipped on 8.5. Passes on 9.1/8.6, skipped on 8.5.
DONE (ChangeLog 2007-01-25, FR 1614860)
-client is in sendmessage and documented in smtp.man.
smtp::sendmessage -client exists and is documented. It was added in January 2007 (FR 1614860). Closing.
FIXED since tcllib 1.11 (2008-03-15, per aku: spf, term, grammar_fa/fa_op, dns etc.; ChangeLogs cite SF 1826418). The other reports were artifacts of an outdated procheck.
##nagelfar pragmas), and sak validate exists.
FIXED since tcllib 1.11 (605bf758ee, 2007-10-24: "Changed handling of broken symbolic links ... They are now recognized and returned", fileutil 1.13.4; tests find-1.10.x)
DONE (mostly), otherwise OUTDATED
sak test run -l STEM writes STEM.log, STEM.summary, STEM.failures, STEM.skipped and STEM.none. The part about submitting to sf.net no longer applies (tickets are in fossil).
sak test run -l STEM now writes the detailed log and a separate failures list, which can be attached to a ticket. Closing.
[image name ?label?] markup. dtplite maps symbolic names to png/jpeg/pic/txt variants. Tcllib's own d…DONE (doctools 1.4.7, 2010-06-08, added the [image name ?label?] markup. dtplite maps symbolic names to png/jpeg/pic/txt variants. Tcllib's own docs, e.g. modules/pt/include/*.dia, keep diagrams as tklib diagram sources that are rendered to images.)
proc image, ChangeLog 2010-06-08)
DONE (term::ansi::code::ctrl, added with the term module in c45a25f68f 2006-07-11, before this RFE)
make test uses verbose batch mode when stdout is not a tty; make test_batch forces it)DONE (3ea92fe7fb, 2007-08-21: make test uses verbose batch mode when stdout is not a tty; make test_batch forces it)
make test uses the plain log when output is not a terminal, and make test_batch forces it. No configure option is needed.
make install runs install-binaries, i.e. sak.tcl critcl, which builds and installs tcllibc. devdoc/tcllib_installer.man ("Build & Insta…DONE (make install runs install-binaries, i.e. sak.tcl critcl, which builds and installs tcllibc. devdoc/tcllib_installer.man ("Build & Installation", parts/b_critcl.inc) documents building the accelerators.)
generate_c only if critcl is already loaded, or through tcllibc, which is the intended design.
make install now builds and installs tcllibc via critcl (install-binaries), and the installer guide documents how to build the accelerators. uuid picks up the C version from tcllibc.
FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (cff1860c31, 2008-12-17, logger 0.9, RFE 2381524)
${f}::debug foo bar baz printed [bar] [debug] 'baz' with tcllib 1.9, 1.10 and 1.11 (logger 0.7/0.8). With 1.12, 1.15, 1.19 and trunk on 8.6 and 9.1 it prints [foo] [debug] 'foo bar baz'.
-_logger::service marker that way.
FIXED since tcllib 1.11 (7b5c1024fa, 2008-02-29, comm 4.5.7, fix for SF 1861565)
comm::comm new test -port <busy> -listen 1 and comm::comm config -port <busy> both give "couldn't open socket: address already in use"; test comm-5.0 covers it
[info proc $chan]
FIXED since tcllib 1.21 (ce8dab3154, 2021-03-22)
DONE (8437472089, 2010-10-20, kennykb)
FIXED since tcllib 1.14 (52c11ba5ad, 2011-08-09, bug 3325112)
fconfigure -peername call in OpenControlConn was removed by that check-in, which is exactly the reporter's diagnosis.
DONE (logger::utils / logger::appender, 81c17070d3, 2005-09-28, tcllib 1.8)
logger::utils::applyAppender -appender console -serviceCmd $log -appenderArgs {-conversionPattern {\[%d\] \[%c\] \[%M\] \[%p\] %m}} prints [2026/11/15 01:06:52] [foo] [myproc] [warn] hello on 9.1 and 8.6. That includes the caller proc (%M), as the ticket asked. fileAppend -outputChannel covers the per-channel request in the comments.
FIXED since tcllib 1.9 (bd21455bc5, 2006-07-02, ncgi 1.3.1 "Fixed bug 547274": the nvlist content-type patterns became application/x-www-form-urlencoded* etc.)
ncgi::reset "a=b&c=d" "application/x-www-form-urlencoded; charset=UTF-8"; ncgi::nvlist gives a b c d on 9.1 and 8.6
[type], so multipart would lose its boundary.
DONE (-socketcmd tls::socket for pop3s in 1e4e56a154, 2009-04-13, pop3 1.7; STLS via -stls/-tls-callback in 38c311e999, 2011-01-23, pop3 1.8)
tls::import ... -ssl2 0 -ssl3 1 -tls1 1 -cipher SSLv3,TLSv1, which is dated and may fail against modern TLS 1.2+-only servers with OpenSSL 3.
-socketcmd tls::socket for pop3s (pop3 1.7) or -stls 1 for STARTTLS (pop3 1.8).
FIXED since tcllib 1.9 (ab08ecbe1c, 2006-01-18)
<p> is now a sibling of <h1>. The htmlparse.tcl before ab08ecbe1c makes <p> a child of <h1>; the version from ab08ecbe1c gives the right tree.
Reorder was too aggressive. ab08ecbe1c ("less aggressive", SF Patch 953854) fixed it.
<p> after <h1> is now its sibling.
ncgi::header ?type? ?name value ...? already existed in 2004, before this RFE was filed (it is in the 2004-05-04 revision 35934da2af); it p…DONE (ncgi::header ?type? ?name value ...? already existed in 2004, before this RFE was filed (it is in the 2004-05-04 revision 35934da2af); it prints Content-Type, extra headers and the pending Set-Cookie lines)
ncgi::header
(.*)=(.*) regexp was replaced by string first =)FIXED since tcllib 1.9 (6ad5a29080, 2006-07-02, ncgi 1.3.2; the greedy (.*)=(.*) regexp was replaced by string first =)
ncgi::reset "a=b=c&d==&=x&e=1" ""; ncgi::nvlist gives a b=c d = anonymous x e 1 on 9.1 and 8.6
=
FIXED since tcllib 1.6 (9bd4ab9e64, 2003-12-01)
^-?([0-9]+)( |-)?(.*)$ with the missing negation fixed, and the message (which includes the line) is only shown in VERBOSE mode. Normal servers (ftpd) parse fine.
[sectref id]. fmt.latex emits \label{id} after each \section and \ref{label} for se…DONE (doctools 1.3.4, 2008-05-15: (sub)section ids plus [sectref id]. fmt.latex emits \label{id} after each \section and \ref{label} for sectref.)
FIXED since tcllib 1.10 (cc984c045f, 2006-11-09, bug 1191607)
ftp::Quote $h HELP against ftpd returns the whole 214 multi-line reply (9.1).
DONE (3286b5637f 2013-02-15 "installer uses the embedded documentation instead of generating", then 888d8ab7b9/46a48af79f which moved the installed docs to idoc/; first release tcllib 1.16)
div/`…DONE (mostly). Since doctools 1.3.x (2008-05, ChangeLog "_html.tcl ... divisions a CSS can lock onto") the HTML output puts every part in a div/span with a doctools_* class. The engine parameters meta, header, footer, xref and raw let you add your own CSS. Section headings are now "Name"/"Description" in initial caps. You still cannot drop the Name/Description sections or change the tags.
class="doctools_section" etc. Read fmt.html __var.
meta parameter, so fonts, colors and heading styles are customizable with CSS. Further structural changes need a custom engine.
DONE (e69e86b94f, 2003-04-18, Arjen's optimisation procs; solveLinearProgram followed)
FIXED since tcllib 1.4 (0515c88443, 2002-08-06, SF bug 582668)
ftp::Get $h a.txt -variable v returns 1 with correct content in active and passive mode, on 9.1 and 8.6. The $dest check is now if {$ftp(inline) == 0}, exactly the fix suggested in the ticket.
mkdoc module + app added in tcllib 1.21, 8defde4552, 2022-04-28; also tepam::doc_gen for TEPAM procs)DONE (mkdoc module + app added in tcllib 1.21, 8defde4552, 2022-04-28; also tepam::doc_gen for TEPAM procs)
DONE (a C implementation of struct::graph, the main topic of the discussion, is in tcllib: modules/struct/graph/*.c, graph_c.tcl. Graph I/O formats are not part of struct.)
FIXED since ~tcllib 1.1/1.6 (the -retr-mode/size handling of 2001-07-31 and the binary/dot-unstuffing rework of 2003-11-18, see pop3 ChangeLog). The report was against pop3 1.2.
read (RetrFast); -retr-mode slow is the workaround. The pop3 test suite passes (44/45, the 1 skip is TLS).