Triage of all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15. Each ticket was checked against tcllib trunk on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5, using local servers for the network modules and a Windows 11 VM for Windows-only tickets. Outdated, superseded, duplicate and misfiled tickets are listed separately. Rows marked patch link to a prototype fix with a regression test (147 in all, in tcllib-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-16.
DUPLICATE of dcf333e549 (same bug; this report has the correct analysis and the same suggested fix, which prototypes/dcf333e549.patch implements, including its suggested tests)
WRONG-TRACKER (Tkhtml3 / BAWT distribution; not in tcllib or tklib). This is the same situation as sibling 0c118eed38 (tclvfs), which oehhar closed as Invalid.
-translation binary alone is the right fix.
Status now: Open
dns-tcp-partial-reads, not merged: Fix 187a6fa7ae, 022bca0ff5: the dns client did not handle TCP replies that arrive in several reads. Buffer until the 2-byte length has arrived, read the lenDUPLICATE of 187a6fa7ae (the same TcpEvent short-read bug, still present on trunk). The attachment dns.patch (679c38e68f…) is not in the local repository copy, so it could not be compared.
DUPLICATE of 935ac3b65b (same SHA256Init/Update/Final C2375 errors; fixed on trunk in cc4d362b78)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib diagrams; same text filed there as ffcd8611b8, still open; tklib e9c4eeae1f "diagrams not rendered proper" has a patch diagrams.diff, not applied)
geo::direction/geo::octant assuming the old canvas convention and requires only math::geometry 1.1.2.
DUPLICATE of f8e09da9dc (closed By Design; the documentation was updated in 3f868874e7, 2019-06-27)
pki::verify with an explicit algo compares the hash with the raw decrypted data, which matches pki::sign ... raw of a precomputed digest; pki.man now says to pass algo only for "raw" signatures. The behaviour is unchanged on trunk.
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 15b81478b8, 2018-12-27)
DUPLICATE of a0e091b25d (probably; fixed in tepam 0.5.1, 5b9813887f 2016-03-05, first released in tcllib 1.19)
cmd -help, cmd sub -help and ns::cmd -help all print correct help, with and without namespaces and with or without a main procedure. The a0e091b25d script (sub-procedure names wrong in DESCRIPTION) reproduces with tepam.tcl from tcllib-1-18 and is fixed on trunk.
OUTDATED (aku's 2016 "still active?" placeholder; the author says caching and pluggable markup engines live in his separate toadhttpd/clay projects. The "httpd 4.4" he announced in 2020 never reached tcllib: trunk is still 4.3.6)
package require Tcl 8.5 9; main1_83.tcl was removed; tcllib 2.x needs 8.5+)OUTDATED (both snit loaders now package require Tcl 8.5 9; main1_83.tcl was removed; tcllib 2.x needs 8.5+)
zlib stream put "" "buffer error" was fixed in the Tcl core in 8.6.5, released 2016; tcllib is not involved)OUTDATED (the zlib stream put "" "buffer error" was fixed in the Tcl core in 8.6.5, released 2016; tcllib is not involved)
unzip -t is OK. A bare $z put "" after $z get fails the same way, again only before 8.6.5.
$zlib put $data with an empty string on the last read. Tcl before 8.6.5 raised Z_BUF_ERROR for that (Tcl ticket 25842c161f).
if {$data ne ""} guard would help only on Tcl 8.6.0-8.6.4, and no test can fail on supported Tcl versions)
zlib stream put error was fixed in Tcl 8.6.5. mkzip works with files whose size is a multiple of 4096 on 8.6.5+ and 9.x. Closing.
OUTDATED (FireTcl embeds Tcl into Firefox through the XUL/XULRunner extension mechanism, which Firefox removed in version 57 (2017). Nobody ever started integrating it: no firetcl branch or check-in in tcllib, and the etoyoc sandbox mentioned in the comment is gone.)
SUPERSEDED (by 4bc853f186 2020-05-15 "fixed all warnings (gcc 5.4)", 022eea6e5b 2024-01-21 Tcl 9 work, 0de126b30d/385cc65bf9/0b25980a00 2026-10 warning fixes)
rde_param_query_lstop now returns its value (param.c:428). The review branch tkt-5613c718c2-cwarnings was never merged. critcl is not installed here, so no build.
(long int). That truncates on Win64, where intptr_t should be used as on line 428.
OUTDATED (2015 request driven by taolib/odie, which never went into tcllib. The "kettle" branch that was agreed on was never started. aku explained that a new module only needs an entry in support/installation/modules.tcl.)
object/array/string) and huddle jsondump). The undocumented json::dict2json still exists,…SUPERSEDED (by json::write (documented generator, object/array/string) and huddle jsondump). The undocumented json::dict2json still exists, with quoting disabled (if {0 && …}).
OUTDATED (SourceForge download page; releases are now on core.tcl-lang.org)
OUTDATED (2012 patch against the 2006 CVS installer.tcl; it no longer applies. DESTDIR is handled by Makefile.in passing $(DESTDIR) in all paths. Installing packages as .tm is still not supported; that would need a fresh RFE.)
OUTDATED (SourceForge-era tracker/home page; tcllib now uses core.tcl-lang.org/tcllib with Fossil tickets)
http::config -zip (http 2.9.0, Tcl 8.6.9).WRONG-TRACKER (Tcl). DONE there: http::config -zip (http 2.9.0, Tcl 8.6.9).
http::config on 8.6 (http 2.9.9), 9.0 and 9.1 (2.10.3) shows -zip 1. Also checked old builds: http 2.8.9 (8.6.5) lacks it, http 2.9.0 (8.6.9) has it.
http::config -zip 0 disables requesting compressed responses.
OUTDATED (the gdocs example uses Google ClientLogin and Documents List API 3.0, which Google shut down in 2015. The suggested accountType change is moot.)
string trim in 2treeCallback)DUPLICATE of 715193ffff (same string trim in 2treeCallback)
<pre> x </pre> loses its spaces on 9.1 and 8.6. Test 5.3 of the 715193 prototype covers <pre>.
2treeCallback, string trim $textBehindTheTag.
pre a special case)
<pre> included.
Status now: Pending (Out of Date)
WRONG-TRACKER (BWidget has its own repository; already Pending/Out of Date since 2013)
json2huddle (modules/yaml), which keeps types; json.man now documents the type loss and points to typed-json, b96bdd2…SUPERSEDED (by huddle::json json2huddle (modules/yaml), which keeps types; json.man now documents the type loss and points to typed-json, b96bdd24d5 / 2b2bcd7ecf, 2026-01-27)
package require dict any more)OUTDATED (Tcl 8.4 support dropped; tcllib requires 8.5+; there is no package require dict any more)
if {$::tcl_version < 8.5} branch remains in ::yaml::_parseTimestamp; harmless.)
DUPLICATE of 2680202fff (same md5c leak, reported with tcllibc of 1.11.x, which predates the fix); FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (2ba9a8f7a5)
md5::md5 testdata loop: no growth on 9.1/8.6
OUTDATED (Iocpsock is unmaintained, Tcl 8.5+ sockets on Windows are fine; since comm 4.6 the -socketcmd option lets users plug in any socket command)
_set_scroll still enters the auto branch when `…WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is Open in tklib. The suggested patch has not been applied: _set_scroll still enters the auto branch when sb(lock) is set.)
update idletasks with lock=1. A nested call re-grids the scrollbar, recurses, and resets lock to 0 on the way out, so the outer lock is lost and the calls can recurse without end.
if {$sb(auto) && !$sb(lock)}.
OUTDATED (about an old third-party starkit build and Tcl 8.5.2 tclkit. The sdarchive is defunct, and tcllib does not ship a .kit.)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket 2346118fff is Open in the tklib tracker. The limitation is still present: canvas_sqmap.tcl delegates all methods except raise/lower/scan/xview/yview to the hull unfiltered, so find/gettags/etc. expose the internal canvas::sqmap::cells image items and tag.)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there) / OUTDATED: plothist.test no longer exists. The core was a Tk panic ("TkpGetFontFromAttributes: cannot get any font") on Solaris 8 displaying to Exceed, a font problem of that X server, not a plotchart bug.
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 2008, ctext 3.2)
update, 5 times: no background errors. ctext's destroy handler cancels commentsAfterId/highlightAfterId/blinkAfterId.
DUPLICATE of 1811890fff
key lines are dropped on trunk, 9.1/8.6)
=
OUTDATED (pregistry is only an internal sak package, consistently 0.1 in index and source. The 1.0 came from an unrelated package in ActiveState's teapot repository, which is gone.)
package provide both say 0.1. It is not installed as a tcllib package.
-socketcmd tls::socket also defaults the port to 995)SUPERSEDED (by -socketcmd, 1e4e56a154, 2009-04-13, pop3 1.7: -socketcmd tls::socket also defaults the port to 995)
-socketcmd tls::socket (port 995 by default).
OUTDATED (tkchat, not tcllib)
::Plotchart::createHorizontalBarchart measures every y label with `font mea…WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Already DONE in tklib: ::Plotchart::createHorizontalBarchart measures every y label with font measure and sets config($w,margin,left) to the widest label + 5. This is the approach the patch proposed.
DUPLICATE of 892318ffff (open RFE "ftp - site to site transfer support"; aku already linked them in 2008)
SUPERSEDED (by log::logsubst, ea802e332b, 2018-05-18, log 1.4, tcllib 1.20)
log::logsubst debug {[info script]} substitutes only when debug is not suppressed. if {![log::lvIsSuppressed debug]} {...} has always been possible too.
log::logsubst debug {... [cmd] ...} (log 1.4, tcllib 1.20): the substitution runs only when the level is active. log::lvIsSuppressed also works for arbitrary code.
det, added in dfb98177e3, 2009-04-06, by Michael Baudin; matrix rank was never added)SUPERSEDED (determinant via LU: det, added in dfb98177e3, 2009-04-06, by Michael Baudin; matrix rank was never added)
DUPLICATE of 548540ffff (same diagnosis and same one-line patch as the 2007 comment there)
::ftp::Timeout sets state.control to 1
shtmlview::doctools package renders doctools documents in a Tk shtmlview widget, through HTML)SUPERSEDED (tklib's shtmlview::doctools package renders doctools documents in a Tk shtmlview widget, through HTML)
DUPLICATE of 1627877fff (identical submission, already Closed)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Largely DONE in tklib: the controlwidget module provides meter, rdial, tachometer, voltmeter and vertical_meter widgets.
configure && make install passes explicit paths.)OUTDATED (old Apple system Tcl, tcllib 1.9. /System is read-only under SIP anyway. configure && make install passes explicit paths.)
bindir from the first non-zipfs auto_path entry ([file dirname $libdir]/bin). With Apple's /System Tcl this would still give /System/Library/bin. Homebrew/MacPorts Tcl gives sensible paths.
./configure --prefix=... && make install or the installer's -app-path option.
puts "$::auto_path", puts $path, puts "libdir is $libdir") in that same block.
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib). The same ticket 1475562fff also exists in tklib's tracker and is Open there. It is too vague to act on.
$plot bindplot and $plot bindlast, and the docs …WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). The request is DONE in tklib: Plotchart now has $plot bindplot and $plot bindlast, and the docs say to use canvas tags on the elements for other bindings (plotchart.man, section "Interaction").
bindplot/bindlast and canvas tags on plot elements. Closing.
SUPERSEDED (by the logger trace facility, logger 0.7, SF patch 1530725, 2006-08-18, tcllib 1.9)
${log}::trace (proc entry/leave tracing). The 2008 comment already noted the overlap.
${log}::trace) since tcllib 1.9, which covers this.
file tempfile, TIP 210, as dgp noted in 2009. fileutil::tempfile already creates the file with {RDWR CREAT EXCL} and mod…SUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 file tempfile, TIP 210, as dgp noted in 2009. fileutil::tempfile already creates the file with {RDWR CREAT EXCL} and mode 0600.)
OUTDATED (tkchat app/Tclers chat infrastructure; Ffidl-based Aqua hack from 2005; the starkit link on mini.net is dead). All other ~90 tkchat tickets in this tracker are closed.
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. installer.tcl is gone, but modules/ctext still contains the standalone install.tcl ("Run this with the wish…"), test.c, long_test_script and ad-hoc ctext_test*.tcl scripts.)
fossil ls of tklib trunk modules/ctext
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. Still true: in a tklib trunk checkout every plotchart file, including plotchart.man, NEWS, pkgIndex.tcl and *.test, has the executable bit, as do 176 files repo-wide.)
find -perm -u+x
fossil commit that clears the x bit on non-scripts would fix it.
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. The bug described in the mail still exists: ctext removes all tags except _cComment from the affected range on insert/delete, so user tags vanish. The attached modified code, which prefixes ctext's own tags with __ctext, was never applied.)
insert end "abc def" mytag, inserting or deleting one character in that line removes mytag completely.
foreach tag [tag names] {if not _cComment: tag remove}
search -all, linemap rewrite, tile frame, personal tweaks) was ne…WRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there). The 2005 patch (highlight85 with search -all, linemap rewrite, tile frame, personal tweaks) was never applied, and against ctext 3.3 it is obsolete: ctext has a different linemap now (smooth scrolling patch 3285751 accepted), and the author already warned that it mixes in personal changes.
-all searches and the patch's procs. Not present.
search -all idea might be worth redoing.
jpeg in 7cdc13439b, 2009-02-06; support/installation/modules…OUTDATED (the exif module was deprecated and excluded from installation in favour of jpeg in 7cdc13439b, 2009-02-06; support/installation/modules.tcl Exclude exif. The patch was never applied. jpeg::formatExif has vendor MakerNote handling for Canon/Nikon/Fuji/Olympus.)
-errorcmd, called for inaccessible directories; the callbacks were fixed in 39120747d3, 2015-04-22)SUPERSEDED (by fileutil::traverse -errorcmd, called for inaccessible directories; the callbacks were fixed in 39120747d3, 2015-04-22)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Also OUTDATED: the use case was the wikit Tk GUI on MacOS 9 without Itcl. Itcl now ships with Tcl, and ttk buttons cover the need.
OUTDATED (about the TclPro debugger, an obsolete tool; renaming the commands would break the API)
SUPERSEDED (by tepam; getKnownOptions already leaves unknown options in the list)
OUTDATED (2003 patch series against profiler 0.2.1, with Tcl 8.3 alias-mode code; never applied)
profiler::add/remove pattern, watchForNewProcs, canonical names via namespace origin, call-level lists) exists. The 8.3 Handler path it builds on is legacy now that Tcl 8.5+ is required.
tooltip package supports -image since tklib ticket 29705…WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; widget::balloonhelp no longer exists there. The equivalent tklib tooltip package supports -image since tklib ticket 2970577fff, Closed.)
-image. The same ticket 777061ffff is also Open in the tklib tracker.
DUPLICATE of 724730ffff (same wiki page 8787 use case: multiple visits per node in walk)
visited) doesn't work with the C implementation.
tmE (Tcl vs critcl), so tcllib's ow…OUTDATED (the walk tests still expect one exact order, but each implementation has its own expected order via tmE (Tcl vs critcl), so tcllib's own C implementation is covered. cgraph, the third-party implementation that motivated the ticket, is defunct.)
OUTDATED (file never existed in the tcllib fossil repo; tklib's widget module has no digraph.tcl)
OUTDATED (Tcl 8.2-era packaging issue)
if {![package vsatisfies [package provide Tcl] 8.5 9]} {return}, and logger.tcl has package require Tcl 8.5 9.
OUTDATED (tkchat). The storage part was done in 2006 (~/.tkchat_msgs, mbox format); the viewer was never added.
OUTDATED (about Tcl 8.2/8.3-era compatibility. Tcllib now requires Tcl 8.5+ and tcltest 2, and the harness was reworked into sak/support/devel/all.tcl.)
args)SUPERSEDED (by tepam, tcllib's procedure argument parser; plus getoptions/getKnownOptions work on args)
WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is also Open in the tklib tracker. tklib has no splash or fullscreen package, and the fullscreen part is covered by Tk 8.5+ wm attributes -fullscreen.)
OUTDATED (2002 request for a BWidget demo app; targets wish8.3; wrong project)
OUTDATED (example-app UI complaints from 2002; the reporter never answered the 2004 question about which parts concern the ftp package)
Disconnect now resets the File menu entries (entryconfigure 0/1), so that part looks addressed. The selection reset on Connect and the upload cd behaviour are app design, with no ftp-package bug identified.
WRONG-TRACKER (Tk/tklib. The same SF ticket in the tklib tracker was closed "Not Applicable Here", and Tk 480944ffff "Add console support to Tk / Unix" is Closed/Duplicate. Unix wish 8.6/9.1 still has no console command, though console.tcl is shipped.)
info commands console is empty, and $tk_library/console.tcl exists.
{*} and tcl::mathfunc::max/min; math::statistics::max/min/mean take a list)SUPERSEDED (Tcl 8.5 {*} and tcl::mathfunc::max/min; math::statistics::max/min/mean take a list)
math::statistics::max {1 5 3} gives 5.0, and expr {max(1,5,3)} gives 5 (9.1).
math::max {*}$list or tcl::mathfunc::max avoid eval.
OUTDATED (an open-ended pointer to a list of schemes, not a concrete request)
/?text search.OUTDATED (tkchat). The request was in fact implemented there: split/history pane in tkchat rev 1.341 (2006, per treincke) and /?text search.
arcs/nodes argument parsing is now a shared helper (CheckE in graph_tcl.tcl), and there is a parallel cr…SUPERSEDED (struct::graph 2.x rewrite: arcs/nodes argument parsing is now a shared helper (CheckE in graph_tcl.tcl), and there is a parallel critcl C implementation (graph/methods.c), where cmdline is not applicable)
_arcs, _nodes)
SUPERSEDED (by the nns nano-nameserver modules: nameserv, nameserv::server, nameserv::auto, as noted by aku in 2008)
clock add, full format/scan), tcllib's clock::iso8601/clock::rfc2822, and the calendar module)SUPERSEDED (by the Tcl 8.5 clock rewrite (clock add, full format/scan), tcllib's clock::iso8601/clock::rfc2822, and the calendar module)
Excluded in support/installation/modules.tcl, as the 2003 comment says.
SUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 coroutines / coroutine::util await; callbacks can set variables waited on with await; Thread has real semaphores for threads)
coroutine::util await, which waits for a write to any of several variables)SUPERSEDED (by coroutines in Tcl 8.6 and coroutine::util await, which waits for a write to any of several variables)
pipe; Tcl 8.6 has chan pipe, open | and exec improvements; dup 429384 was closed in 2001)OUTDATED (depends on TclX pipe; Tcl 8.6 has chan pipe, open | and exec improvements; dup 429384 was closed in 2001)