Open tcllib tickets: Outdated, superseded, duplicate

Triage of all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15. Each ticket was checked against tcllib trunk on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5, using local servers for the network modules and a Windows 11 VM for Windows-only tickets. Outdated, superseded, duplicate and misfiled tickets are listed separately. Rows marked patch link to a prototype fix with a regression test (147 in all, in tcllib-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-16.

Outdated, superseded, duplicate 80

⬜04b8e4fb3c2026buildmessage/copymessage emit Content-Transfer-Encoding header twiceDUPLICATE of dcf333e549 (same bug; this report has the correct analysis and the same suggested fix, which prototypes/dcf333e549.patch implements, i…

Open ticket 04b8e4fb3c · Bug · mime · filed 2026-10-08

Full verdict

DUPLICATE of dcf333e549 (same bug; this report has the correct analysis and the same suggested fix, which prototypes/dcf333e549.patch implements, including its suggested tests)

  • Module mime 1.7.2
  • Tested see dcf333e549
  • Cause see dcf333e549
  • Prototype prototypes/dcf333e549.patch
  • Suggested action close as duplicate of dcf333e549 once that is fixed (or fix under both)
  • Suggested ticket comment Duplicate of dcf333e549; the proposed fix there is the one suggested here, with the suggested tests.
⬜0e69b86c2e2025No longer "-encoding binary" in Tcl 9.0WRONG-TRACKER (Tkhtml3 / BAWT distribution; not in tcllib or tklib). This is the same situation as sibling 0c118eed38 (tclvfs), which oehhar closed…

Open ticket 0e69b86c2e · Bug · A Category Is Missing · filed 2025-10-07

Full verdict

WRONG-TRACKER (Tkhtml3 / BAWT distribution; not in tcllib or tklib). This is the same situation as sibling 0c118eed38 (tclvfs), which oehhar closed as Invalid.

  • Module none (Tkhtml3 hv3-0.1.tm is not part of tcllib)
  • Tested grep of tcllib/tklib trees for tkhtml/hv3: no hits
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (not tcllib code)
  • Suggested action close as Invalid / Third party
  • Suggested ticket comment hv3-0.1.tm belongs to Tkhtml3, not tcllib, so please report it to Tkhtml3 (or BAWT, which ships it). There, -translation binary alone is the right fix.
🔧022bca0ff52024Fix for dns: can't read "state(size)": no such element in arrayDUPLICATE of 187a6fa7ae (the same TcpEvent short-read bug, still present on trunk). The attachment dns.patch (679c38e68f…) is not in the local repo…

Open ticket 022bca0ff5 · Patch · dns · filed 2024-04-22

🔧 Since triage (updated 2026-11-16)

Status now: Open

  • 🔧 2026-11-15 check-in 79c8191d74 on dns-tcp-partial-reads, not merged: Fix 187a6fa7ae, 022bca0ff5: the dns client did not handle TCP replies that arrive in several reads. Buffer until the 2-byte length has arrived, read the len
  • 💬 2026-11-16 serhiy.storchaka: Duplicate of 187a6fa7ae; proposed fix in branch dns-tcp-partial-reads. The attachment isn't in my clone, so I could not compare it with that fix.
Full verdict

DUPLICATE of 187a6fa7ae (the same TcpEvent short-read bug, still present on trunk). The attachment dns.patch (679c38e68f…) is not in the local repository copy, so it could not be compared.

  • Module dns 1.6.1
  • Tested see 187a6fa7ae
  • Prototype see prototypes/187a6fa7ae.patch
  • Suggested action close as Duplicate after the fix for 187a6fa7ae is applied
  • Suggested ticket comment Same bug as 187a6fa7ae. A proposed fix with a test is tracked there.
⬜89960459062023tcllib 1.21 compilation fails on Windows and MSVCDUPLICATE of 935ac3b65b (same SHA256Init/Update/Final C2375 errors; fixed on trunk in cc4d362b78)

Open ticket 8996045906 · Bug · (unused) · filed 2023-08-24

Full verdict

DUPLICATE of 935ac3b65b (same SHA256Init/Update/Final C2375 errors; fixed on trunk in cc4d362b78)

  • Module sha256c
  • Tested see 935ac3b65b
  • Cause same as 935ac3b65b
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Duplicate
  • Suggested ticket comment Duplicate of 935ac3b65b. The conflicting declarations were removed from sha256.h on trunk in cc4d362b78.
⬜de2be80fd22021direction and octant delete the minus sign lead to diagram display bugsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib diagrams; same text filed there as ffcd8611b8, still open; tklib e9c4eeae1f "diagrams not rendered proper" has a patch diagram…

Open ticket de2be80fd2 · Bug · math :: geometry · filed 2021-06-16

Full verdict

WRONG-TRACKER (tklib diagrams; same text filed there as ffcd8611b8, still open; tklib e9c4eeae1f "diagrams not rendered proper" has a patch diagrams.diff, not applied)

  • Module math, math::geometry 1.4.2
  • Tested code inspection. The sign change was intentional (fb4812f82b, math::geometry 1.4.0, 2020-09-20). math_geometry.man has had a "COORDINATE SYSTEM" section since then, saying y points up and angles are counter-clockwise, and that Tk canvas differs. tklib modules/diagrams (basic.tcl, point.tcl) still calls geo::direction/geo::octant assuming the old canvas convention and requires only math::geometry 1.1.2.
  • Prototype none (fix belongs in tklib diagrams)
  • Suggested action close here as a duplicate of tklib ffcd8611b8 / Third Party; handle in tklib (review e9c4eeae1f's patch)
  • Suggested ticket comment The change in math::geometry 1.4 was intentional and is documented in the COORDINATE SYSTEM section. tklib's diagram package must adapt; tracked in tklib ffcd8611b8 and e9c4eeae1f (with patch).
⬜bbdff172a32020::pki::verify always returns false when "algo" argument is providedDUPLICATE of f8e09da9dc (closed By Design; the documentation was updated in 3f868874e7, 2019-06-27)

Open ticket bbdff172a3 · Bug · pki · filed 2020-02-12

Full verdict

DUPLICATE of f8e09da9dc (closed By Design; the documentation was updated in 3f868874e7, 2019-06-27)

  • Module pki 0.22
  • Tested code read: pki::verify with an explicit algo compares the hash with the raw decrypted data, which matches pki::sign ... raw of a precomputed digest; pki.man now says to pass algo only for "raw" signatures. The behaviour is unchanged on trunk.
  • Cause by design (rkeene, 2020-02-18): algo is only meant for raw signatures without a PKCS#1 v1.5 DigestInfo.
  • Prototype none (not a bug)
  • Suggested action close as Duplicate of f8e09da9dc. The reporter's point that "algo" is a misleading name could become a docs RFE.
  • Suggested ticket comment Same as f8e09da9dc: by design, and the docs now say to pass algo only when the signature was made with "raw". Closing as duplicate.
⬜8c91e468002018Error when bindplot on createLogXYPlotWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 15b81478b8, 2018-12-27)

Open ticket 8c91e46800 · Bug · (unused) · filed 2018-12-10

Full verdict

WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 15b81478b8, 2018-12-27)

  • Module tklib Plotchart 2.7.0
  • Tested tklib trunk on Xvfb, wish9.1 and wish8.6: bindplot/bindlast on createLogXYPlot and bindplot on createXLogYPlot all succeed
  • Cause missing methodProc entries and unset scaling($w,eventobj) in tklib plotbind.tcl/plotchart.tcl; the reporter's patch was applied in tklib
  • Prototype none (not tcllib)
  • Suggested action close as Fixed (resolution is already "Not Applicable Here")
  • Suggested ticket comment Plotchart is in tklib, where this was fixed in 15b81478b8 (2018-12-27). bindplot/bindlast work on log plots with current tklib. Closing.
⬜a8218fdfc02017Incorrect help for commands / subcommandsDUPLICATE of a0e091b25d (probably; fixed in tepam 0.5.1, 5b9813887f 2016-03-05, first released in tcllib 1.19)

Open ticket a8218fdfc0 · Bug · tepam · filed 2017-09-01

Full verdict

DUPLICATE of a0e091b25d (probably; fixed in tepam 0.5.1, 5b9813887f 2016-03-05, first released in tcllib 1.19)

  • Module tepam 0.5.4
  • Tested the two attached patches (pkgIndex.tcl.patch, tepam.tcl.patch) are missing from the repository (their blobs are not in tcllib.fossil), so I could not compare them. On trunk with 9.1 and 8.6, cmd -help, cmd sub -help and ns::cmd -help all print correct help, with and without namespaces and with or without a main procedure. The a0e091b25d script (sub-procedure names wrong in DESCRIPTION) reproduces with tepam.tcl from tcllib-1-18 and is fixed on trunk.
  • Cause The reporter had "0.5", which is tcllib 1.18 / Debian. The subcommand help bug in 0.5.0 (every DESCRIPTION entry shows the last sub-procedure's name) is a0e091b25d. The 0.5.1 fix also bumped pkgIndex.tcl, which matches the two attachments.
  • Prototype none (already fixed; regression test tepam-bug_fixes.help_text exists in bug_fixes.test)
  • Suggested action close as Fixed (or Duplicate of a0e091b25d), unless the submitter shows a case that still fails
  • Suggested ticket comment This looks like a0e091b25d, fixed in tepam 0.5.1 (tcllib 1.19). The attached patches are no longer available. Please reopen with an example if command/subcommand help is still wrong in current tepam.
⬜809e351f412016httpd - Make conversion (tml, md) extensible, and cacheableOUTDATED (aku's 2016 "still active?" placeholder; the author says caching and pluggable markup engines live in his separate toadhttpd/clay projects…

Open ticket 809e351f41 · Bug · httpd · filed 2016-11-14

Full verdict

OUTDATED (aku's 2016 "still active?" placeholder; the author says caching and pluggable markup engines live in his separate toadhttpd/clay projects. The "httpd 4.4" he announced in 2020 never reached tcllib: trunk is still 4.3.6)

  • Module httpd 4.3.6
  • Tested code review only (content.file handles .md and .tml with fixed code paths and no cache hooks)
  • Cause -
  • Prototype none (RFE outside the module's scope, according to its author)
  • Suggested action close as Rejected (out of scope; see toadhttpd)
  • Suggested ticket comment No 4.4 rework ever reached tcllib, and the author keeps caching and pluggable markup engines in toadhttpd/clay. Closing as out of scope for tcllib's httpd.
⬜faf551c7782016snit doesn't work in Tcl 8.3OUTDATED (both snit loaders now package require Tcl 8.5 9; main1_83.tcl was removed; tcllib 2.x needs 8.5+)

Open ticket faf551c778 · Bug · snit · filed 2016-10-03

Full verdict

OUTDATED (both snit loaders now package require Tcl 8.5 9; main1_83.tcl was removed; tcllib 2.x needs 8.5+)

  • Module snit 2.3.4 / 1.4.3
  • Tested code inspection
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Out of Date
  • Suggested ticket comment Tcl 8.3 is no longer supported by tcllib or snit (minimum 8.5). Closing.
⬜deef12251a2016Depending on input file, zipfile:mkzip::mkzip may raise errorOUTDATED (the zlib stream put "" "buffer error" was fixed in the Tcl core in 8.6.5, released 2016; tcllib is not involved)

Open ticket deef12251a · Bug · zip · filed 2016-02-03

Full verdict

OUTDATED (the zlib stream put "" "buffer error" was fixed in the Tcl core in 8.6.5, released 2016; tcllib is not involved)

  • Module zipfile::mkzip 1.2.4 (requires Tcl 8.6)
  • Tested mkzip on a 2400 KiB file (600*4096 bytes, so the streaming branch ends with an empty read). Tcl 8.6.0 and 8.6.4 fail with "buffer error" and leave a broken zip. 8.6.5, 8.6.6, 8.6 tip and 9.1 work, and unzip -t is OK. A bare $z put "" after $z get fails the same way, again only before 8.6.5.
  • Cause mkzip.tcl add_file_to_archive streaming loop calls $zlib put $data with an empty string on the last read. Tcl before 8.6.5 raised Z_BUF_ERROR for that (Tcl ticket 25842c161f).
  • Prototype none (a one-line if {$data ne ""} guard would help only on Tcl 8.6.0-8.6.4, and no test can fail on supported Tcl versions)
  • Suggested action close as Fixed (in the Tcl core). Optionally add the guard if 8.6.0-8.6.4 still matter.
  • Suggested ticket comment The empty zlib stream put error was fixed in Tcl 8.6.5. mkzip works with files whose size is a multiple of 4096 on 8.6.5+ and 9.x. Closing.
⬜0c3a46d24c2015New FireTcl libraryOUTDATED (FireTcl embeds Tcl into Firefox through the XUL/XULRunner extension mechanism, which Firefox removed in version 57 (2017). Nobody ever st…

Open ticket 0c3a46d24c · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2015-08-22

Full verdict

OUTDATED (FireTcl embeds Tcl into Firefox through the XUL/XULRunner extension mechanism, which Firefox removed in version 57 (2017). Nobody ever started integrating it: no firetcl branch or check-in in tcllib, and the etoyoc sandbox mentioned in the comment is gone.)

  • Module none (proposed new module "firetcl")
  • Tested searched the tcllib timeline and branches for "firetcl". Nothing found.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (RFE)
  • Suggested action close as Out of Date
  • Suggested ticket comment FireTcl depends on the XUL extension mechanism, which Firefox dropped in version 57. Nobody started the integration, so closing.
⬜5613c718c22015Fixing compiler-warnings in C-codeSUPERSEDED (by 4bc853f186 2020-05-15 "fixed all warnings (gcc 5.4)", 022eea6e5b 2024-01-21 Tcl 9 work, 0de126b30d/385cc65bf9/0b25980a00 2026-10 war…

Open ticket 5613c718c2 · Bug · Build System & Testing · filed 2015-05-28

Full verdict

SUPERSEDED (by 4bc853f186 2020-05-15 "fixed all warnings (gcc 5.4)", 022eea6e5b 2024-01-21 Tcl 9 work, 0de126b30d/385cc65bf9/0b25980a00 2026-10 warning fixes)

  • Module C accelerators (pt rde_critcl, struct graph/tree, md5, sha1…)
  • Tested code reading. The broken rde_param_query_lstop now returns its value (param.c:428). The review branch tkt-5613c718c2-cwarnings was never merged. critcl is not installed here, so no build.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Fixed/Out of Date
  • Suggested ticket comment The real bug (missing return in rde_param_query_lstop) and the warnings were fixed by later warning cleanups and the Tcl 9 work. The 2015 branch is obsolete.
  • Note param.c:568 still casts a pointer through (long int). That truncates on Win64, where intptr_t should be used as on line 428.
⬜8c587f8f332015Combine information from /support into /modulesOUTDATED (2015 request driven by taolib/odie, which never went into tcllib. The "kettle" branch that was agreed on was never started. aku explained…

Open ticket 8c587f8f33 · RFE · Development Tools · filed 2015-01-06

Full verdict

OUTDATED (2015 request driven by taolib/odie, which never went into tcllib. The "kettle" branch that was agreed on was never started. aku explained that a new module only needs an entry in support/installation/modules.tcl.)

  • Module devtools / sak
  • Tested timeline search (no kettle branch or check-ins)
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Out of date / Rejected
  • Suggested ticket comment Nobody started the kettle evaluation, and the modules that drove the request never came into tcllib. Adding a module still only needs an entry in support/installation/modules.tcl. Closing.
⬜3610482fff2013Symmetrical json conversionSUPERSEDED (by json::write (documented generator, object/array/string) and huddle jsondump). The undocumented json::dict2json still exists,…

Open ticket 3610482fff · Patch · json · filed 2013-04-10

Full verdict

SUPERSEDED (by json::write (documented generator, object/array/string) and huddle jsondump). The undocumented json::dict2json still exists, with quoting disabled (if {0 && …}).

  • Module json 1.3.6
  • Tested code read
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Superseded. Optionally remove or deprecate the half-working undocumented dict2json/list2json/string2json helpers.
  • Suggested ticket comment Generating JSON with type control is covered by json::write (and huddle). A key list cannot make the conversion symmetric in general (strings vs numbers vs nested values).
⬜3555995fff2012Latest version download link on sourceforgeOUTDATED (SourceForge download page; releases are now on core.tcl-lang.org)

Open ticket 3555995fff · Bug · A Category Is Missing · filed 2012-08-10

Full verdict

OUTDATED (SourceForge download page; releases are now on core.tcl-lang.org)

  • Module SourceForge project page
  • Tested none
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Out of date
  • Suggested ticket comment This was about the SourceForge download link. Releases are now distributed from core.tcl-lang.org. Closing.
⬜3495830fff2012First go at installing tcl modulesOUTDATED (2012 patch against the 2006 CVS installer.tcl; it no longer applies. DESTDIR is handled by Makefile.in passing $(DESTDIR) in all paths. I…

Open ticket 3495830fff · Patch · A Category Is Missing · filed 2012-02-29

Full verdict

OUTDATED (2012 patch against the 2006 CVS installer.tcl; it no longer applies. DESTDIR is handled by Makefile.in passing $(DESTDIR) in all paths. Installing packages as .tm is still not supported; that would need a fresh RFE.)

  • Module installer.tcl
  • Tested compared the attached diff with the current installer.tcl (no minstall, no -destdir; Makefile uses $(DESTDIR))
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (patch obsolete)
  • Suggested action close as Out of date
  • Suggested ticket comment The patch no longer applies to the reworked installer. DESTDIR is supported through the Makefile. Installing as Tcl modules would need a new RFE.
⬜3495047fff2012Bug Database link broken on tcllib home pageOUTDATED (SourceForge-era tracker/home page; tcllib now uses core.tcl-lang.org/tcllib with Fossil tickets)

Open ticket 3495047fff · Bug · A Category Is Missing · filed 2012-02-27

Full verdict

OUTDATED (SourceForge-era tracker/home page; tcllib now uses core.tcl-lang.org/tcllib with Fossil tickets)

  • Module SourceForge project page
  • Tested none
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Out of date
  • Suggested ticket comment This was about the SourceForge home page. The project has moved to core.tcl-lang.org/tcllib. Closing.
⬜3163579fff2011Add a -compress config option for ::http::configWRONG-TRACKER (Tcl). DONE there: http::config -zip (http 2.9.0, Tcl 8.6.9).

Open ticket 3163579fff · RFE · None · filed 2011-01-21

Full verdict

WRONG-TRACKER (Tcl). DONE there: http::config -zip (http 2.9.0, Tcl 8.6.9).

  • Module http (Tcl core, not tcllib)
  • Tested http::config on 8.6 (http 2.9.9), 9.0 and 9.1 (2.10.3) shows -zip 1. Also checked old builds: http 2.8.9 (8.6.5) lacks it, http 2.9.0 (8.6.9) has it.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Fixed / wrong tracker.
  • Suggested ticket comment http belongs to Tcl. Since http 2.9.0 (Tcl 8.6.9), http::config -zip 0 disables requesting compressed responses.
⬜3141163fff2010Login at hosted accounts in Rest API gdocs APIOUTDATED (the gdocs example uses Google ClientLogin and Documents List API 3.0, which Google shut down in 2015. The suggested accountType change is…

Open ticket 3141163fff · Bug · None · filed 2010-12-21

Full verdict

OUTDATED (the gdocs example uses Google ClientLogin and Documents List API 3.0, which Google shut down in 2015. The suggested accountType change is moot.)

  • Module rest (modules/rest/gdocs example)
  • Tested modules/rest/gdocs still points to https://www.google.com/accounts/ClientLogin.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested action close as Out of Date. Optionally remove or mark the dead gdocs (and similar) example interfaces.
  • Suggested ticket comment Google retired ClientLogin and the Documents List API, so the gdocs example cannot work at all anymore. Closing.
⬜3091244fff2010parsing doesn't respect pre tag & trims trailing whitespacesDUPLICATE of 715193ffff (same string trim in 2treeCallback)

Open ticket 3091244fff · Bug · htmlparse · filed 2010-10-20

Full verdict

DUPLICATE of 715193ffff (same string trim in 2treeCallback)

  • Module htmlparse 1.2.3
  • Tested <pre> x </pre> loses its spaces on 9.1 and 8.6. Test 5.3 of the 715193 prototype covers <pre>.
  • Cause htmlparse.tcl 2treeCallback, string trim $textBehindTheTag.
  • Prototype see prototypes/715193ffff.patch (removes the trim entirely, as Rolf and Martin suggested here, instead of making pre a special case)
  • Suggested action close as Duplicate when 715193 is resolved
  • Suggested ticket comment Same cause as 715193; the proposed fix there keeps all PCDATA whitespace, <pre> included.
⏳3004301fff2010Bad images.tgz files in CVSWRONG-TRACKER (BWidget has its own repository; already Pending/Out of Date since 2013)

Open ticket 3004301fff · Bug · bwidget · filed 2010-05-19 · Pending (resolved, waiting for confirmation)

⏳ Since triage (updated 2026-11-16)

Status now: Pending (Out of Date)

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (BWidget has its own repository; already Pending/Out of Date since 2013)

    • Module BWidget (not in tcllib or tklib)
    • Tested neither tcllib.fossil nor tklib.fossil has any bwidget/keramik files
    • Cause CVS binary handling. The CVS era is long gone.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment BWidget is maintained in its own repository and CVS is gone. Closing.
    ⬜2967134fff2010json2dict improvements index json arrays in dictSUPERSEDED (by huddle::json json2huddle (modules/yaml), which keeps types; json.man now documents the type loss and points to typed-json, b96bdd2…

    Open ticket 2967134fff · RFE · json · filed 2010-03-10

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by huddle::json json2huddle (modules/yaml), which keeps types; json.man now documents the type loss and points to typed-json, b96bdd24d5 / 2b2bcd7ecf, 2026-01-27)

    • Module json 1.3.6
    • Tested code/doc read
    • Cause by design json2dict drops type info
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Rejected/Superseded
    • Suggested ticket comment json2dict is intentionally untyped (now documented). For type-preserving parsing use huddle::json (json2huddle) or the typed-json module linked from the json docs.
    ⬜2910682fff2009yaml's dict package needsOUTDATED (Tcl 8.4 support dropped; tcllib requires 8.5+; there is no package require dict any more)

    Open ticket 2910682fff · Bug · yaml · filed 2009-12-08

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (Tcl 8.4 support dropped; tcllib requires 8.5+; there is no package require dict any more)

    • Module yaml 0.4.2 / huddle 0.5
    • Tested grep of yaml.tcl/huddle.tcl; yaml tests pass on 9.1 and 8.6.
    • Cause n/a. (One dead if {$::tcl_version < 8.5} branch remains in ::yaml::_parseTimestamp; harmless.)
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Outdated
    • Suggested ticket comment Tcllib now requires Tcl 8.5+, and yaml/huddle no longer load the dict package. Closing.
    ⬜2847341fff2009leak in md5 (critcl)DUPLICATE of 2680202fff (same md5c leak, reported with tcllibc of 1.11.x, which predates the fix); FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (2ba9a8f7a5)

    Open ticket 2847341fff · Bug · md5 · filed 2009-08-30

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 2680202fff (same md5c leak, reported with tcllibc of 1.11.x, which predates the fix); FIXED since tcllib 1.12 (2ba9a8f7a5)

    • Module md5 2.0.9 / md5c 0.12
    • Tested same hand-built md5c run as 2680202fff, including the md5::md5 testdata loop: no growth on 9.1/8.6
    • Cause see 2680202fff
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Fixed (duplicate of 2680202fff)
    • Suggested ticket comment Same leak as 2680202fff, fixed in 2ba9a8f7a5 before tcllib 1.12. No growth with the current md5c.
    ⬜2787849fff2009Can comm use Iocpsock under WindowsOUTDATED (Iocpsock is unmaintained, Tcl 8.5+ sockets on Windows are fine; since comm 4.6 the -socketcmd option lets users plug in any socket command)

    Open ticket 2787849fff · RFE · comm · filed 2009-05-06

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (Iocpsock is unmaintained, Tcl 8.5+ sockets on Windows are fine; since comm 4.6 the -socketcmd option lets users plug in any socket command)

    • Module comm 4.7.3
    • Tested code reading (comm.man -socketcmd)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Since comm 4.6 a custom socket command can be given with -socketcmd, so an alternative socket implementation can be used without changes to comm. Closing.
    ⬜2499978fff2009Infinite bug on widget::scrolledwindowWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is Open in tklib. The suggested patch has not been applied: _set_scroll still enters the auto branch when `…

    Open ticket 2499978fff · Bug · tklib · filed 2009-01-11

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is Open in tklib. The suggested patch has not been applied: _set_scroll still enters the auto branch when sb(lock) is set.)

    • Module tklib widget::scrolledwindow 1.2.1
    • Tested code review of tklib trunk modules/widget/scrollw.tcl:_set_scroll. Not reproduced: the reporter saw it only on Windows XP, and the trace shows a BWidget Tree inside the scrolledwindow.
    • Cause _set_scroll calls update idletasks with lock=1. A nested call re-grids the scrollbar, recurses, and resets lock to 0 on the way out, so the outer lock is lost and the calls can recurse without end.
    • Prototype none (tklib; NEEDS-WINDOWS to reproduce)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here. In tklib, consider the one-line guard if {$sb(auto) && !$sb(lock)}.
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The identical ticket is open in the tklib tracker, and the suggested guard is still not applied there.
    ⬜2370853fff2008Wrong path added to auto_pathOUTDATED (about an old third-party starkit build and Tcl 8.5.2 tclkit. The sdarchive is defunct, and tcllib does not ship a .kit.)

    Open ticket 2370853fff · Bug · None · filed 2008-12-01

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (about an old third-party starkit build and Tcl 8.5.2 tclkit. The sdarchive is defunct, and tcllib does not ship a .kit.)

    • Module n/a (third-party tcllib.kit from equi4 sdarchive)
    • Tested no kit packaging in the tcllib sources.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date.
    • Suggested ticket comment This concerns the old sdarchive tcllib.kit, which tcllib itself does not produce. Closing as out of date.
    ⬜2346118fff2008canvas::sqmap limitationsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket 2346118fff is Open in the tklib tracker. The limitation is still present: canvas_sqmap.tcl delegates all meth…

    Open ticket 2346118fff · Bug · tklib · filed 2008-11-25

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket 2346118fff is Open in the tklib tracker. The limitation is still present: canvas_sqmap.tcl delegates all methods except raise/lower/scan/xview/yview to the hull unfiltered, so find/gettags/etc. expose the internal canvas::sqmap::cells image items and tag.)

    • Module tklib canvas::sqmap 0.3.1
    • Tested code review of tklib trunk modules/canvas/canvas_sqmap.tcl
    • Cause n/a (design TODO)
    • Prototype none (tklib)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here. The tklib copy stays open.
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The identical ticket is open in the tklib tracker, so closing the tcllib copy.
    ⬜2168846fff2008tklib test suite for plotchart generates coreWRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there) / OUTDATED: plothist.test no longer exists. The core was a Tk panic ("TkpGetFontFromAttributes: canno…

    Open ticket 2168846fff · Bug · tklib :: plotchart · filed 2008-10-15

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there) / OUTDATED: plothist.test no longer exists. The core was a Tk panic ("TkpGetFontFromAttributes: cannot get any font") on Solaris 8 displaying to Exceed, a font problem of that X server, not a plotchart bug.

    • Module tklib plotchart
    • Tested tklib trunk plotchart.test (42/42) and plotcontour.test (2/2) pass on 9.1 and 8.6 under Xvfb
    • Cause environment (X server without usable fonts)
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here, and in tklib as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment plothist.test is gone and the plotchart tests pass. The core dump was a Tk font panic caused by that X server. Closing as out of date.
    ⬜2059415fff2008ctext error when widget destroyedWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 2008, ctext 3.2)

    Open ticket 2059415fff · Bug · None · filed 2008-08-19

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; fixed there in 2008, ctext 3.2)

    • Module ctext (tklib) 3.3
    • Tested on Xvfb :116 with wish 9.1 and 8.6, tklib trunk ctext.tcl. Created a ctext, inserted highlighted text, destroyed it, then update, 5 times: no background errors. ctext's destroy handler cancels commentsAfterId/highlightAfterId/blinkAfterId.
    • Cause n/a (fixed)
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Fixed (wrong tracker). The same ticket is also Open in the tklib tracker; close it there too.
    • Suggested ticket comment Fixed in tklib's ctext 3.2 (2008): pending after-callbacks are cancelled on destroy. Not reproducible with current ctext.
    ⬜2037560fff2008support keys with no = signDUPLICATE of 1811890fff

    Open ticket 2037560fff · RFE · inifile · filed 2008-08-04

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 1811890fff

    • Module inifile 0.3.3
    • Tested same as 1811890fff (bare key lines are dropped on trunk, 9.1/8.6)
    • Cause ini.tcl:_loadfile ignores lines without =
    • Prototype see prototypes/1811890fff.patch
    • Suggested action close as Duplicate of 1811890fff
    • Suggested ticket comment Same request as 1811890fff, which has a patch. Tracking it there.
    ⬜1931567fff2008pregistry version problemOUTDATED (pregistry is only an internal sak package, consistently 0.1 in index and source. The 1.0 came from an unrelated package in ActiveState's …

    Open ticket 1931567fff · Bug · A Category Is Missing · filed 2008-04-01

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (pregistry is only an internal sak package, consistently 0.1 in index and source. The 1.0 came from an unrelated package in ActiveState's teapot repository, which is gone.)

    • Module pregistry 0.1 (sak-internal, support/devel/sak/registry)
    • Tested grep for pregistry: only support/devel/sak. pkgIndex and package provide both say 0.1. It is not installed as a tcllib package.
    • Cause version clash in ActiveTcl teapot, not in tcllib
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment pregistry is an internal sak helper (0.1 in both index and code). The conflicting 1.0 came from ActiveState's teapot, which no longer exists. Closing.
    ⬜1906274fff2008pop3 module doesn't support pop3sSUPERSEDED (by -socketcmd, 1e4e56a154, 2009-04-13, pop3 1.7: -socketcmd tls::socket also defaults the port to 995)

    Open ticket 1906274fff · Bug · pop3 · filed 2008-03-03

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by -socketcmd, 1e4e56a154, 2009-04-13, pop3 1.7: -socketcmd tls::socket also defaults the port to 995)

    • Module pop3 1.11
    • Tested code read. Leftovers from the attached patch: the "To many arguments" typo (pop3.tcl:284) is still there, and the -stls check reports "Argument to -tls has to be boolean" (pop3.tcl:270).
    • Prototype none (only the two cosmetic message fixes remain)
    • Suggested action close as Fixed (by -socketcmd), optionally fixing the two error messages
    • Suggested ticket comment pop3s is supported since pop3 1.7 via -socketcmd tls::socket (port 995 by default).
    ⬜1890987fff2008Encoded chars in rss feedsOUTDATED (tkchat, not tcllib)

    Open ticket 1890987fff · Patch · app: tkchat · filed 2008-02-11

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (tkchat, not tcllib)

    • Module none (tkchat_rss.tcl, tclapps)
    • Tested n/a
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment tkchat is not part of tcllib; closing as out of date.
    ⬜1891251fff2008Support of long ylabels in horizontal bar chartsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Already DONE in tklib: ::Plotchart::createHorizontalBarchart measures every y label with `font mea…

    Open ticket 1891251fff · Patch · tklib: plotchart · filed 2008-02-11

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Already DONE in tklib: ::Plotchart::createHorizontalBarchart measures every y label with font measure and sets config($w,margin,left) to the widest label + 5. This is the approach the patch proposed.

    • Module tklib plotchart (Plotchart 2.7.0)
    • Tested read tklib trunk modules/plotchart/plotchart.tcl, lines 1917-1925.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (already implemented)
    • Suggested action close here as Wrong tracker. Close the tklib copy as Fixed.
    • Suggested ticket comment Implemented in tklib's Plotchart: the left margin of horizontal bar charts now follows the widest y label. Closing.
    ⬜1813193fff2007ftp - FXP - cross server transfer not going through clientDUPLICATE of 892318ffff (open RFE "ftp - site to site transfer support"; aku already linked them in 2008)

    Open ticket 1813193fff · RFE · ftp · filed 2007-10-14

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 892318ffff (open RFE "ftp - site to site transfer support"; aku already linked them in 2008)

    • Module ftp 2.4.14
    • Tested code check. There is no FXP/site-to-site support. ftp::Quote can send raw PASV/PORT, but the API has no way to start the transfer on two sessions together.
    • Cause n/a (feature)
    • Prototype none (RFE; FXP is also disabled on most servers because of FTP bounce)
    • Suggested action close as Duplicate of 892318, keep that one as the single RFE
    • Suggested ticket comment Same request as [892318], which stays open as the RFE; closing this one as a duplicate.
    ⬜1779624fff2007Execute a command only when debug is active.SUPERSEDED (by log::logsubst, ea802e332b, 2018-05-18, log 1.4, tcllib 1.20)

    Open ticket 1779624fff · RFE · log · filed 2007-08-22

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by log::logsubst, ea802e332b, 2018-05-18, log 1.4, tcllib 1.20)

    • Module log 1.5
    • Tested code and docs. log::logsubst debug {[info script]} substitutes only when debug is not suppressed. if {![log::lvIsSuppressed debug]} {...} has always been possible too.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date.
    • Suggested ticket comment Use log::logsubst debug {... [cmd] ...} (log 1.4, tcllib 1.20): the substitution runs only when the level is active. log::lvIsSuppressed also works for arbitrary code.
    ⬜1735135fff2007tcllib math::linearalgebra additions (matrix stuff)SUPERSEDED (determinant via LU: det, added in dfb98177e3, 2009-04-06, by Michael Baudin; matrix rank was never added)

    Open ticket 1735135fff · RFE · math · filed 2007-06-11

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (determinant via LU: det, added in dfb98177e3, 2009-04-06, by Michael Baudin; matrix rank was never added)

    • Module math, math::linearalgebra 1.1.7
    • Tested code inspection. The submitted code was on a pastebin (rafb.net) and is gone.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date. Matrix rank can be computed from determineSVD.
    • Suggested ticket comment det (LU based, as suggested here) is in linearalgebra since 2009. The original paste is no longer available. A rank command could be a new RFE.
    ⬜1709566fff2007crash during ftp::GetDUPLICATE of 548540ffff (same diagnosis and same one-line patch as the 2007 comment there)

    Open ticket 1709566fff · Bug · ftp · filed 2007-04-29

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 548540ffff (same diagnosis and same one-line patch as the 2007 comment there)

    • Module ftp 2.4.14
    • Tested reproduced the Start_Time error on Get timeout (9.1, 8.6), see 548540
    • Cause ::ftp::Timeout sets state.control to 1
    • Prototype prototypes/548540ffff.patch (test ftp-timeout-1.1 covers this crash)
    • Suggested action close as Duplicate of 548540
    • Suggested ticket comment Same issue as [548540]; the patch there applies your change and adds a test for the Get crash.
    ⬜1695129fff2007doctools - Add backend 'Tk'SUPERSEDED (tklib's shtmlview::doctools package renders doctools documents in a Tk shtmlview widget, through HTML)

    Open ticket 1695129fff · RFE · doctools · filed 2007-04-05

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (tklib's shtmlview::doctools package renders doctools documents in a Tk shtmlview widget, through HTML)

    • Module doctools 1.6.1; tklib shtmlview::doctools
    • Tested checked tklib trunk modules/shtmlview (shtmlview-doctools.man)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date / Fixed (via tklib)
    • Suggested ticket comment tklib's shtmlview::doctools package now displays doctools documents in a Tk widget, which covers this use case without a separate tagged-text backend.
    ⬜1627892fff2007Networking: what about SSH ??DUPLICATE of 1627877fff (identical submission, already Closed)

    Open ticket 1627892fff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2007-01-04

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 1627877fff (identical submission, already Closed)

    • Module none
    • Tested ticket comparison
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Duplicate
    • Suggested ticket comment Duplicate of 1627877fff.
    ⬜1580085fff2006tklib - Dial meter items for canvasWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Largely DONE in tklib: the controlwidget module provides meter, rdial, tachometer, voltmeter and ver…

    Open ticket 1580085fff · RFE · tklib: request for new module · filed 2006-10-18

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Largely DONE in tklib: the controlwidget module provides meter, rdial, tachometer, voltmeter and vertical_meter widgets.

    • Module tklib (request for a new module)
    • Tested listed tklib trunk modules/controlwidget.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close here as Wrong tracker. In tklib, close as Fixed (covered by controlwidget) unless canvas *items* specifically are still wanted.
    • Suggested ticket comment Belongs to tklib, where the controlwidget package now provides dial and meter widgets. Closing the tcllib copy.
    ⬜1571751fff2006[OSX] Install paths for tcllib 1.9OUTDATED (old Apple system Tcl, tcllib 1.9. /System is read-only under SIP anyway. configure && make install passes explicit paths.)

    Open ticket 1571751fff · Bug · Installer · filed 2006-10-05

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (old Apple system Tcl, tcllib 1.9. /System is read-only under SIP anyway. configure && make install passes explicit paths.)

    • Module installer.tcl (default paths)
    • Tested code read. installer.tcl still derives bindir from the first non-zipfs auto_path entry ([file dirname $libdir]/bin). With Apple's /System Tcl this would still give /System/Library/bin. Homebrew/MacPorts Tcl gives sensible paths.
    • Cause installer.tcl ~line 296-310 heuristic
    • Prototype none (cannot test macOS)
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment Apple's system Tcl is deprecated and /System is read-only nowadays. Use ./configure --prefix=... && make install or the installer's -app-path option.
    • Side note installer.tcl has leftover debug output (puts "$::auto_path", puts $path, puts "libdir is $libdir") in that same block.
    ⬜1475562fff2006improved handling of incorrect callsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib). The same ticket 1475562fff also exists in tklib's tracker and is Open there. It is too vague to act on.

    Open ticket 1475562fff · RFE · tklib: plotchart · filed 2006-04-24

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib). The same ticket 1475562fff also exists in tklib's tracker and is Open there. It is too vague to act on.

    • Module tklib plotchart (Plotchart 2.7.0 in tklib trunk)
    • Tested none (no concrete case is given).
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (no concrete bug)
    • Suggested action close here as Wrong tracker. In tklib, close as Outdated unless someone gives a concrete case.
    • Suggested ticket comment Plotchart is part of tklib, and the same ticket is open in tklib's tracker. Closing the tcllib copy.
    ⬜1475567fff2006interaction with elements of the plotsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). The request is DONE in tklib: Plotchart now has $plot bindplot and $plot bindlast, and the docs …

    Open ticket 1475567fff · RFE · tklib: plotchart · filed 2006-04-24

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). The request is DONE in tklib: Plotchart now has $plot bindplot and $plot bindlast, and the docs say to use canvas tags on the elements for other bindings (plotchart.man, section "Interaction").

    • Module tklib plotchart (Plotchart 2.7.0)
    • Tested read tklib trunk plotchart.man and plotchart.tcl.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close here as Wrong tracker. Close the tklib copy as Fixed.
    • Suggested ticket comment Plotchart lives in tklib. It now supports interaction through bindplot/bindlast and canvas tags on plot elements. Closing.
    ⬜1427220fff2006TraceLog: Debugging helperSUPERSEDED (by the logger trace facility, logger 0.7, SF patch 1530725, 2006-08-18, tcllib 1.9)

    Open ticket 1427220fff · RFE · None · filed 2006-02-08

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by the logger trace facility, logger 0.7, SF patch 1530725, 2006-08-18, tcllib 1.9)

    • Module n/a (proposed new package; the attachment is not in the repo)
    • Tested logger.man documents ${log}::trace (proc entry/leave tracing). The 2008 comment already noted the overlap.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date / Rejected.
    • Suggested ticket comment The logger package provides proc-level tracing (${log}::trace) since tcllib 1.9, which covers this.
    ⬜1409177fff2006more secure alternative to [tempfile]SUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 file tempfile, TIP 210, as dgp noted in 2009. fileutil::tempfile already creates the file with {RDWR CREAT EXCL} and mod…

    Open ticket 1409177fff · RFE · fileutil · filed 2006-01-18

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 file tempfile, TIP 210, as dgp noted in 2009. fileutil::tempfile already creates the file with {RDWR CREAT EXCL} and mode 0600.)

    • Module fileutil 1.16.4
    • Tested read TempFile on trunk
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Superseded
    • Suggested ticket comment Tcl 8.6's [file tempfile] creates and opens the file atomically. fileutil::tempfile keeps its name-returning API (with O_EXCL, 0600) for compatibility.
    ⬜1376903fff2005tkchat - aqua mods - set app name + unhide on alertOUTDATED (tkchat app/Tclers chat infrastructure; Ffidl-based Aqua hack from 2005; the starkit link on mini.net is dead). All other ~90 tkchat ticke…

    Open ticket 1376903fff · Patch · app: tkchat · filed 2005-12-09

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (tkchat app/Tclers chat infrastructure; Ffidl-based Aqua hack from 2005; the starkit link on mini.net is dead). All other ~90 tkchat tickets in this tracker are closed.

    • Module none (tkchat was never in the tcllib repository; it lived in tclapps)
    • Tested tcllib repo history: no tkchat files ever
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment tkchat is not part of tcllib (it was in tclapps), and this 2005 Ffidl/Aqua patch is obsolete. Closing.
    ⬜1346299fff2005ctext module dir contains obsolete filesWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. installer.tcl is gone, but modules/ctext still contains the standalone install.tcl ("Run this with th…

    Open ticket 1346299fff · Bug · tklib :: ctext · filed 2005-11-02

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. installer.tcl is gone, but modules/ctext still contains the standalone install.tcl ("Run this with the wish…"), test.c, long_test_script and ad-hoc ctext_test*.tcl scripts.)

    • Module tklib ctext 3.3
    • Tested fossil ls of tklib trunk modules/ctext
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (tklib)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here. In tklib, remove install.tcl (and maybe move the test scripts).
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The identical ticket is open there, and install.tcl is still present in tklib's modules/ctext.
    ⬜1346295fff2005plotchart files in release have wrong unix permissionsWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. Still true: in a tklib trunk checkout every plotchart file, including plotchart.man, NEWS, pkgIndex.t…

    Open ticket 1346295fff · Bug · tklib :: plotchart · filed 2005-11-02

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. Still true: in a tklib trunk checkout every plotchart file, including plotchart.man, NEWS, pkgIndex.tcl and *.test, has the executable bit, as do 176 files repo-wide.)

    • Module tklib plotchart
    • Tested fresh tklib trunk checkout, find -perm -u+x
    • Cause the exec bit is recorded in the fossil manifest
    • Prototype none (tklib)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here. In tklib, a fossil commit that clears the x bit on non-scripts would fix it.
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The identical ticket is open there, and the plotchart files still carry the x bit in tklib trunk.
    ⬜1167772fff2005code/block expansionWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. The bug described in the mail still exists: ctext removes all tags except _cComment from the affected…

    Open ticket 1167772fff · Patch · tklib: ctext · filed 2005-03-21

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. Same ticket Open there. The bug described in the mail still exists: ctext removes all tags except _cComment from the affected range on insert/delete, so user tags vanish. The attached modified code, which prefixes ctext's own tags with __ctext, was never applied.)

    • Module tklib ctext 3.3
    • Tested tklib trunk ctext under Xvfb, wish 9.1 and 8.6. After insert end "abc def" mytag, inserting or deleting one character in that line removes mytag completely.
    • Cause ctext.tcl instance insert/delete (lines ~375, 400, 461): foreach tag [tag names] {if not _cComment: tag remove}
    • Prototype none (tklib)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here. In tklib, keep open as a real bug (remove only ctext's highlight tags).
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The identical ticket is open there. ctext 3.3 still strips user tags on insert/delete.
    ⬜1167797fff20058.5 speed improvement via -allWRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there). The 2005 patch (highlight85 with search -all, linemap rewrite, tile frame, personal tweaks) was ne…

    Open ticket 1167797fff · Patch · tklib: ctext · filed 2005-03-21

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib, same ticket Open there). The 2005 patch (highlight85 with search -all, linemap rewrite, tile frame, personal tweaks) was never applied, and against ctext 3.3 it is obsolete: ctext has a different linemap now (smooth scrolling patch 3285751 accepted), and the author already warned that it mixes in personal changes.

    • Module tklib ctext 3.3
    • Tested grepped tklib ctext.tcl for -all searches and the patch's procs. Not present.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (tklib)
    • Suggested action close here as Not Applicable Here, and in tklib as Out of Date. Only the search -all idea might be worth redoing.
    • Suggested ticket comment This is tklib. The patch targets ctext 3.1, mixes in personal tweaks, and no longer applies to ctext 3.3. Closing as out of date.
    ⬜1161942fff2005Adds most EXIF-2.2 tags to exif.tclOUTDATED (the exif module was deprecated and excluded from installation in favour of jpeg in 7cdc13439b, 2009-02-06; support/installation/modules…

    Open ticket 1161942fff · Patch · exif · filed 2005-03-12

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (the exif module was deprecated and excluded from installation in favour of jpeg in 7cdc13439b, 2009-02-06; support/installation/modules.tcl Exclude exif. The patch was never applied. jpeg::formatExif has vendor MakerNote handling for Canon/Nikon/Fuji/Olympus.)

    • Module exif 1.1.4
    • Tested compared the attached unidiff with trunk exif.tcl (vendor makerNote dispatch, UserComment, 0xA408.. tags absent)
    • Prototype none (deprecated module, 344-line patch without test images)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment The exif package is deprecated (not installed since 2009); use the jpeg package, which handles EXIF 2.2 tags and several vendor maker notes.
    ⬜1114498fff2005Change 'find' API to allow an error handlerSUPERSEDED (by fileutil::traverse -errorcmd, called for inaccessible directories; the callbacks were fixed in 39120747d3, 2015-04-22)

    Open ticket 1114498fff · RFE · fileutil · filed 2005-02-02

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by fileutil::traverse -errorcmd, called for inaccessible directories; the callbacks were fixed in 39120747d3, 2015-04-22)

    • Module fileutil 1.16.4, fileutil::traverse 0.7
    • Tested read traverse.tcl/traverse.man on trunk
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Fixed/Superseded
    • Suggested ticket comment Use fileutil::traverse with -errorcmd (and -filter/-prefilter). It provides the requested error handler. fileutil::find stays as it is.
    ⬜971076ffff2004snitbutton widgetWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Also OUTDATED: the use case was the wikit Tk GUI on MacOS 9 without Itcl. Itcl now ships with Tcl, a…

    Open ticket 971076ffff · RFE · tklib: request for new module · filed 2004-06-11

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; the copy there is Open). Also OUTDATED: the use case was the wikit Tk GUI on MacOS 9 without Itcl. Itcl now ships with Tcl, and ttk buttons cover the need.

    • Module tklib (request for a new module)
    • Tested none
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close here as Wrong tracker. Close in tklib as Outdated.
    • Suggested ticket comment This request belongs to tklib, and its use case (wikit on MacOS 9 without Itcl) no longer exists. Closing.
    ⬜932516ffff2004html - many procedures not compatible with prodebugOUTDATED (about the TclPro debugger, an obsolete tool; renaming the commands would break the API)

    Open ticket 932516ffff · Bug · html · filed 2004-04-09

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (about the TclPro debugger, an obsolete tool; renaming the commands would break the API)

    • Module html 1.6
    • Tested html.tcl still defines html::foreach/for/while/if/set/eval.
    • Cause the prodebug instrumenter mistakes these commands for the core control commands. aku (2019) said renaming would be a major API change, for a 2.x version.
    • Prototype none (API change)
    • Suggested action close as Won't Fix / Outdated (or keep as an RFE for an html 2.0)
    • Suggested ticket comment The TclPro debugger is no longer maintained, and renaming these public commands would break existing users. Closing; a renamed API can be done in an html 2.x if anyone wants it.
    ⬜861801ffff2003Add a new option parser routine tailored for functionsSUPERSEDED (by tepam; getKnownOptions already leaves unknown options in the list)

    Open ticket 861801ffff · RFE · cmdline · filed 2003-12-17

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by tepam; getKnownOptions already leaves unknown options in the list)

    • Module cmdline 1.5.3
    • Tested attached getFunctionOptions compared with the current code
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Procedure argument parsing is covered by tepam, and getKnownOptions for the lenient case. Closing.
    ⬜828717ffff2003Enhancing the profilerOUTDATED (2003 patch series against profiler 0.2.1, with Tcl 8.3 alias-mode code; never applied)

    Open ticket 828717ffff · Patch · profiler · filed 2003-10-23

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (2003 patch series against profiler 0.2.1, with Tcl 8.3 alias-mode code; never applied)

    • Module profiler 0.7
    • Tested compared with current profiler.tcl. None of the proposed API (profiler::add/remove pattern, watchForNewProcs, canonical names via namespace origin, call-level lists) exists. The 8.3 Handler path it builds on is legacy now that Tcl 8.5+ is required.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (large API redesign, out of scope)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date. Anyone who still wants individual features (add/remove by pattern, profiling builtins) can file them as separate RFEs.
    • Suggested ticket comment This 2003 patch series targets profiler 0.2.1 and Tcl 8.3/8.4 and was never finished. Closing as outdated; please open focused RFEs for features you still want against the current profiler.
    ⬜777061ffff2003add images to widget::balloonhelpWRONG-TRACKER (tklib; widget::balloonhelp no longer exists there. The equivalent tklib tooltip package supports -image since tklib ticket 29705…

    Open ticket 777061ffff · Patch · None · filed 2003-07-24

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib; widget::balloonhelp no longer exists there. The equivalent tklib tooltip package supports -image since tklib ticket 2970577fff, Closed.)

    • Module none. widget::balloonhelp is not in tcllib or tklib history.
    • Tested no balloonhelp file or check-in in either repo. tklib trunk modules/tooltip/tooltip.tcl accepts -image. The same ticket 777061ffff is also Open in the tklib tracker.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date here, and close the tklib copy too.
    • Suggested ticket comment widget::balloonhelp is not part of tcllib (and no longer of tklib). tklib's tooltip package provides image support (-image).
    ⬜724822ffff2003graph - simply increased functionality in walkDUPLICATE of 724730ffff (same wiki page 8787 use case: multiple visits per node in walk)

    Open ticket 724822ffff · RFE · struct :: graph · filed 2003-04-21

    Full verdict

    DUPLICATE of 724730ffff (same wiki page 8787 use case: multiple visits per node in walk)

    • Module struct::graph 2.4.4
    • Tested code inspection. The suggested hack (letting the callback unset visited) doesn't work with the C implementation.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Duplicate of 724730ffff
    • Suggested ticket comment Same request as 724730ffff (multi-visit walk). Closing as duplicate.
    ⬜720933ffff2003testsuite makes incorrect assumptions about walk orderOUTDATED (the walk tests still expect one exact order, but each implementation has its own expected order via tmE (Tcl vs critcl), so tcllib's ow…

    Open ticket 720933ffff · Bug · struct :: graph · filed 2003-04-14

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (the walk tests still expect one exact order, but each implementation has its own expected order via tmE (Tcl vs critcl), so tcllib's own C implementation is covered. cgraph, the third-party implementation that motivated the ticket, is defunct.)

    • Module struct::graph 2.4.4 (graph/tests/walk.test)
    • Tested code inspection of walk.test 3.x / 4.x
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none (rewriting all walk expectations as "any valid order" is possible but not needed for tcllib itself)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment The walk tests now take implementation-specific orders (tmE) for tcllib's Tcl and C graphs, and cgraph is gone. Closing.
    ⬜714947ffff2003widget: digraph.tcl needs TIP 44 updateOUTDATED (file never existed in the tcllib fossil repo; tklib's widget module has no digraph.tcl)

    Open ticket 714947ffff · Bug · widget · filed 2003-04-03

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (file never existed in the tcllib fossil repo; tklib's widget module has no digraph.tcl)

    • Module none (digraph.tcl was in a separate SourceForge CVS "widget" repository)
    • Tested searched the tcllib and tklib fossil filename tables and trunk listings for digraph; no match.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Outdated
    • Suggested ticket comment digraph.tcl was part of the old SourceForge "widget" CVS module and is not in tcllib or tklib. Closing as outdated.
    ⬜693059ffff2003logger 0.1 depends on Tcl 8.2OUTDATED (Tcl 8.2-era packaging issue)

    Open ticket 693059ffff · Bug · log · filed 2003-02-25

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (Tcl 8.2-era packaging issue)

    • Module logger 0.9.5, log 1.5
    • Tested modules/log/pkgIndex.tcl now starts with if {![package vsatisfies [package provide Tcl] 8.5 9]} {return}, and logger.tcl has package require Tcl 8.5 9.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date.
    • Suggested ticket comment All log-module packages now require Tcl 8.5+, and the shared index checks for that first, so this no longer applies.
    ⬜681734ffff2003tkchat - logging data changeOUTDATED (tkchat). The storage part was done in 2006 (~/.tkchat_msgs, mbox format); the viewer was never added.

    Open ticket 681734ffff · RFE · apps : tkchat · filed 2003-02-06

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (tkchat). The storage part was done in 2006 (~/.tkchat_msgs, mbox format); the viewer was never added.

    • Module none (tkchat, tclapps)
    • Tested n/a
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment Memos have been stored in ~/.tkchat_msgs since 2006, and tkchat is not part of tcllib. Closing.
    ⬜663394ffff2003Update all.tclOUTDATED (about Tcl 8.2/8.3-era compatibility. Tcllib now requires Tcl 8.5+ and tcltest 2, and the harness was reworked into sak/support/devel/all.…

    Open ticket 663394ffff · RFE · None · filed 2003-01-06

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (about Tcl 8.2/8.3-era compatibility. Tcllib now requires Tcl 8.5+ and tcltest 2, and the harness was reworked into sak/support/devel/all.tcl.)

    • Module test harness (the top-level all.tcl is gone; it is now support/devel/all.tcl, driven by sak.tcl)
    • Tested no top-level all.tcl in trunk. testsNeedTcltest/testutilities handle the version checks.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date.
    • Suggested ticket comment The old all.tcl was replaced by sak.tcl + support/devel/all.tcl, and tcllib now requires Tcl 8.5 and tcltest 2, so this no longer applies.
    ⬜601964ffff2002cmdline::parseargsSUPERSEDED (by tepam, tcllib's procedure argument parser; plus getoptions/getKnownOptions work on args)

    Open ticket 601964ffff · Patch · cmdline · filed 2002-08-29

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by tepam, tcllib's procedure argument parser; plus getoptions/getKnownOptions work on args)

    • Module cmdline 1.5.3
    • Tested code reading. The proc was never added, and aku's 2003 questions were never answered.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Never answered since 2003. tepam now covers declarative proc/argument parsing. Closing.
    ⬜577678ffff2002Add the package tkmisc to tklibWRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is also Open in the tklib tracker. tklib has no splash or fullscreen package, and the fullscreen part is cove…

    Open ticket 577678ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2002-07-05

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (tklib. The same ticket is also Open in the tklib tracker. tklib has no splash or fullscreen package, and the fullscreen part is covered by Tk 8.5+ wm attributes -fullscreen.)

    • Module none (tklib request)
    • Tested tklib trunk file list (no splash/fullscreen module); tklib ticket 577678ffff Open, related 1041229fff "A new splash screen widget?" Closed.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close in tcllib as Not Applicable Here; decide in tklib
    • Suggested ticket comment This is a tklib request and is tracked by the same ticket in the tklib tracker. Closing the Tcllib copy.
    ⬜554233ffff2002Browser for imagesOUTDATED (2002 request for a BWidget demo app; targets wish8.3; wrong project)

    Open ticket 554233ffff · RFE · apps : request for new app · filed 2002-05-09

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (2002 request for a BWidget demo app; targets wish8.3; wrong project)

    • Module none (BWidget images directory; BWidget is a separate project, not in tcllib or tklib)
    • Tested n/a
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date / Wont fix
    • Suggested ticket comment This is about BWidget, which is a separate project. Closing.
    ⬜548233ffff2002more hpupdate bug reportsOUTDATED (example-app UI complaints from 2002; the reporter never answered the 2004 question about which parts concern the ftp package)

    Open ticket 548233ffff · Bug · ftp · filed 2002-04-24

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (example-app UI complaints from 2002; the reporter never answered the 2004 question about which parts concern the ftp package)

    • Module examples/ftp/hpupdate.tcl (example app, not the ftp package)
    • Tested code read only. Disconnect now resets the File menu entries (entryconfigure 0/1), so that part looks addressed. The selection reset on Connect and the upload cd behaviour are app design, with no ftp-package bug identified.
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment These are UI issues in the hpupdate example, not in the ftp package. The menu state is now reset by Disconnect, and the question from 2004 was never answered, so I'm closing this.
    ⬜526094ffff2002Unix console commandWRONG-TRACKER (Tk/tklib. The same SF ticket in the tklib tracker was closed "Not Applicable Here", and Tk 480944ffff "Add console support to Tk / U…

    Open ticket 526094ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2002-03-05

    Full verdict

    WRONG-TRACKER (Tk/tklib. The same SF ticket in the tklib tracker was closed "Not Applicable Here", and Tk 480944ffff "Add console support to Tk / Unix" is Closed/Duplicate. Unix wish 8.6/9.1 still has no console command, though console.tcl is shipped.)

    • Module none (Tk feature)
    • Tested wish9.1 and wish8.6 on Xvfb: info commands console is empty, and $tk_library/console.tcl exists.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Not Applicable Here
    • Suggested ticket comment This is a Tk feature, not a Tcllib one. The tklib copy of this ticket was closed as Not Applicable Here. Use tkcon, or raise it in the Tk tracker.
    ⬜516468ffff2002Allow lists as arguments to statisticsSUPERSEDED (Tcl 8.5 {*} and tcl::mathfunc::max/min; math::statistics::max/min/mean take a list)

    Open ticket 516468ffff · RFE · math · filed 2002-02-12

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (Tcl 8.5 {*} and tcl::mathfunc::max/min; math::statistics::max/min/mean take a list)

    • Module math, math 1.2.x misc.tcl / math::statistics 1.6.1
    • Tested math::statistics::max {1 5 3} gives 5.0, and expr {max(1,5,3)} gives 5 (9.1).
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date / Superseded
    • Suggested ticket comment math::statistics::min/max/mean take lists, and since Tcl 8.5 math::max {*}$list or tcl::mathfunc::max avoid eval.
    ⬜514494ffff2002Information about uri schemesOUTDATED (an open-ended pointer to a list of schemes, not a concrete request)

    Open ticket 514494ffff · RFE · uri · filed 2002-02-07

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (an open-ended pointer to a list of schemes, not a concrete request)

    • Module uri 1.2.8
    • Tested none
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Outdated
    • Suggested ticket comment This is only a pointer to the scheme registry. uri supports the common schemes, and other packages can register more (dns does). Specific schemes can be requested in new tickets.
    ⬜511700ffff2002Chat window enhancement?OUTDATED (tkchat). The request was in fact implemented there: split/history pane in tkchat rev 1.341 (2006, per treincke) and /?text search.

    Open ticket 511700ffff · RFE · apps : tkchat · filed 2002-02-01

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (tkchat). The request was in fact implemented there: split/history pane in tkchat rev 1.341 (2006, per treincke) and /?text search.

    • Module none (tkchat, tclapps)
    • Tested n/a
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of date
    • Suggested ticket comment Both parts were implemented in tkchat: a history pane and /? search. tkchat is not part of tcllib anyway. Closing.
    ⬜483623ffff2001Use cmdline where applicableSUPERSEDED (struct::graph 2.x rewrite: arcs/nodes argument parsing is now a shared helper (CheckE in graph_tcl.tcl), and there is a parallel cr…

    Open ticket 483623ffff · Bug · struct :: graph · filed 2001-11-19

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (struct::graph 2.x rewrite: arcs/nodes argument parsing is now a shared helper (CheckE in graph_tcl.tcl), and there is a parallel critcl C implementation (graph/methods.c), where cmdline is not applicable)

    • Module struct::graph 2.4.4
    • Tested code inspection (graph_tcl.tcl _arcs, _nodes)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Argument handling was refactored in graph 2.x (shared CheckE helper, plus a C implementation). cmdline would add nothing now. Closing.
    ⬜481019ffff2001comm registry mechanismSUPERSEDED (by the nns nano-nameserver modules: nameserv, nameserv::server, nameserv::auto, as noted by aku in 2008)

    Open ticket 481019ffff · RFE · comm · filed 2001-11-12

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by the nns nano-nameserver modules: nameserv, nameserv::server, nameserv::auto, as noted by aku in 2008)

    • Module comm 4.7.3; nns (nameserv, nameserv::auto) on trunk
    • Tested code reading only (modules/nns: nns.tcl, server.tcl, nns_auto.tcl)
    • Cause n/a (RFE)
    • Prototype none (RFE)
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date / Implemented (by nns)
    • Suggested ticket comment The nns modules (nameserv client/server, nameserv::auto) provide a name server for comm ids. Closing; a fully transparent Tk-send-like registry can be filed anew if still wanted.
    ⬜478818ffff2001date/time/calendar module for tcllibSUPERSEDED (by the Tcl 8.5 clock rewrite (clock add, full format/scan), tcllib's clock::iso8601/clock::rfc2822, and the calendar module)

    Open ticket 478818ffff · RFE · tcllib: request for new module · filed 2001-11-06

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by the Tcl 8.5 clock rewrite (clock add, full format/scan), tcllib's clock::iso8601/clock::rfc2822, and the calendar module)

    • Module calendar 0.4 (in the tree but excluded from installation), clock::iso8601, clock::rfc2822
    • Tested code review. modules/calendar exists but is Excluded in support/installation/modules.tcl, as the 2003 comment says.
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment The Tcl 8.5 clock command and Tcllib's clock::iso8601 and clock::rfc2822 now cover most of this. The calendar module was created but its maintainers excluded it from distribution. Closing.
    ⬜454718ffff2001SemephoreSUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 coroutines / coroutine::util await; callbacks can set variables waited on with await; Thread has real semaphores for threads)

    Open ticket 454718ffff · RFE · control · filed 2001-08-23

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by Tcl 8.6 coroutines / coroutine::util await; callbacks can set variables waited on with await; Thread has real semaphores for threads)

    • Module control 0.1.4
    • Tested code reading
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Waiting for any of several callbacks is now done with coroutines (coroutine::util await). Closing.
    ⬜449521ffff2001Add waitForAny to control moduleSUPERSEDED (by coroutines in Tcl 8.6 and coroutine::util await, which waits for a write to any of several variables)

    Open ticket 449521ffff · RFE · control · filed 2001-08-09

    Full verdict

    SUPERSEDED (by coroutines in Tcl 8.6 and coroutine::util await, which waits for a write to any of several variables)

    • Module control 0.1.4; coroutine 1.4
    • Tested code reading (coroutine.tcl ::coroutine::util::await)
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment Tcl 8.6 coroutines cover this; tcllib's coroutine::util await waits for any of several variables. Closing.
    ⬜429388ffff2001execCmd procedure: improved exec (UNIX)OUTDATED (depends on TclX pipe; Tcl 8.6 has chan pipe, open | and exec improvements; dup 429384 was closed in 2001)

    Open ticket 429388ffff · Patch · control · filed 2001-06-01

    Full verdict

    OUTDATED (depends on TclX pipe; Tcl 8.6 has chan pipe, open | and exec improvements; dup 429384 was closed in 2001)

    • Module control 0.1.4
    • Tested attachment description and hobbs' comment
    • Cause n/a
    • Prototype none
    • Suggested action close as Out of Date
    • Suggested ticket comment The patch depends on TclX, and Tcl 8.6 provides chan pipe for this. Closing as out of date.