Triage of all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15. Each ticket was checked against tcllib trunk on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5, using local servers for the network modules and a Windows 11 VM for Windows-only tickets. Outdated, superseded, duplicate and misfiled tickets are listed separately. Rows marked patch link to a prototype fix with a regression test (147 in all, in tcllib-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-16.
9 of 509 tickets are closed or pending (None 5; Invalid 2; Out of Date 1; Fixed 1); 40 more have fix check-ins and 0 more have comments. Rows show the progress with an emoji; open a row for the details.
all 509 open and Pending tickets of tcllib: 308 bugs, 150 feature requests and 51 patches, many from the SourceForge era. They were checked in 26 batches on Linux against tcllib trunk (adeef82ca0, 2026-11-13) with Tcl 9.1, 9.0, 8.6 and 8.5. Network modules (ftp, ftpd, smtp, pop3, pop3d, dns, ldap, http, websocket, …) were tested against local servers on 127.0.0.1. A Windows 11 VM ran the Windows-only tickets and the whole test suite. 148 prototype patches were written. Every patch that changes code includes a regression test, which fails without the fix and passes with it on 9.1 and 8.6. Nothing has been committed or posted yet.
35 fix branches are on the server for 40 tickets, each with a "Proposed fix in branch" comment on its ticket. The emoji in the rows show each ticket's state. The branches are the prototypes with their regression tests. The module tests pass on Linux with Tcl 9.1, 8.6 and 8.5, and on Windows with 9.1 and 8.6, with no failure that trunk does not have too.
ScmUnpack leaves open, so the test now closes it.
tcl::chan::memchan and about 20 other virtchannel files use try since 14c9a08008 (2024-09-20, in tcllib 2.0).
134 reproduced and 22 partly fixed. 129 feature requests are still open; many of those could be closed as stale. 22 docs issues, 22 not reproduced, 23 not a bug.
package require nettool always fails. Since 94a3829047 (2024-09-13, in tcllib 2.0) its pkgIndex.tcl names nexttool.tcl. The same check found four more index entries that don't match the code (🔧523f7e0556). Among them is rest: the index says 1.7 while rest.tcl provides 1.8, so package require rest fails on trunk (🔧cdbdd399e4).
ldap::starttls and ldap::info whoami always fail with "invalid command name" in tcllib 1.21, 2.0 and trunk. The 2022 change 495ba2b8f5 calls asnEncodeString, which asn does not export.
smtp::sendmessage returns code 7 with a raw dict instead of raising an error. A rejected Bcc copy is not reported at all.
autoproxy::tls_socket uses the wrong host;
Tcl_InitStubs(interp, "8.6", 0);
-encoding binary in practcl and doctools::tcl::parse;
package require tool fails when no USER/USERNAME variable is set;
struct::graph::op::tarjan hangs for node names with spaces. This is a regression of Bug 2815302: the 2009 fix was undone by the GSoC merge 42c21b6c75.
::crc::Crc gives a wrong CRC for non-reflected 32-bit CRCs, because tcl_platform(wordSize) is 4 there.
struct 1.5 requires struct::matrix 1.2.1, which no longer exists.
review and merge, or close:
tkt-4dd68ce4e76841f: linear-model t values, ⬜4dd68ce4e7. Checked independently; correct.
e15c2a7c-json-write-hao: ⬜e15c2a7ce1. It merges cleanly, but the test name json-write-6.2 is used twice.
tkt-⬜d74e6561a2-yaml-huddle: ⬜d74e6561a2.
bug-f6624cf52ba4: ⬜f6624cf52b. It breaks the bad-option message; the prototype fixes that.
fix-dns-udp-ipv6-7554bfed30: needs tcludp to test.
ak-tkt-⬜b41b6f76b0-ftp-eprt: ftp EPRT/EPSV for IPv6, from 2014; needs a rebase.
pbrooks-ticket-664392: needs a Windows run.
virtchan-1985a34255: refchan truncate exists only in Tcl 9.
sha256-vc-fix and apn-vc-fixes look superseded by cc4d362b78.
some patches touch the same lines or each add the same new test file, so they must be merged by hand:
modules/ftp/ftp.test. The module had no tests.
rest.test. smtp: 3 patches, each creating smtp.test.
dump.
-encoding binary line by both 🔧146ae829a9 and 🔧8ac37e504d.
these need a decision:
INVALID errorcode word.
ncgi::encode uses UTF-8, so %C3%B6 instead of %F6.
math::decimal::fromstr raises an error on invalid input.
fileutil::lexnormalize keeps leading .. in relative paths.
yaml_null.
from and destructor errors.
websocket.test uses the external echo server ws.ifelse.io and has no constraint, so a full sak test run contacts an outside host. It needs a local server (the triage used one) or a constraint that is off by default.
-errorstack);
snit::typemethod/method at runtime now need a fully qualified type name.
checkmime.msg in the current directory, and practcl.test leaves an empty test directory.