Open tklib tickets: Superseded or outdated

Triage of all 71 open and Pending tickets of tklib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15: whether a bug still exists in tklib trunk with Tk 9.1 and 8.6, whether a patch is still needed, and whether a request has been implemented, superseded or become outdated. 25 prototype patches with regression tests; rows marked patch have one. None is committed.

Superseded or outdated 14

⬜9c9ba349302013Add Taotk to tklibOUTDATED (no code was ever submitted; taotk is not in tklib)

Open ticket 9c9ba34930 · tklib · RFE · filed 2013-10-12

Full verdict

OUTDATED (no code was ever submitted; taotk is not in tklib)

  • Module (new module) · RFE
  • Tested n/a
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action No code was attached in 13 years, and Tao/taotk has had no visible activity since then. Close as "Out of Date". The author can open a new ticket with code if still interested.
⬜3480882fff2012new widget - read-only textSUPERSEDED (by dgw::txrotext in the text module, dgw::txmixins, added 2024-06-26 in 1dfb1781ad). It uses the approach AK suggested in the comment…

Open ticket 3480882fff · tklib: request for new module · RFE · filed 2012-01-28

Full verdict

SUPERSEDED (by dgw::txrotext in the text module, dgw::txmixins, added 2024-06-26 in 1dfb1781ad). It uses the approach AK suggested in the comments: insert/delete disabled, ins/del for programmatic edits.

  • Module (new module) · RFE
  • Tested n/a (read the code)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action tklib now has a read-only text widget: dgw::txrotext in package dgw::txmixins (module text). Close as "Out of Date"/superseded.
⬜2168846fff2008tklib test suite for plotchart generates coreOUTDATED (the abort is a Tk panic "TkpGetFontFromAttributes: cannot get any font" caused by the remote X server (Exceed) having no usable fonts. It…

Open ticket 2168846fff · plotchart · Bug · filed 2008-10-15

Full verdict

OUTDATED (the abort is a Tk panic "TkpGetFontFromAttributes: cannot get any font" caused by the remote X server (Exceed) having no usable fonts. It is not a plotchart bug. The broken plothist.test, which sourced plotchart.tcl from the cwd, no longer exists)

  • Module plotchart · Bug
  • Tested Tk 9.1 and 8.6, sak test run plotchart: plotchart.test and plotcontour.test both pass. Current Tk on X11 uses Xft, so the old core-font panic path is no longer relevant.
  • Cause X server font configuration (tkUnixFont.c GetSystemFont panic), and plothist.test that has since been removed
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action The crash was a Tk panic because the X server offered no fonts at all. Plotchart can't prevent that. The plothist.test file with the bad source is gone, and the plotchart tests pass with Tk 8.6 and 9.x. Close as Out of Date.
⬜1580085fff2006tklib - Dial meter items for canvasSUPERSEDED (by the controlwidget module, with tachometer, voltmeter and rdial, added 2010-07, 90dbb66551 / 152b699338)

Open ticket 1580085fff · tklib: request for new module · RFE · filed 2006-10-18

Full verdict

SUPERSEDED (by the controlwidget module, with tachometer, voltmeter and rdial, added 2010-07, 90dbb66551 / 152b699338)

  • Module (new module) · RFE
  • Tested n/a (looked at the modules)
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action Dial and needle meters have been in tklib since 2010 as part of [controlwidget] (tachometer, voltmeter, rdial). Close as "Out of Date"/superseded.
⬜1475562fff2006improved handling of incorrect callsOUTDATED (too vague. Current Plotchart gives sensible errors)

Open ticket 1475562fff · plotchart · RFE · filed 2006-04-24

Full verdict

OUTDATED (too vague. Current Plotchart gives sensible errors)

  • Module plotchart · RFE
  • Tested Tk 9.1. Wrong argument counts give a Tcl "wrong # args" error, $p nosuch gives "No such method - nosuch", a zero step gives "Step size can not be zero", and non-numeric data raises an expr error. Nothing fails silently or behaves unexpectedly.
  • Cause n/a. The only wart is that "wrong # args" messages for methods name internal procs (e.g. DrawData w series xcrd ycrd) instead of the method.
  • Prototype none (no concrete case)
  • Suggested ticket action Incorrect calls now raise errors (wrong # args, unknown method, zero step size). Without a concrete example of wrong behaviour there is nothing to fix. Close as Out of Date.
⬜1167797fff20058.5 speed improvement via -allPATCH-OBSOLETE (10 of 11 hunks fail against ctext 3.3). The main idea, using text search -all in ctext::highlight, is not implemented yet.

Open ticket 1167797fff · tklib: ctext · Patch · filed 2005-03-21

Full verdict

PATCH-OBSOLETE (10 of 11 hunks fail against ctext 3.3). The main idea, using text search -all in ctext::highlight, is not implemented yet.

  • Module ctext · Patch
  • Tested patch --dry-run against trunk
  • Cause the patch is against ctext 3.1 (2004). It also mixes in personal tweaks (quote matching turned off, blink count 4→10, borders changed, ttk frame).
  • Prototype none (performance rework with nothing to regression-test; the linemap overhaul is a redesign)
  • Suggested ticket action The patch no longer applies and contains unrelated personal changes. ctext now requires Tcl/Tk 8.5+, so search -all could be used directly in ctext::highlight. That would be a fresh change, not this patch. Close as "Out of Date", or keep it as an RFE for the -all speedup only.
⬜971076ffff2004snitbutton widgetOUTDATED (only a wiki link; it targets the wikit Tk GUI on MacOS 9 without Itcl)

Open ticket 971076ffff · tklib: request for new module · RFE · filed 2004-06-11

Full verdict

OUTDATED (only a wiki link; it targets the wikit Tk GUI on MacOS 9 without Itcl)

  • Module (new module) · RFE
  • Tested n/a
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action No code was ever attached. The use case (wikit tkGui on MacOS 9) is gone, and ttk buttons cover styled buttons. Close as "Out of Date".
⬜832488ffff2003License woesOUTDATED (misfiled tcllib ticket). tklib has no comm module and no comm.LICENSE or expander_license.txt.

Open ticket 832488ffff · (none) · Bug · filed 2003-10-29

Full verdict

OUTDATED (misfiled tcllib ticket). tklib has no comm module and no comm.LICENSE or expander_license.txt.

  • Module licensing (tcllib comm and textutil modules) · Bug
  • Tested searched the tklib trunk tree.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action This concerns tcllib's comm module, which is not part of tklib. Close as Out of Date (re-file against tcllib if still relevant).
⬜777061ffff2003add images to widget::balloonhelpPATCH-OBSOLETE / IMPLEMENTED. balloonhelp became the tooltip package. Tooltip 1.8 added -image (shown with -compound left) and an -info f…

Open ticket 777061ffff · (none) · Patch · filed 2003-07-24

Full verdict

PATCH-OBSOLETE / IMPLEMENTED. balloonhelp became the tooltip package. Tooltip 1.8 added -image (shown with -compound left) and an -info field (edc5a0a48f, 2024-05-23, ticket 803a13c9f0). Label properties come from the option database (*Tooltip*Label.*, tooltip::configure), which covers the "use resources" part. Trunk has tooltip 2.0.4.

  • Module tooltip (formerly balloonhelp) · Patch
  • Tested Tk 9.1, 8.6: tooltip::tooltip .b -image im "Text" works.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (the 2003 context diff is against balloonhelp.tcl 2.0 and does not apply)
  • Suggested ticket action Images in tooltips are supported since tooltip 1.8 (edc5a0a48f), and label properties are taken from the option database. Close as Out of Date.
⬜714947ffff2003widget: digraph.tcl needs TIP 44 updateOUTDATED (digraph.tcl was part of Jeff Hobbs' old "widget" code in the tcllib CVS. It never entered the tklib repository: no file name matches "dig…

Open ticket 714947ffff · widget · Bug · filed 2003-04-03

Full verdict

OUTDATED (digraph.tcl was part of Jeff Hobbs' old "widget" code in the tcllib CVS. It never entered the tklib repository: no file name matches "digraph" in the repo history.)

  • Module widget · Bug
  • Tested searched the repository; no pre-8.4 tkFoo internal commands remain in the tklib modules (only the guarded ::tkPriv use in tablelist).
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action digraph.tcl is not part of tklib, and Tk 8.4 itself is long obsolete. Close as "Out of Date".
⬜663394ffff2003Update all.tclOUTDATED. The RFE was about Tcl 8.2/8.3 compatibility of all.tcl (2003), and andreas_kupries reported in 2003 that it was done. Tests are now run w…

Open ticket 663394ffff · (none) · RFE · filed 2003-01-06

Full verdict

OUTDATED. The RFE was about Tcl 8.2/8.3 compatibility of all.tcl (2003), and andreas_kupries reported in 2003 that it was done. Tests are now run with sak.tcl test run and modules require Tcl 8.5+.

  • Module test harness · RFE
  • Tested inspected support/devel/all.tcl and sak.tcl test.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action Done in 2003 according to the comments. Since then the test driver moved to sak.tcl and the Tcl 8.2 baseline is long gone. Close as Out of Date.
⬜577678ffff2002Add the package tkmisc to tklibOUTDATED (maximizedTopLevel is superseded by wm attributes $w -fullscreen 1 (Tk 8.5+). The splash window showTransientWindow is about 40 line…

Open ticket 577678ffff · tcllib: request for new module · RFE · filed 2002-07-05

Full verdict

OUTDATED (maximizedTopLevel is superseded by wm attributes $w -fullscreen 1 (Tk 8.5+). The splash window showTransientWindow is about 40 lines of overrideredirect + after code. The proposer, who is also the plotchart maintainer, has not pursued it since 2004)

  • Module new module (tkmisc) · RFE
  • Tested unpacked the attachment (tkmisc.tcl 140 lines, man page, test). The stored attachment is double UTF-8 encoded from the SF migration and becomes a valid tar.gz again after decode('utf-8').encode('latin-1').
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action Full-screen windows are covered by wm attributes -fullscreen, and a splash window is a few lines of wm overrideredirect code. Close as Rejected/Out of Date unless someone wants a dedicated splash module. (Note: the attachment is mangled by the SF import and needs latin-1 re-encoding to unpack.)
⬜535066ffff2002menu management module for tklibSUPERSEDED (by the menubar module, added 2009-12, f115c81599)

Open ticket 535066ffff · tklib: request for new module · RFE · filed 2002-03-26

Full verdict

SUPERSEDED (by the menubar module, added 2009-12, f115c81599)

  • Module (new module) · RFE
  • Tested n/a
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action tklib has had a menubar management package ([menubar]) since 2009, so this 2002/2005 submission is no longer needed. Close as "Out of Date".
⬜509776ffff2002Locale dependant test failuresOUTDATED. The argv0 patch was applied long ago: tklib's support/devel/all.tcl line 166 has set ::argv0 [pSet ::argv0]. The remaining locale i…

Open ticket 509776ffff · (none) · Bug · filed 2002-01-28

Full verdict

OUTDATED. The argv0 patch was applied long ago: tklib's support/devel/all.tcl line 166 has set ::argv0 [pSet ::argv0]. The remaining locale issue concerned tcllib's mime tests, and the mime module is not part of tklib.

  • Module test harness (tcllib-era; the locale part was about tcllib's mime tests) · Bug
  • Tested inspected support/devel/all.tcl in trunk.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none
  • Suggested ticket action The argv0 part was applied in 2003 and is in tklib's all.tcl. The locale part was about tcllib's mime module, which is not in tklib (report it to tcllib if it still happens there). Close as Out of Date.