Open tklib tickets: Open RFEs

Triage of all 71 open and Pending tickets of tklib (bugs, patches and feature requests) on 2026-11-15: whether a bug still exists in tklib trunk with Tk 9.1 and 8.6, whether a patch is still needed, and whether a request has been implemented, superseded or become outdated. 25 prototype patches with regression tests; rows marked patch have one. None is committed.

Open RFE 7

⬜5c3ef045942025Allow rotated horizontal axis labelsRFE-OPEN (only bar charts support -xlabelangle (plotaxis.tcl:DrawXlabels, Tk 8.6+). The xy, tx and log plots' DrawXaxis/DrawTimeaxis have no angl…

Open ticket 5c3ef04594 · plotchart · RFE · filed 2025-05-22

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (only bar charts support -xlabelangle (plotaxis.tcl:DrawXlabels, Tk 8.6+). The xy, tx and log plots' DrawXaxis/DrawTimeaxis have no angle option)

  • Module plotchart · RFE
  • Tested code inspection of trunk plotaxis.tcl
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (needs a new axis option, e.g. xconfig -labelangle or a plotconfig bottomaxis labelangle property, used by DrawXaxis/DrawLogXaxis/DrawTimeaxis with anchor selection as in DrawXlabels, plus a larger bottom margin. That is moderate work with an API addition.)
  • Suggested ticket action Bar charts already have -xlabelangle. Extending this to the xy, time and log axes as a labelangle axis property (rotating the labels and enlarging the bottom margin) seems worthwhile. Keep open.
⬜5e9db381512021tklib::diagrams should through syntax sugar can run pikchr scriptRFE-OPEN (large; low value). There is no pikchr compatibility. diagrams already has equivalents for some pikchr shapes: drum is a cylinder and `e…

Open ticket 5e9db38151 · diagrams · Patch · filed 2021-07-05

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (large; low value). There is no pikchr compatibility. diagrams already has equivalents for some pikchr shapes: drum is a cylinder and ellipse an oval. file, dot, fit, same, behind and % units are missing.

  • Module diagrams · Patch (actually an RFE; no patch attached)
  • Tested n/a (code inspection of basic.tcl element definitions).
  • Prototype none (new language front end, far beyond 60 lines)
  • Suggested ticket action Change the type to Feature Request. A pikchr front end would be a sizeable new subsystem. Contributions are welcome; otherwise close as Won't Fix.
⬜4e8fb9d55e2019Update ctextRFE-OPEN. No patch is attached; the code lives in an external GitHub repo (ctextAdvanced) and was not reviewed (no network). None of the proposed f…

Open ticket 4e8fb9d55e · ctext · Patch · filed 2019-05-30

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN. No patch is attached; the code lives in an external GitHub repo (ctextAdvanced) and was not reviewed (no network). None of the proposed features are in trunk: no per-class tag options in addHighlightClass*, no -linemap_font, no -linemap_font_select. The linemap bug behind item 2 does reproduce: with a highlight class whose tag font is larger (Helvetica 20 bold), line numbers drift away from the text lines. Line 9 is at text y=179 but its linemap number is at y=123, on both Tk 9.1 and 8.6.

  • Module ctext · Patch
  • Tested Tk 9.1, 8.6: ctext with a big-font tag on odd lines, compared dlineinfo of the text and the linemap.
  • Cause ctext.tcl ctext::linemapUpdate draws the numbers in a second text widget with uniform line height, so it cannot follow lines with different heights.
  • Prototype none (needs a linemap redesign, e.g. a canvas placed with dlineinfo as in the wiki example; well over 60 lines)
  • Suggested ticket action Ask the submitter to attach the patch against current trunk, split into (a) a linemap that copes with variable line heights and (b) the new options. Keep it open as a feature request.
⬜1730868fff2007install as Tcl ModulesRFE-OPEN (low value). Neither installer.tcl, support/installation/*.tcl nor Makefile.in knows anything about .tm installation. Most tklib p…

Open ticket 1730868fff · (none) · RFE · filed 2007-06-04

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (low value). Neither installer.tcl, support/installation/*.tcl nor Makefile.in knows anything about .tm installation. Most tklib packages are multi-file and/or carry data files, so Tcl Module installation would only fit a subset of them.

  • Module installer · RFE
  • Tested grep of the installer and sak sources in trunk.
  • Cause n/a
  • Prototype none (installer redesign, not a small fix)
  • Suggested ticket action Still not implemented in the tklib installer. Most tklib packages consist of several files and resources, so .tm installation would cover only a few single-file packages. Close as "Won't Fix" unless someone wants to work on it.
⬜1346299fff2005ctext module dir contains obsolete filesRFE-OPEN (still valid; housekeeping). The file is install.tcl, not installer.tcl. It is still in trunk, together with the "Installation" sectio…

Open ticket 1346299fff · ctext · Bug · filed 2005-11-02

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still valid; housekeeping). The file is install.tcl, not installer.tcl. It is still in trunk, together with the "Installation" section of README that tells users to run wish8.4 install.tcl. Other leftovers from before tklib: test.c (Panache WM C source, unrelated), long_test_script, and the ad-hoc ctext_test*.tcl demo scripts. The tklib installer installs only the package files (support/installation/modules.tcl: Module ctext _ctxt _man _null).

  • Module ctext · Bug
  • Tested inspected the trunk tree, README and the installer config.
  • Cause files copied over from the standalone ctext distribution.
  • Prototype none (only deletes files and edits README; nothing to regression-test)
  • Suggested ticket action Remove modules/ctext/install.tcl, test.c, long_test_script and the README installation section. Move the ctext_test*.tcl demos to examples/ctext. Then close as Fixed.
⬜1007766fff2004Add a case-insensitive matching option to ctextRFE-OPEN, with a working alternative. Keyword classes (addHighlightClass) are matched by exact array lookup, so there is no case-insensitive mode…

Open ticket 1007766fff · ctext · RFE · filed 2004-08-12

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN, with a working alternative. Keyword classes (addHighlightClass) are matched by exact array lookup, so there is no case-insensitive mode. addHighlightClassForRegexp .t kw blue {(?i)\m(subroutine|function)\M} highlights keywords in any case (verified with Tk 9.1 and 8.6, as aku hinted in 2022).

  • Module ctext · RFE
  • Tested Tk 9.1, 8.6: "Subroutine" and "SUBROUTINE" get the tag through a (?i) regexp class but not through a keyword class.
  • Cause ctext.tcl:ctext::addHighlightClass / highlight look up words case-sensitively.
  • Prototype none for an option (that would be an API addition). The (?i) workaround is documented in 1007764fff.patch.
  • Suggested ticket action Use a regexp class with the (?i) embedded option, e.g. {(?i)\m(subroutine|function)\M}, now mentioned in the docs. Close as Works For Me unless a real -nocase option for keyword classes is still wanted.
⬜996330ffff2004ico - Testsuite missingRFE-OPEN (still valid: trunk has no modules/ico/*.test). The prototypes for 3470437fff and e7f1ed859e both start a modules/ico/ico.test (write/read…

Open ticket 996330ffff · ico · Bug · filed 2004-07-23

Full verdict

RFE-OPEN (still valid: trunk has no modules/ico/*.test). The prototypes for 3470437fff and e7f1ed859e both start a modules/ico/ico.test (write/read round trips, icon member sizes).

  • Module ico · Bug (reminder)
  • Tested n/a
  • Prototype none of its own; see 3470437fff.patch and e7f1ed859e.patch, whose ico.test files need merging.
  • Suggested ticket action A first ico.test arrives with the fixes for 3470437fff and e7f1ed859e. Close as Fixed once it is committed.