Triage of 818 open and Pending Bug tickets of Tcl with no comment or check-in from me on 2026-10-16 (in Tcl's workflow Pending means "resolved, waiting for confirmation"). Reproduced on Linux (main 9.1 tip, 9.0 tip, 8.7b1, 8.6 tip, 8.5, 8.4 and old releases), on FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and OpenIndiana VMs for platform tickets, and on a Windows 11 VM. Rows marked patch link to a prototype patch (287 in all, in tcl-triage/prototypes). Updated 2026-11-11: the emoji before each ticket id shows its progress.
166 of 818 tickets are closed or pending (Fixed 139; Duplicate 10; Works For Me 9; Out of Date 4; Wont Fix 1; Invalid 1; None 1; Remind 1); 63 more have fix check-ins and 6 more have comments. Rows show the progress with an emoji; open a row for the details.
773 open and Pending Bug tickets of Tcl with no comment or check-in from me: 761 Open and 12 Pending (in Tcl's workflow Pending means "resolved, waiting for confirmation"). 53 batches on Linux, then a Windows VM for the NEEDS-WINDOWS tickets. A second run on 2026-10-22 added 45 tickets I had already commented on or that were filed since (4 batches on Linux, then Windows run 6), so 818 in all. Rows with a prototype patch link to it; many of the prototypes have become fix branches since.
of the 818 triaged tickets, 121 are closed, 78 have a fix branch or a merged fix, 6 have a comment and 24 are Pending; 589 are untouched. The emoji in the rows show each ticket's state.
the 201 prototype patches of tickets nobody had worked on since the triage were checked again on the current tips (Linux; the Windows VM for the 15 Windows-related ones): the bug reproduced before the patch and was gone after it, and the related tests passed. Verified 183, verified with a new regression test 11, fixed meanwhile 4 (β¬2114165fff, β¬2997967fff, β¬d0d47f8196, and the Windows sleep patch), incomplete 2 (β¬1094682fff: the iogt tests now run but need new expected trails; β¬2980143fff: Thread passes the error code but not all return options), not reproducible on the tip 1 (β¬e5c21e566f). Four prototypes were wrong and were corrected: β¬1743302fff (crashed with TCL_COMPILE_STATS), β¬b198d6560a (accepted an invalid switch option pair), β¬1214461fff (missed the mac* encodings) and β¬3046359fff (leaked memory). Each row with a checked prototype shows the details under "Prototype check".
26, for bugs that had no ticket. Fixed and closed: 58bae89897 (he era names swapped, all branches), 8584043146 (Windows after sleeping 72 minutes, 9.0), 63941fee4f (interp create resets the system encoding, main and 9.0), 2dff98e079 (format %A, main and 9.0), a63f5a4fed (safe interp gets the parent's error info, all branches), 31294d48ef (-DUSE_THREAD_ALLOC=0, main and 9.0), e580d8372b (half-hour time zones, all branches), 8a8f4957db (man page markup, main and 9.0). Open with a proposed fix:
unix-async-close-pending, 2b6b0a5729 chan-close-write-pending, 4c5a98f5a0 gets-auto-saw-cr, 7aa8fd34c4 epoll-error-writable, d48728e10b transform-short-read, d6c1d2f78e channel-names-no-address.
trace-error-keep-frame, 1e66ba3d49 expr-operator-prefixed-funcs.
unix-delete-deep-tree, 076ed602e1 win-delete-long-path, 08203e40e3 win-delete-tree-with-symlinks; existing RFE c8d4f01a54 win-readlink-symlinks.
testasync-null-interp, 7dc0420245 man2html-tk-beside, 1555016064 zip-depends-on-library (an incremental build keeps a stale library zip), 0a908bb93b header-dependencies (make does not rebuild objects after a header change).
:: in installed man page names becomes _), f0fd63394b (registry.test skips all its tests on main; fixed on main by Jan in b6340f48b4, ticket still open), 72d1c8c271 (Windows 8.6: under ephemeral port exhaustion, sockets get disabled for the whole process and Tcl sometimes crashes; found in Windows run 6).
$tcl_library/encoding to the encoding search path. A --disable-zipfs tclsh whose library is not in the compiled-in place has no encodings except the 13 built-in ones, and the system encoding falls back to iso8859-1. Prototype, test encoding-26.1. β branch init-encoding-dirs.
close of a pending socket -async with buffered data fails with "transport endpoint is not connected" and the server gets nothing; 8.6 and 8.7b1 deliver it. Since d5bc305ad2 (2020-03-04): Tcl_Close closes the read side first, and shutdown(SHUT_RD) aborts the connect on Linux. Prototype, test socket-14.20. β new ticket 251f46655c, branch unix-async-close-pending; β
1329568fff closed.
can't read "socketWrState(...)" every time; also (9.x and 8.6) the CRLF after a chunked -channel response is read as the next status line. Two prototypes (http-4.19, http11-5.1.*) to combine. β branch http-keepalive-reuse-closed.
-translation auto, "a\r", "b", "\nc\n" in separate reads give the lines "a" and "bc". Since a3ed092aab (sebres, 2022-07-27, the fix for b3977d199b). Prototype, test io-29.36.3; the b3977d199b tests still pass. β new ticket 4c5a98f5a0, branch gets-auto-saw-cr; β
2953593fff closed.
epoll-error-writable; β
653218ffff closed.
clock format ... -locale he fails ("extra characters after close-quote"); a6c8a2df48 (2017-04-13) turned the escaped quotes in he.msg back into bare ones. Prototype, test clock-71.2. β fixed in main and 9.0, closed; the era names were swapped too (58bae89897, fixed).
after ms / Tcl_Sleep can hang for about 72 minutes: win/tclWinNotify.c computes (unsigned long)vdelay.usec / 1000 with a negative usec, since 837dbec7cc (2023-03-08, a -Wconversion cleanup). Seen with a 9.0.5 tclsh and its children; with a half-speed clock 4 of 8 runs hung on 9.0.5, none on 8.6 or patched 9.0. main is not affected (TIP 723). Prototype tcl90-winsleep.patch (core-9-0-branch, 4 lines).
encoding system koi8-r; interp create; encoding system gives utf-8 on main, 9.1.0, 9.0; koi8-r on 8.6.
format %A garbles its output on main, 9.0, 8.7 (format %A -1.5 β -xX1.8p+0, %A Inf β IxF), since 5cfe15b5d6 (2018-02-14). Found with β
40f315bc23; prototype 40f315bc23-A.patch, test format-19.5.
exec echo |foo, since 8.4.13, 47d7a23bdf). Branches: async-test-msvc-constraint, imported-cmd-step-traces (π§fc88534d38), leave-trace-own-result (π§2811381fff), exec-pipeline-words (π§2339907fff, π§1862356fff).
regexp -indices -inline {((a?)*|(b?)*)+} aaa differs between main and 9.0 (one of the recent regexp fixes on main); not bisected.
file exists while another loops encoding system (9.0 40/40, main 10/10). Prototype (reference counting), clean 40/40. β branch system-encoding-keep-retired. Also Tcl_GetEncoding(NULL, NULL) returns systemEncoding re-read after unlocking (main, 9.0, 8.6).
file mkdir does umask(0); umask(old), so with threads the process umask can stay 0000 and later files are world-writable (3/3 on main, 9.0, 8.6). Prototype; π§623585ffff removes the same code. β branch mkdir-no-umask-call (both).
iortrans-reentrant-argv.
interp-delete-callbacks-path.
notifier-delete-source-in-loop (new testevent deletesource, tests notify-3.x).
transform-write-keep-input. Side finding: a blocking gets on a socket with a transform waits for a full 4096-byte block β d48728e10b, branch transform-short-read.
file delete -force d1/d2/d3/.. returns success after deleting the contents of d2 but not d2 (since 8.5). Prototype. β branch delete-refuse-dot-dot.
lset leaves an extra {} element (since TIP 331, 2008). Prototype. β branch lset-undo-append-on-error.
interp limit time callback that enters the event loop overwrites the busy child's result (8.5βmain). One prototype. β branch time-limit-handler-reentry.
binary format count overflow: panics (x99999999999999999999, @9223372036854775807) or silently returns "" on main, 9.0, 8.6. Two prototypes to combine. β branch binary-format-size-overflow (both).
gets of a line over 2 GB panics (int counters, main, 9.0). Prototype, no test (needs > 4 GB). β branch gets-long-lines (also a wrong count with -translation binary and a crash after a CR at a buffer end; tests gets-bigdata-1..3, constraint bigdata).
interp limit -time does not stop expr {3**30000000 > 0} (4β20 s) β needs limit checks in libtommath or a size cap; no prototype.
string match, glob, lsearch -glob take exponential time on a*a*β¦b patterns (all versions). Prototype (127 lines, same results as 9.0 on 20000 random cases). β branch glob-match-linear.
testasync segfaults when the handler fires from the event loop (test code only; see β¬502022ffff). β ec1ee3bc92, branch testasync-null-interp.
FreeBSD, NetBSD, OpenBSD and OpenIndiana (for Solaris) for 16 tickets; the Windows 11 VM for 58+ NEEDS-WINDOWS tickets in five runs. Results show in the rows as "Unix VMs, run 1" and "Windows VM, run N".
file delete -force on a tree deeper than MAX_PATH returns OK and deletes nothing (β¬bc7925fc50; 9.1, 9.0, 8.6) β 076ed602e1, branch win-delete-long-path; file delete -force fails on a directory that contains a file symlink β 08203e40e3, branch win-delete-tree-with-symlinks; file readlink fails on every symlink (only junctions work) β existing RFE c8d4f01a54, branch win-readlink-symlinks.
open returns the stdin channel after the host closed stdin), β¬502197ffff (env() misses SetEnvironmentVariable changes), β
1758527fff (8.6 backport), β¬66aa81c90a ("No error" for a DLL with a missing dependency; 8.6 version too), β¬aa9f3ef820 (file exists on device names), β¬972c35d41d (file symlinks are copied as targets), β¬8527d8becf (junctions on network drives), β¬6235d23a76, π§76952ef592, β
2ef3430fdc (native MSYS2 install), β
2b874804b5 (8.6 only). β³75d525d37c: a listening socket transferred to another thread still crashes (9.0, 8.6) β the Pending/Fixed status is wrong. β¬027ba061a8: threads made in wish have no stdout/stderr. β³b6d0d8cc2c is normal TCP TIME_WAIT (not a bug).
cd into a junction and cd .., pwd/glob and file exists/open disagree; TclpObjChdir passes the unnormalized path) β the combined Unix+Windows prototype is tested, test winFile-5.1; β¬147b28d043 (exec gui.exe & blocks ~3 s in WaitForInputIdle) β prototype tested, exec returns in 4 ms; β¬1199331fff (per-drive working directory) fixed on main by 38f0ce657c (235 lines), still broken on 9.0 and 8.6; β¬3185623fff (... path component) needs a decision. Not run on the VM: β¬2049971fff (needs tzutil, a system setting).
load); β¬488530ffff, β¬219254ffff, β¬3160902fff, β¬7cd721e9ea, β¬1963074fff prototypes verified on illumos; DTrace builds (β¬2815500fff, β¬1802202fff) behave on OpenIndiana x86. OpenIndiana also fails 11 socket.test tests on main (9 on 8.6, socket -async to a port without a listener) and scan-15.1 β 59e7e7fdfb and dbf9884c56.
knownMsvcBug; prototypes β
1056311fff and β
3544685fff (combine). format.test's knownMsvcBug can probably be relaxed (MSVC 2022 fixed the CRT bug, β¬cb7aac6f2c).
auto_path done, but env(TCL_LIBRARY) and env(TCLLIBPATH) are still described in both tclvars.n and library.n), β³8f5e7a2633 (Jan keeps it for dkf's clock init cleanup).
121 tickets whose verdict is FIXED without a caveat; 96 closed by 2026-10-21. Left open after rereading the comments: β¬6094de399d, β¬4f06d7ca08, β¬c5825d3235, π¬e4d394cd24, β¬1b8a893ded, β¬f9764cd7a9, β¬29b19f5ef0, β¬27b3ce2997, β¬1bd796d9c2, π§ce4483c2cb, β¬255c116110, β 0e15cc8367, β¬9969cf8ca6, β¬3389684fff, β¬3387109fff, π§3099612fff, β¬2895741fff, π§2788582fff, β¬2502037fff, β¬1569064fff, β¬1201589fff, β¬1199331fff, β¬1122203fff, β¬1028264fff, β¬488882ffff. All: β¬6094de399d, β¬4f06d7ca08, β 1577f1d373, β f2b5f89c0d, β¬c5825d3235, π¬e4d394cd24, β f2f597cb78, β 0dc653a2fb, β c9098c8bae, β¬1b8a893ded, β d63061a1ac, β 6d2ef441cc, β c315de9e44, β¬f9764cd7a9, β¬29b19f5ef0, β¬27b3ce2997, β¬1bd796d9c2, π§ce4483c2cb, β df6a0e97f2, β 6f16de3d8d, β a16a1119e5, β b5777d3d32, β¬255c116110, β 56ebd82953, β a1bd37b719, β 25a42264db, β e83a97c7fe, β ece07271f4, β 1df76ec751, β dc69e5ecf0, β 6676bc2548, β e80478c91d, β e87bcf819f, β 63e15dab99, β 95a8293a29, β eb71701c36, β ab951a7503, β 52f7abe82f, β 7f2928e3a9, β e7d3094475, β 75ae1eca5a, β 17902c1882, β 0e15cc8367, β fed5069f8a, β fbc88fb645, β e8004edfe5, β f4f44174e4, β 7393be0be6, β 9b47029467, β 05382a5317, β 8e53aea5b9, β¬9969cf8ca6, β 3608957fff, β 3606118fff, β 3606116fff, β 3606108fff, β 3605722fff, β 3598300fff, β 3588687fff, β 3547593fff, β 3534607fff, β 3522894fff, β 3518301fff, β 3486740fff, β 3475995fff, β 3432269fff, β 3407860fff, β¬3389684fff, β¬3387109fff, β 3378439fff, β 3181906fff, π§3099612fff, β 3075155fff, β 3075027fff, β 3048353fff, β 3023017fff, β 3009227fff, β 2976509fff, β 2974481fff, β 2957998fff, β 2952904fff, β 2910867fff, β¬2895741fff, β 2889257fff, π§2788582fff, β 2564363fff, β 2544740fff, β¬2502037fff, β 2406596fff, β 2166445fff, β 1997860fff, β 1905560fff, β 1889754fff, β 1845108fff, β 1799833fff, β 1787911fff, β 1786647fff, β 1758527fff, β 1752589fff, β¬1569064fff, β 1483802fff, β 1459837fff, β 1386377fff, β 1306694fff, β 1227201fff, β¬1201589fff, β¬1199331fff, β 1197447fff, β¬1122203fff, β 1106853fff, β 1048733fff, β¬1028264fff, β 962519ffff, β 772581ffff, β 671624ffff, β 627552ffff, β 550646ffff, β 519868ffff, β¬488882ffff, β 219237ffff, β 218871ffff.
55 more FIXED verdicts mention something left (often "8.6 keeps the old behaviour", a test or a man page still to fix, or fixed only on main); read the row before closing: β³a127bf6415, β³8f5e7a2633, β¬248c105fcc, β¬e38dce74e2, β¬9c258a841a, β¬f23022e07a, β¬d34442777f, π’7e3f26c748, β 6390566ecd, β¬5294e6feca, β¬e39cb3f462, β¬b9ce8b73e4, β¬baf4387372, β¬83116f5e05, β¬56ab601b7d, β¬d3cf54139d, β¬6aea6a8e25, β¬46f801ea5a, β¬39f6304c2e, β¬1907b57bc4, β¬f63b3ab13d, β¬1211aceef2, β¬3606117fff, β¬3606119fff, β¬3598502fff, β¬3562482fff, π¬3545876fff, β¬3541726fff, β¬3540794fff, β¬3363556fff, β¬3156499fff, β¬2976497fff, β¬2924753fff, β¬2912880fff, β¬2869384fff, β¬2613599fff, β¬2490456fff, β¬2461756fff, β¬2114165fff, β¬2030670fff, β 1879220fff, β¬1826826fff, β¬1805794fff, β¬1617864fff, β¬1591407fff, β¬1470152fff, β¬1464890fff, β¬1274916fff, β¬1094682fff, β¬961646ffff, β¬959052ffff, β¬849514ffff, β¬833713ffff, β¬582506ffff, β¬219372ffff.
68 (Linux, the Unix VMs and the Windows VM): β¬bb9ca2fa95, β¬c057378986, β¬081338a2de, β¬718de2132f, β¬8798610883, β¬1f1b168626, β¬a35d210bfc, β¬c5348d22cf, β¬95061fc746, β¬a850726018, β¬60725611c9, β 016be131a2, β 00c62f6777, β¬2d2a321244, β¬2d34167e97, β¬0d3963254c, β¬93da2e42b9, β 58053c93b3, β¬538ba1e615, β¬32c5740a4d, β¬60c12e1499, β 40f315bc23, β¬f8e4918f79, β¬714db57d20, β¬6c49da8a19, β¬3613497fff, β¬3584573fff, β¬3561500fff, β 3544685fff, β¬3400826fff, β¬3104471fff, β¬3103740fff, β¬3103656fff, β 3006571fff, β¬3002022fff, β¬2966493fff, β 2953593fff, β¬2912794fff, β¬2896758fff, β¬2815500fff, β¬2750491fff, β¬2666369fff, β¬2035893fff, β¬1963074fff, β¬1958930fff, β¬1906935fff, β¬1904907fff, β¬1840211fff, β¬1829708fff, β¬1811495fff, β¬1802202fff, β¬1771754fff, β¬1752124fff, β¬1745928fff, β¬1706593fff, β¬1675258fff, β¬1593707fff, β 1567838fff, β¬1502071fff, β¬1080650fff, β¬821499ffff, β¬803370ffff, β¬717848ffff, β¬708166ffff, β¬636161ffff, β¬576158ffff, β¬502022ffff, β¬219307ffff.
bug-β³554117edde (β³554117edde, β¬2392973fff), bug-β³723a2f4ac3 / sebres-bug-β³723a2f4ac3, br-β¬ebc39f14d7-oo-no-trace 495ffc0324 (β¬ebc39f14d7), aku-tkt-π§6141c15186 (π§6141c15186), bug-3485833 (β¬3485833fff: ensemble traces still 150β200Γ slower), bug-3418547 (β¬3418547fff, β¬3601284fff), bug-β¬58b96f6744 (one line), bug-3600058-td, bug-1224888 (also handles macOS), apn-winconsole-noreadahead (β¬1d06180006), windows-thread-join (β¬9b63fd201b), bug-β¬7bad415e3e-8.6 138b037189, fCmd-test-constraints 0049270a8b (300724b80c: 19 fCmd tests never run on main), e83297c2af (β¬391bc0fd2c), bug-β³8f5e7a2633 (Tcl side), bug-β e87bcf819f (fixed otherwise). On main only, not backported: 14e87701df (β¬255c116110, β 0e15cc8367), TIP 723 (β¬1805794fff = β¬f9764cd7a9 = β¬1464890fff), TIP 755 (β¬d3cf54139d).
env-stale-element; info exists ends array searches β β¬2889293fff, β¬994454ffff β combined prototype saved under both ticket ids, not committed; file delete -force read-only subdirs β β¬38a31dffdf, β¬b43efdfd61 β combined fix done, left uncommitted (unix-delete-deep-tree would need the same in DeleteTreeAt); file copy EPERM β π§1523045fff, π§731062ffff β branch copy-eperm-attrs; file copy into itself β π§82049f96f8, π§875545270d β branch copy-into-itself; .. after a symlink β π§3577801fff, π§3570244fff, π§3183016fff (+ test π§3099612fff) β branch normalize-dotdot-after-link (physical on Unix, lexical on Windows), β¬953284ffff (stale normalized-path cache) still separate; umask β π§cd609219f5, π§623585ffff β mkdir-no-umask-call; after overflow β π§96c3f3b47d, π§1802895fff β after-overflow-8-6, after-overflow-9-0 (main fixed by TIP 723); binary format β π§ce4483c2cb, π§2788582fff β binary-format-size-overflow; http keep-alive β π’05b158ed56, π’3764f4e81f β http-keepalive-reuse-closed; glob matchers β π’a4a7f2abd3 β glob-match-linear, π§3556218fff and π’219233ffff β glob-bracket-posix on top of it (POSIX bracket rules, main only; dgp asks for wider review).
append/lappend (β¬3057639fff, β¬3e30dc62e0, β¬309cfea3a2, β¬8014353dcb); clock scan of a year+month with the day from -base (β¬2837916fff, β¬b32fffae81); skipping unreadable directories in glob (β¬1146047fff prototype vs β¬3531271fff RFE).
(all ticketed now) β half-hour zones in tclGetDate.y (IST, NST, JT, CAST, CADT) lose 30 minutes (integer division) β e580d8372b, clock-half-hour-zones; interp-26.8: the parent's errorInfo leaks into a safe child through an alias β a63f5a4fed, safe-interp-no-parent-traceback; socket channel names contain a heap address visible to safe interps β d6c1d2f78e, channel-names-no-address; expr {eq(1)} with a user-defined eq fails since 8.5 β 1e66ba3d49, expr-operator-prefixed-funcs; -DUSE_THREAD_ALLOC=0 does not disable the threaded allocator (tclInt.h tests defined()) β 31294d48ef, thread-alloc-off-switch; async-4.3 never runs on Unix/MinGW since c0c61fa7cf (inverted constraint) β async-test-msvc-constraint (β
1056311fff, β
3544685fff); MEM_DEBUG's "previously disposed object" panic can no longer fire β π’7e3f26c748, memdebug-freed-marker; β
1943546fff is a Tk text bug β closed as a duplicate of Tk 18f35ed566.