tcltk-dev

Building Old Tcl/Tk Releases

Old sources don’t compile with current toolchains as-is. This page lists the flags and per-version fixes that build every release from 8.5.0 to 8.6.18 (and Tk 8.6.9.1 and 8.6.11.1) with gcc 15 on Linux and MSVC 2022 on Windows, plus a few notes for 8.4.

Layout used here

What Where
Linux installs ~/tcltk/<version>/bin/{tclsh,wish}8.X
Linux sources ~/tcltk/rel/<version>/{tcl,tk}
Windows installs %USERPROFILE%\rel\<version>\bin\{tclsh8Xt,wish8Xt}.exe
Windows build scripts %USERPROFILE%\rel\ (described below)

Checking that Tk really initialised: wish keeps running after “Application initialization failed”, so ask for a command that only exists once the Tk library loaded:

echo 'puts [package provide Tk]/[llength [info commands ::tk::AmpWidget]]; exit' > /tmp/tkcheck.tcl
DISPLAY=:99 timeout 20 ~/tcltk/8.5.4/bin/wish8.5 /tmp/tkcheck.tcl

8.5.4/1 means Tk initialised. Run it on Xvfb, never on :0. Pass a script file: piping into wish’s stdin can hang with a window open.

Getting the sources

Release tags are core-X-Y-Z, for example core-8-5-0 or core-8-6-9-1. Export them from the local repositories:

v=8.5.4; t=core-$(echo $v | tr . -)
mkdir -p ~/tcltk/rel/$v && cd ~/tcltk/rel/$v
fossil tarball $t tcl.tar.gz -R ~/tcltk/tcl.fossil --name tcl && tar xzf tcl.tar.gz
fossil tarball $t tk.tar.gz  -R ~/tcltk/tk.fossil  --name tk  && tar xzf tk.tar.gz

Linux (gcc 15)

gcc 15 defaults to C23, so old sources need an older standard and relaxed errors:

CC="gcc -std=gnu17 -fpermissive -U_FORTIFY_SOURCE -D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=0"
cd ~/tcltk/rel/$v/tcl/unix
./configure --prefix=$HOME/tcltk/$v CC="$CC" && make -j8 && make install
cd ~/tcltk/rel/$v/tk/unix
./configure --prefix=$HOME/tcltk/$v --with-tcl=$HOME/tcltk/rel/$v/tcl/unix CC="$CC" && make -j8 && make install

What each flag fixes:

Flag Without it
-std=gnu17 configure fails with “C compiler cannot create executables” (implicit int in its tests); tkMain.c clashes with glibc’s _Generic strrchr
-fpermissive the same old-C errors in the sources
-U_FORTIFY_SOURCE -D_FORTIFY_SOURCE=0 8.5.0 aborts at run time in a fortify check

Tk 8.5.0–8.5.3: cannot initialise on current X

wish stops with “no event type or button # or keysym” at bind Listbox <MouseWheel> (Bug 2010422, fixed in 8.5.4). The virtual event numbers collide with newer X event types. Backport the 8.5.4 fix:

Windows (MSVC 2022)

This uses MSVC 2022 Build Tools with Windows SDK 10.0.26100 (UCRT), and a few local helper scripts in %USERPROFILE%\rel:

Script Role
versions.txt releases to build, one per line (8.6.18 … 8.5.0, including 8.6.9.1 and 8.6.11.1)
driver.ps1 runs build-rel.cmd for every version, 4 in parallel; writes logs\ALL.done
build-rel.cmd V TCLTAG TKTAG builds and installs one release into rel\V; skips it if bin\tclsh*.exe and bin\wish*.exe exist
oldtcl-fixes.ps1, oldtk-fixes.ps1 apply the source fixes below with regexes; each one is a no-op on releases that don’t need it
wishcheck.ps1 + wishcheck.tcl start every wish*.exe and append V tk=… amp=… (or V TIMEOUT) to logs\wishcheck.txt

For a Tk-only release such as 8.6.9.1, driver.ps1 uses the Tcl tag of the first three parts (core-8-6-9) and the Tk tag of the full version (core-8-6-9-1). Logs go to logs\<V>.log, and the result (OK, FAILED, skipped) goes to logs\<V>.status.

Run the scripts in the interactive desktop session (see testing.md), so that wishcheck can open windows:

powershell -NoProfile -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -File %USERPROFILE%\rel\driver.ps1
:: or a single release:
%USERPROFILE%\rel\build-rel.cmd 8.6.10 core-8-6-10 core-8-6-10

What build-rel.cmd does for one release:

call vcvarsall.bat x64
fossil tarball -R %USERPROFILE%\tcltk\tcl.fossil --name tcl TCLTAG tcl.tgz   :: into rel\src\V
fossil tarball -R %USERPROFILE%\tcltk\tk.fossil  --name tk  TKTAG  tk.tgz
tar xzf ...;  oldtcl-fixes.ps1 rel\src\V\tcl
cd tcl\win
nmake -f makefile.vc MACHINE=AMD64 OPTS=threads INSTALLDIR=rel\V release
nmake -f makefile.vc MACHINE=AMD64 OPTS=threads INSTALLDIR=rel\V install
oldtk-fixes.ps1 rel\src\V\tk
cd ..\..\tk\win
nmake -f makefile.vc MACHINE=AMD64 OPTS=threads ^
      "OPTIMIZATIONS=-O2 -GS -GL -DOEMRESOURCE -DHAVE_VSSYM32_H -FIwinsock2.h" ^
      TCLDIR=rel\src\V\tcl INSTALLDIR=rel\V release install
:: on success rel\src\V is deleted

Run Tcl’s release and install as separate nmake calls. makefile.vc tests !if exist($(TCLSH)) when it parses the file, so in a single call the install step thinks tclsh is missing. Delete rel\V\bin to force a rebuild.

Per-version fixes

All of these are applied automatically except IX86=IX86 for Tk 8.4. 8.4 isn’t in versions.txt, so its builds were done by hand.

Version Problem Fix
Tk < 8.6.10 X11’s None macro breaks IMAGE_POLICY_ENTRY in winnt.h "OPTIMIZATIONS=-O2 -GS -GL -DOEMRESOURCE -DHAVE_VSSYM32_H -FIwinsock2.h" on the nmake line (build-rel.cmd passes it for every version)
Tk < 8.6.8 the SDK defines SEARCH_ALL rename the SEARCH_* enum in tkText.c to TK_TEXT_SEARCH_*
Tk 8.5 tmschema.h no longer exists ttkWinXPTheme.c: include vssym32.h
Tcl < 8.6.3 timezone is not declared tclWinTime.c: timezone → _timezone (edit the source; a -D breaks struct timeb)
Tcl ≤ 8.5.10 C2099 “initializer is not a constant” drop #define hypot _hypot from tclWinPort.h
Tcl ≤ 8.5.8 _stati64 mismatch; duplicate errno values tcl.h: typedef struct _stat64 Tcl_StatBuf; tclPosixStr.c: guard ENOLINK/ENOPROTOOPT against ESOCKTNOSUPPORT/EPFNOSUPPORT (as in 8.5.9)
Tk 8.4 the manifest says X86 → 0xC000007B at start add IX86=IX86 to the nmake line

Using old builds